Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
(OP)
A recent survey undertaken in South Africa has shown that of the practicing civil engineers in the country, 70% of civil engineers are over the age of 50.
I was wondering whether this was happening in other countries and possibly what the percentages are? It would appear that there is a shift more towards the finance and business side of things.
It is my opinion that the skills shortage starts directly at university level - I have seen students becoming disillusioned with engineering and moving into other fields - the reasons for this are varied.
Also, employers do not pay too much attention to a graduate engineer (especially consultancy firms) and look for the more experienced engineer - it is understandable in the work environment, but maybe needs to be looked at again. I realise that often one tends to spend quite a bit of time training and mentoring graduates, and then they leave for greener pastures - I look at it this way, at least when they do leave they go with good practical knowledge of the field as well as a lasting impression of the company they left.
What are others opinion in terms of skills shortages?
I was wondering whether this was happening in other countries and possibly what the percentages are? It would appear that there is a shift more towards the finance and business side of things.
It is my opinion that the skills shortage starts directly at university level - I have seen students becoming disillusioned with engineering and moving into other fields - the reasons for this are varied.
Also, employers do not pay too much attention to a graduate engineer (especially consultancy firms) and look for the more experienced engineer - it is understandable in the work environment, but maybe needs to be looked at again. I realise that often one tends to spend quite a bit of time training and mentoring graduates, and then they leave for greener pastures - I look at it this way, at least when they do leave they go with good practical knowledge of the field as well as a lasting impression of the company they left.
What are others opinion in terms of skills shortages?





RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
I agree with you that it would be more appropriate to take a look at the university level as it is the students there which are the "new blood" in the profession. Compare that with either an increase/no change/decrease in the anticipated available positions from an economic/job market standpoint and you would in my opinion have a much better picture.
Every employer is unique in evaluating their staffing needs. If they have a suitable "blend" of junior to senior level positions, they may be less likely to hire a recent graduate. A company with a greater number of seniors might look to bring a graduate in so that they can be trained and fill an anticipated retirement. From a consultancy standpoint, I would likely think that graduates would have difficulty. A consultancy firm would have a tough sell to a client with offering them someone with little experience, even in an "apprenticeship" role. Rightly or wrongly, it would be a matter of perceived confidence in the work results.
Regards,
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
I happen to be in this group and have a pretty good idea why the shortage.
When I started at University of Idaho computers, software and the internet were really starting to hit their stride with respect to growth in the industry. Many of the students that may have been civil/geotechnical engineers changed their majors to electrical engineering, software engineering, computer science and other computer related fields.
This has left a severe shortage of civil/geotech engineers within that window of time. That window follows the career paths of those that graduated in civil/geotech.
We've got plenty of entry level folks, not nearly enough mid level folks, and are just ok (could use 1 or 2 more) senior level folks at our office. This shortage seems to have effected mining engineers, as well.
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
What is happening now is that many power companys are hiring non-power based electrical engineers, and haveing to mentor them in the power side of electrical engineering.
On the other hand we have seen many new job applicants from outside the US, which is difficult to verify there educational background. And there is a concern about the cultural differences which may irritate our customers (and owners).
Also there are shortages of technications, and linemen. Which I wonder if it is because of aging of population, no desire for those fields, more glamor of other fields, or other factors.
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
While they did not specifically say anything about the number of expected new employment or age statistics to indicate retirement, I get the impression that there will be increased demand for civil engineers, but not a severe shortage. I suspect that wages/training will not increase, but those in that field can feel pretty safe and not be too worried about being "down-sized."
-- MechEng2005
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
As to the demographic shift, aging population due to retirement of the "baby boom"- even if they all retire at 65 (which they won't, since mandatory retirement rules and laws are quietly being removed/repealed), the peak of the North American baby boom won't be retiring for another 10 years, and some of the peak population years won't hit retirement age for another twenty years. The leading edge of the baby boom is just hitting retirement age. Panic at the entry level appears premature by at least a decade.
This is the same old business lobby-fed, media driven shortage hysteria that this profession has seen regularly every five to ten years from the day I began my education as an engineer until today. Every five years there's a reported shortage of some sub-discipline or another, or a new buzzword which will revolutionize industry and create a labour vacuum etc. It's hype intended to swing the supply taps open. Unfortunately when the inevitable bust comes, nobody will be there to shut the taps off again. Our inability to maintain any control on the supply side has been the reason engineers' salaries have slipped in relation to those of just about any other regulated profession over the past fifty years. It's also the reason we train and permit the immigration of vastly more engineers than the labour market could need in Canada.
Please let's see an ACTUAL shortage of engineers for a few years- maybe we can gain some of the ground back that we collectively lost relative to the doctors, lawyers, accountants and even scientists etc.
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
One reason why there may be a shortage of Civil Engineers is because the general population has no clue what a Civil Engineer. Everytime I tell someone that I am a Civil Engineer, they get a very blank and confused look on their face and nod their head. May be 1 of 10 will actually have an idea what we do. The rest of the engineering professions have descriptive titles. I.E. structural, chemical, electrical, petroleum, and etc. That tell what kind of work you do.
If people do not know what we do, how would someone know to look at that profession for a future career. Everything we do is buried underground. If we design a pond, the home owners think it was a water amenity designed by the landscape archtects. My old roommate confirmed this, and he has an engineering degree. We were driving around Minneapolis, I pointed to some dry detention basins, and told him that I design them. He thought they were just landscaped areas.
The comment, about Civil Engineers not being a sexy, is basically true. But I think that applies to engineering as a whole. When was the last time an engineer was front and center of a project, when something did not fail. Doesn't happen too often. Engineers are like make-up artist. The movie stars get all the glory(like architects, and developers), but the make-up artist makes them look good. Like engineers make things work.
Salaries are definately a reason for fewer Civil Engineers. Who wants to work in a career with a lower starting salary, almost immediately having large responsibilities, and you do not get any glory? Sometimes, I ask myself the samething everyday. Why did I not go to business school, have a very good potential for a 6 figure salary, with little responsibility, and the ability to pass off my mistakes.
sorry, this turned into a little bit of a rant, but it kind of shows
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Whenever I have used the term civil engineer, I am told no engineers are civil, so maybe blank looks aren't so bad.
In my case there is a definate lack of civil engineers (including structural). But the driving factors here are the economy, ongoing seismic upgrading and some major pieces of infrastucture reaching the end of thier design/usable lives.
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Just as an aside, I'm a Civil Engineer (B.Eng Civil, Concentration Management), but have worked as a Structural Engineer since before I graduated... I can't think of myself as anything else anymore. I certainly don't consider myself merely a "Civil" anymore than an Aeronautical would.
Cheers,
YS
B.Eng (Carleton)
Working in New Zealand, thinking of my snow covered home...
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Don Phillips
http://worthingtonengineering.com
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Had I understood from the beginning the full breadth of what civil engineers really do, and then stuck around the extra year for the M.Eng at my school, I'd have 17 years' experience now, rather than 9.
Hg
Eng-Tips policies: FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
I understand the reasons why companies dont spend the money training (which by the way seems a common isssue in US,UK and Aust) in the end it is self defeating as it ends up with a shortage of skilled intermediate engineers.
I think the problem is that these places are often reluctant to give decent increases often giving a nominal increasse that barely keeps up with salary. It is a career and as such you salary is expected to increase in real terms with experience. Good firms should spend the time making sure that their salaries are competitive so that they keep their employees.
RE: Civil/Geotechnical Engineering Skills Shortages
Sadly, it doesn't work that way. The best way to improve everyone's performance is for everybody to share knowledge and so improve the average productivity of the work team.
But if you do that then the less experienced people will improve more than the more experienced people, so they will get better pay rises.
So the logical thing to do for the experienced people is to make sure that they do not educate the kids, so that they continue to outperform them.
The organisation then reacts by making sure that the only substantial pay rises occur by promotion into management. Therefore the more experienced people will sacrifice the short term advantage of retaining private knowledge, in the hope of being recognised as a team player, and hence management material.
And that is why your boss is paid far more than you for doing less work.
Here endeth the lesson.
Cheers
Greg Locock
SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.