×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

MV Grounding Bank?
3

MV Grounding Bank?

MV Grounding Bank?

(OP)
Working on a project were the utility company has requested a grounding bank be connected to the primary of their 12KV delta-wye transformer used as a generator step up for (3) 480V landfill gas generators.  It will be located outdoors on a pad with the utility transformer and wired to the generator protection equipment.  Can anyone reccomend a manufacturer who makes this type of equipment.  Is grounding bank the correct terminology?  Google searches come up empty.   

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

They are probably talking about a grounding transformer to provide a ground source on the ungrounded 12 kV delta.  

Historically, this has been done using zig-zag grounding transformer, but can also be done with a small wye-delta transformer.  

Google up "grounding transformer" and see what turns up.   

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

deedo1124,
You say on primary of stepup trafo, that makes it 480V terminals of the trafo. Generator step-up transformers have delta on generator side (generally speaking) and that makes it on 480V side in your case.
If so, where is the need for artificial grounding - 12kV is Star with neutral point available and on 480V side, generator star point can provide grounding!!

May be you would like to clarify.   

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Primary and secondary often get confused with GSUs. Do they want the ground on the 480 side or the 12kV side? Do they want a solid ground or a high resistance ground? Are they concerned with current limiting impedance or the ground grid and/or electrodes?

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

(OP)
The grounding bank is for the 12Kv delta side of the transformer.  The intent is to keep the generators from contributing to a fault on the utility side of the transformer.  Can anyone reccomend a vendor for this type of equipment?

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

2
Any transformer with a 12kV grounded wye and a delta winding will work.  Delta winding voltage doesn't matter as it won't be connected to anything.  Transformer needs to be sized such that it won't be damaged while it feeds a ground fault on the 12kV system.  That's a calculation of current vs. time and is highly dependent on the specific installation conditions.  As for recommended vendor I'd go with who ever you normally buy your transformers from.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Hi David.
I suspect that the OP is looking for a high resistance/impedance  neutral grounding device. I suspect that the transformer is 480 V delta and 12kV wye. In this case do we have to be concerned with high side ground fault current through the transformer? The GSU may be existing and just need a grounding resistor.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

My guess, particularly in light of "12Kv delta" is that we are dealing with a site that takes service at 12kV and has their own (or even utility owned) 12kV Δ-480Y/277V transformers and that the generators are connected solidly grounded to the 480V system.  The utility, quite correctly, is looking for the 12kV system to remain effectively grounded in that interval between when the utility substation breaker opens and the generators are disconnected from the utility system.  It is quite frankly a very expensive solution to very nasty situation that might exist for less than a minute over the entire life of the site.  But so be it.  I wouldn't allow anything less on our system.

A far better solution would be to connect the generators to their own transformers, Δ on the generator side and grounded wye on the 12kV side.  Now they're not looking at a grounding transformer that is unneeded almost all the time.  But when it is needed it better be there or there will be all sorts of trouble.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Thanks David. That makes sense to me.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

davidbeach

Can you explain the situation in your last post further.  Do you mean between the time when the utility breaker opens and the generators are connected to the system.  With utility and generators wouldn't one be closing as the other opened?

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

I think the assumption was that the generator was running in parallel with the utility and both breakers are normally closed in this situation.  

 

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

The utility has a grounded system. In the event of an event opening the utility breaker on the line that services the generator, the line will be fed from the generator momentarily and at this point the line wil be ungrounded. The utility will require a grounded system for the generator so that at no time will it be possible for the line to be energized but ungrounded. A 480V delta by 12kV wye transformer may be the simplest solution.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Yep, I was assuming parallel operation, otherwise the utility wouldn't be requiring the grounding bank.  dpc & waross have filled in a lot of the details.  What wasn't mentioned is that the utility circuit is likely to have many line-neutral/ground connected loads and arresters.  When there is a ground fault on the line and no ground source - utility breaker is open and generators are supplying voltage through a delta winding - the voltage to ground of the unfaulted phases will approach nominal phase-phase voltage.  The overvoltage of up to 1.7 per unit will cause significant damage and must be prevented; therefore the requirement for the grounding bank.  I've required the same.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?


Could somebody please post a single line for this arrangment.  I think I am understanding everything but having a hard time visualizing it.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

See if the utility can replace the existing transfomrer with a Y-gnd Y-gnd transformer.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

deedo1124,

How big are your generators?
Is it necessary to parallel the generators with the grid?

If the generators are small compared to the 12kV source MVA of the utility, the, You should be able to convince the utility that the contribution (for 12kV system earth faults) from the generators is not much and seek waiver from the requirement of providing grounding trafo at 12kV.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

raghun, it will never happen, at least not if my suppositions about configuration are correct.  The problem is the voltage shift on a ground fault on a less than effectively grounded system.  That ground shift poses an unacceptable risk to the utility system and to its other customers.

Without the grounding transformers the fault contribution by the generators, no matter the size, will be approximately zero and that is the problem.  The grounding bank is necessary so that there will be ground fault current and the voltage will be stabilized.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

davidbeach,

I agree with you that the ground fault contribution is zero. With grounding transformer, the contribution from generators to the ground faults in the utility power system can be ensured. That is one part.

I am looking at a case when the utility fault level is large enough even without considering the contribution from these generators. If true, this would save the bother of retrofitting the grounding transformer.

The over voltages in 12kV system is not an issue here, I hope. The utility system must have 12kV neutral grounded at the source end.

Hope I could clarify.  

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Even though the system may be large in relation to the generator, the distribution feeder to the generator may not be large in relation to the generator. In the event that the feeder breaker at the utility substation opened, the line may be energized by the generator. If the generator installation could not provide a ground path, the feeder would see the damaging overvoltages. The generator does not presently have a neutral, that's the point. The system neutral will have no effect with the feeder breaker open.
The problem arises after the utility feeder breaker opens on a ground fault and the feeder is still supplied by the generator.
With no generator ground, the generator will not contribute to a ground fault and will not trip on a feeder ground fault.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Right, Bill, you've got it.  raghun, as Bill rightly states, with the substation breaker open it doesn't matter that the neutral is grounded at the substation and at every few poles, it has no reference to the generator.

The whole concern is during the few cycles between the utility substation breaker opening for a ground fault on the circuit and the generators separating from the circuit.  Even with transfer trip the generators will be on the circuit for 1-2 cycles longer than the substation.  That 1-2 cycles is long enough to do considerable damage.

We will never approve customer generation in parallel with a general use feeder circuit unless the generation always appears to be effectively grounded from the point of common coupling.

In the system of the OP, it would be much better for the generators to be behind a transformer that is grounded wye on the high side and delta (or even grounded wye) on the generator side.

I'd hate to have to make the economic justification for a grounding transformer that is only needed during fault conditions.  But I will require that transformer without hesitation if that is the only way to ensure that the customer generation appears to be effectively grounded when seen from my circuit.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

(OP)
Gentlemen,

The utility is providing a 1500KVA 12KV delta to 480V Y pad mounted transformer.  They are not interested in supplying a different type.  There are 3 generators each rated at 480V 300KW.  Attached is a cut sheet of what we found for the potential ground fault sensing equipment. They want the ground fault equipment pad mounted.  Does any one have any suggestions for  alternative  ground fault sensing equipment.  I have only found this one vendor and the lead time is to long.  The other option is to mount the equipment on a pole but this may not meet their requirements as all other equipment is enclosed pad mounted type.  

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

You might well be better off taking service at primary, lower rates and all that, and then putting in a grounded wye-grounded wye transformer.  In that case you wouldn't need a separate grounding bank as the issue it solves won't be present.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

I agree with davidbeach. grounded wye, grounded wye.
Avoid a grounded wye primary/delta secondary(480). This connection may overload your transformers and will back feed full voltage to a single open primary phase. (Subject to impedance drops).

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

(OP)
One Last time,

The generators are located at a muncipal landfil.  The utility company is providing a 1500KVA, 12Kv to 480V transformer delta primary (12Kv) wye secondary (480V) There is no negotiation this is what they are providing.  Utility will be buying the power from the company that is installing the generators and gas equipment at the site.  The utility company requires a ground fault sensing on the primary side to trip the generators and protect the grid.  This is being done with a "grid protection package" which is a Beckwith relay provided by the microturbine vendor.  The ground fault sensing will be done using three 12KV instrument class Pt's wired in a broken delta formation.  The utility refers to this as a "ground bank".  This equipment needs to be installed in a pad mount enclosure.  It will be wired to the loop bushings on the main transformer.  I have recieved a wealth of information but no one has adressed my main question.  Can any one recomend a vendor who would build this enclosure and provide the PT's and other equipment in a package?  The only one I have found thus far is Elliot Industries.  Design is approved equipment is purchased.  Only open item is the "ground bank".  If any one can reccomend a vendor I would appreciate it.

Thanks,

jd
 

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Oh, well that's certainly not what "ground bank" says to me, but that's their term.  I don't have any ideas about where to find what you need, does the utility have any suggestions?  So they aren't looking for you to provide a ground source for the line but simply a way to measure the voltage to detect a ground fault; simple enough.

Not the way I'd require it done, but that isn't my system.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

David, do I read this properly? To detect grounds don't the 12kV PTs have to be connected in grounded wye configuration?
If so, should they be full 12kV line to line rated PTs with the secondaries at 69 volts?
I can't understand how a ground would be detected unless the primary has a ground reference.
If the PT wye point is grounded, then when one phase is grounded the voltage will rise to 12kV on the healthy phases and the secondary voltage will rise to 120 volts.
Although the normal voltage across the PTs will be 6928 V, with a grounded phase this will rise to 12 kV and would saturate and destroy 6928 V PTs.
.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

The VTs could be grounded wye-grounded wye or they could be grounded wye-broken delta.  I'm not familiar with the Beckwith relay listed; if it has four voltage inputs then three will be used on the 480V system and the one remaining will be connected to the broken delta and will measure 3V0 from the 12kV system.  Remember, broken delta is three windings, unlike open delta which is two windings, and sums the three voltages to produce 3V0.

On a system that could become ungrounded, you are absolutely correct that the VT primary voltage needs to be the line-line voltage.  This scheme has been regularly used on grounded systems as a polarizing source for directional relays and in that case the VTs can be line-neutral rated as the voltage shifts are not as severe - much more a loss of voltage on the faulted phase than a voltage rise on the unfaulted.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

Malton, Kuhlman, Shallbetter, Maysteel can all construct the metering/relaying enclosure - outdoor, padmounted, etc.  As other's mentioned - the use of the term "ground bank" for a set of PT's providing ground fault sensing for the case when the utility and its ground source are isolated from their feeder and the landfill generators are backfeeding the fault is not a new concept.  There are several ways to handle it.  

I'd start the mfg. list in the reverse of the order listed if time is the primary driver for the installation.

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

deedo,

try not to get too stroppy about people not answering your question, when you yourself did not explain until your 5th post, what you actually wanted.

the line of thought that was explained throughout this thread was completely valid with the limited, if somewhat misleading information that you supplied.

in your first post you asked the question "grounding bank the correct terminology?  Google searches come up empty.".  Maybe this should have triggered you to explain up front what you wanted in a bit more detail.

It took 9 days to work out what you asked, and one day to answer the question.  I think that the contributors deserve a little more than attitude mister "One Last time,"

ausphil
    

RE: MV Grounding Bank?

(OP)
Thanks to all for posting and sharing your knowledge on the subject.

I am in the process of getting competetive quotes for a custom pad mounted unit. In addition to the quote from Elliot Industries, Maysteel and Power Design Inc. have previously built similar units and are quoting their solution.  

Your help has been invaluable.

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources