×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Mini torque gage
9

Mini torque gage

Mini torque gage

(OP)
I need to find or make a mini torque meter or gage. This will be used to measure the reaction torque of tiny motors driving propellers and ducted fans. Say 10-20 watts output at 10000-20000 rpm.

Very little space is available. About one inch diameter by one inch long to fir inside the fan tailcone. Smaller is better so as to avoid restricting cooling air flow past the motor.

RE: Mini torque gage

is this an electric fan ? ... why not measure the electric pwoer going into the fan and the fan shaft rpm ?

RE: Mini torque gage

(OP)
rb1957:  This is a model ducted fan for propulsion. Testing will be done in a miniature wind tunnel. Measuring the electricals will not account for losses. I need to measure input volts, amperes, rpm, torque, thrust, air density, air velocity. The one that eludes me is torque. My objective is to improve the fan design, including outlet guide vanes, inlet configuration, exhaust cone diameter, blade configuration in general.

But thanks for the suggestion.  

RE: Mini torque gage

but then measuring the torque probably won't tell you that either.  i think you're intersted in the real work done by the fan, ie the change in airspeed across the fan.

or else you can say that with a smaller fan (less electrical power input) you're accomplishing the same cooling effect (and so are more efficient).

RE: Mini torque gage

I suppose mounting it in a cradle and letting the body rotate and be reacted by a moment arm (a dyno) would bring too much mechanical hardware into the airstream?

Probably not enough room to mount any sort of standard torque/load cell.  Strain gaging the shaft isn't too hard but getting the signal out into the stationary world is tough.  Any room for a rotary transformer or telemetry unit?

Something I've wondered about is using two encoders mounted some distance apart on the shaft.  The torque would twist the shaft and change the relative phase between the two encoders.  Again, probably a custom unit.

RE: Mini torque gage

Maybe you could measure the reaction forces on the motor mount.  You could calibrate the output with known torque inputs.

RE: Mini torque gage

Potentially very cheap way of doing it:  

1) Mount the fan on a couple of thin wires -- My first guess would be about half the size of a coat hanger.  These will be your torque reaction springs.  
2) Make sure that both ends of the wires are FIRMLY ATTACHED, i.e., one end is firmly attached to the motor and one end is firmly attached to the base.  
3) Securely mount a very small mirror on the side of the motor.  
4) Securely mount a laser pointer at some point off of the motor and aim the laser at the mirror.  
5) Mark the point on the wall where the laser reflects at rest.  

This can potentially be EXTREMELY accurate, but your problem may be calibrating it.  

Good luck.  

Historical side note: This is one of the ways that the gravitational constant was originally verified to exist between all objects.  A barbell-shaped mass hanging off of a long string in a vacuum chamber had a small mirror affixed to the bar.  A change in movement of the reflected point of light of a few millimeters at a distance of a hundred feet away was enough to measure the gravitational pull of an orange on a marble.  

-T
 

Engineering is not the science behind building.  It is the science behind not building.   

RE: Mini torque gage

The laser pointer and mirror is a nice idea.

For a small motor, instead of wire 'leaf springs', I'd try a piece of surgical tubing slipped over the motor and a fixed stub of similar diameter, say a diameter or two away.  Make the tubing longer to get a lower spring rate.  Secure with wrapped wire or ty-raps.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Mini torque gage

(OP)
Thanks guys!

Cory Pad: All way too huge!

BobM3: I cannot measure torque of a rotating shaft. I nust use reaction torque. Shaft is .094 inch diameter.

sreid: These strain gags offer some hope. I will study further.


Engineer Tex: The difficulty is that the mirror is inside the motor shroud AND the fan duct AND the wund tunnel wall. All this should destroy any pretense of accuracy.

Mike Halloran: Surgical tubing slipped over the motor would totally block cooling air.

RE: Mini torque gage

You need to scroll down - the miniature one is around the size you need.

RE: Mini torque gage

The presence of multiple windows does not affect the accuracy of the laser galvanometer at all.  Clean the windows once in a while so the scatter doesn't mess up your photography.

You can eliminate half the windows by placing the mirror on the back of the motor at 45 deg to its axis, and the laser in the tailcone, right on the motor axis.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Mini torque gage

(OP)
Mike

CoryPad: I looked at the smallest one. Still too big.

MikeHalloran: Why does multiple windows not distort? I would need to contrive transparent parts of a 1.12 inch diameter motor shroud, a 2.50 fan shroud. The wind tunnel wall will be transparent anyway.

Laser being read from straight aft would be read through the rotating wind tunnel fan. Not good.

I have looked at a conceptually simple unit using a hairspring to restrain motor rotation and a simple pointer mounted on it reading against a scale on the housing. This can be read looking past te front edge of the fan housing through the wind tunnel duct window about 45 degrees forward. Might work.    














 

RE: Mini torque gage

When you say that electrical measurement will not account for losses, what do you mean?  Are you talking about internal mechanical (bearing/windage) losses in the motor and/or electrical losses?

If so, the latter can be accounted for.  I think mechanical losses probably could be too.  If you know the motor's absorbed power at speed/no load, then doesn't that equal electrical + mechanical losses, and won't mechanical losses remain the same regardless of load?

I dunno, but I'd look into calibrating the motor.

RE: Mini torque gage

The laser is behind the motor.  The mirror, attached to the motor, bends the laser beam 90 degrees, so it points RADIALLY away from the motor.  You read the angular deflection by measuring the movement of the laser spot on the far wall.  "Far" can be almost arbitrarily large.

 

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Mini torque gage

I Like Martensyste's idea - calibrate the motor elsewhere and then just monitor volts and amps (and preferably speed)in the wind tunnel.

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Mini torque gage

Just a thought springing from others ideas.  Wind tunnels usually have highly accurate aerodynamic force balances to measure lift, drag, etc.  I would be surprised if the balance can't be configured to measure a rotation torque due to, say, aleron torque.  This measurement would be no different than the motor reaction torque.

RE: Mini torque gage

(OP)
I'm the guy who must build the wind tunnel!  

RE: Mini torque gage

(OP)
ereid: Most interesting! Thanks.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources