×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
I am designing a steel staircase tower 4m x 6m in plan area and 63m in height, divided into 2.4m high flights. The following are the details of the structure
---- At each landing level, there are 4 steel beams all around.
---- The steel staircase tower is supported on 4 pedestals.
---- I have used k brace at all elevations in both directions.
---- Basic wind speed is 50m/s.
---- I have applied wind load as per standard Indian codes.
---- I have divided the height of the structure into 4 groups as per wind pressure zones.
---- I have applied wind load on all beams, columns and bracings in each direction separately
---- I have used a shielding factor for farther frames
---- Dead load = 1.2KN/m2, Live load = 3 KN/m2

I am getting too much tension in the anchor bolts at the top of the pedestals. I know from previous project information that 8 bolts of 1.5 inches would be sufficient. But, my tension is way too much high.

Guys, I want your suggestions on how to reduce the wind load on the structure so that I can reduce the tension in the anchor bolts.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Surely the staircase structure accesses a building at each storey and can be stabilised off the building. I can imagine that you would get massive tensions of a 63m high tower with a plan width of 4m. If the structure is stabilised off the building then you will only need locating bolts.

Carl Bauer
www.bauerconsultbotswana.com

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Instead of assuming that your wind loading is incorrect, I would first check whether your "previous project information" is correct or not.  What uplift force are you getting at each leg?  Do you mean a total of 8-1.5" bolts (2 at each corner)?

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Use a higher grade anchor bolt.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
Thanks to all of you guys for your prompt suggestions on my problem. Here are my views:

---- Carlbauer, I started off using your assumption of stabilising off the building, but my lead has specifically asked my to design the stairway independently.

---- Hokie66, my uplift force is nearly 2200 KN for each pedestal. I have 3 bolts equally spaced along each side of the base plate, totalling 8 bolts for one pedestal.

---- csd72, no one has ever used more than 1.5" bolts for such structure. So, I want to be very sure that there is no other alternative before I increase the size of the bolts.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

I am saying a higher stress grade rather than size, you can get anchors up to 120ksi.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

I would expect a lot of uplift for a tower those dimensions but 2200kN sounds like too much. That is a base moment of 17600kNm for the whole tower about the short side giving an equivalent uniform load of 560kN over the height of the tower. That is 1.5kN/m2 of tower on the long side. That would be too much even for a solid clad tower. You may be adding too many wind loads in by double counting members.

The other question is, if it is independent there is going to be considerable sway at the top. How will you detail the link to the building it is serving such that it doesn't load it?

Carl Bauer
www.bauerconsultbotswana.com

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

If you have such high uplift, obviously you will need huge/heavy concrete footing to counter the overturning effect. Can you embed the columns directly into the footing?

Also, for wind case, does the code allow for overstress?

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

I recently designed a similar stair tower (similar size).

We used diagonals at every level and tied the tower to the building at its roof and let the vertical framing serve as trusses spanning between base and roof.

While you may be able to somehow bully your design to be strong enough, I doubt you will be able to design it to be adequatly stiff enough to avoid it banging against the building.

Just my 2 cents.  I'd connect it to the building - laterally only.

 

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

The shielding that is assumed is probably not effective for members more than 4 diameters/thickness behind the shielding member.  Try adding diagonals between the columns at the lower half of the staircase.  Thus the force is resisted by a 4 meter deep truss.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
Thanks to all of you once again for the valuable insights.

---- csd72, I appologize for misreading your post. Actually, the client has already specified the permissible tensile and shear capacities for bolts, thus fixing the grade.

---- carlbauer, your summary calculations were very helpful in getting the bigger picture. I checked the loads to make sure I did not apply them on duplicate members. To give you an idea of the magnitude of the wind loads, my wind load varies from bottom to top as below:

Columns: From 0.34 KN/m at bottom to 0.46 KN/m at top
Beams: From 0.68 KN/m at bottom to 0.93 KN/m at top
Bracings: From 0.27 KN/m at bottom to 0.37 KN/m at top

The above loads are applied at the windward frame, and shielding factor of 0.7 is used while applying them on leeward frames.

I have defined all the bracings as truss members, released moments at the ends of beams where they meet columns. Also, I have released the moments at the lower end of the steel column where it sits on top of the concrete pedestal.

The sway at top and link to the building was a very good observation. I really did not think of it at this point, but will think about it and let you know.

---- kslee1000, my steel columns rest on 600 mm square concrete pedestals (750 mm high). The pedestals are embedded into a huge mat foundation below. However, my problem is with designing the bolts for tension. The code does not seem to address the issue of overstress.

---- JAE, good to know that you have designed a similar structure. I have the following points:
: By diagonals, do you mean X bracing?
: Have you provided the X bracings in both East-west and North-South directions?
: Could you elaborate on "let the vertical framing serve as trusses spanning between base and roof". I mean, what special member specifications did you define in the software to achieve this, like defining truss members or releasing moments etc.




RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
---- civilperson, by "adding diagonals", do you suggest me to remove the K bracings and replace them with X bracings.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Model the vertical frames as trusses, connect the joints of beam/column with diagonal members which could be X-braces or simply full length diagonals, (receiving both tension and compression force).  Do not forget 30, 45, & 60 degree wind direction which has components in both axis with NO shielding.  Wind also has a vertical direction,(not all wind is horizontal), adding force to platforms and platform/stair supports.  (A minimum of 15 degrees off of horizontal is assumed in tall structures used in refineries).

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Echoing others, I really question try to cantilever a tower this tall off of the foundation without supporting it (laterally) back to what ever structure it is serving.

My guess is that in anything but the lightest breeze, the tower will sway so much people will feel uncomfortable using it.  

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Globally speaking, for free standing tower, I will get ride of the concrete pedestal, and bring the columns directly to the mat foundation with proper corrosion control measurements.
Or do as JAE suggested - analyze the tower as a truss spanning in between the building roof and its own base.
If the stair is to serve the building, it will be somehow connected together on the top. By proper detailing/design, you maybe able to live with the original anchor bolt pattern, or even less.     

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Chandan321,

My apologies - I went back and looked at the model and discovered that we used moment connections between all the beams and columns.

The attached jpg shows the model.  But the idea was the same - span from foundation to upper level, with the entire framework of 4 columns and beams working like a large vertical tube.

 

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

I did a quick hand check and an uplift of 2200kN per column sounds about right for the figures provided. Changing the bracing and beam to column connection detail will have little effect on that.
I agree with JAE that deflection (sway) will likely be a limiting requirement. Trying to cantilever a tower of these dimensions is a bad idea.
Perhaps you should print or email this thread to whoever gave you the instructions to design it this way.
 

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

If the stair tower is to serve a building, certainly connect it to the building as others suggested.  I thought from your OP that it may be an observation deck or similar.  I think you have the idea that the tower will sway if free-standing.  But that may not matter too much if it is a fire tower or something, as the users would not likely brave it in high winds, and if they did, they would be accustomed to the movement.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
Guys, thanks to all of you and your suggestions. Backed up with all your arguments, I talked to my lead and he agreed to take support from the adjacent structure at 2 points. With my revised model, I could reduce the tension in the bolts to around 500 KN, which is very reasonable. After reading all of your posts, I have a few questions:

---- civilperson, If I want to analyse the structure as a truss between the roof and the base, should I define all my columns, beams and bracings as truss members in my modeling software STAAD. Or, is there any other way to define moment releases. If so, which member ends should I release moments at.

---- JAE, thanks for sending the jpg file. What are the green symbols at the top of the structure.

---- slkjh345, kslee1000, dz and hokie66, thanks for your arguments which helped me take support from the adjacent structure. Now, the adjacent structure can only support the staircase in one direction only. Is it OK if I assume pin joints at the the points of support with the adjacent structure.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

You can provide direct connections in direction that the building can support, and provide diagonals to stabilize the stair tower in the other direction. The support can be treated as pin connection, or spring, depending the geometries and stiffness of the support/bracing members.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
Thanks kslee1000 for the suggestions.

---- If I want to do a conservative design for the stair tower, should I pin the supports with the adjacent structure.
---- A pin would mean that the stair tower would get resistance in the other direction also, which may not be fully correct. So, should I release translational degree of freedom along the non-supporting direction.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

If the direction (not supported by the building) is the LONG (strong) direction of the tower, you can try, maybe the results are tollerable, to release the support in that direction. Also, fix the tower base (moment connection) would be a big help.  

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Chandan321,

The green symbols are the RISA model boundary conditions (i.e. supports).  These occurred at the bottom of the model (at the footings) and near the top where the cross beam was connected into the main building.  With boundary condition reactions I could then check the existing building members to verify that they could adequately take the lateral forces from the tower into the building diaphragms.

 

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
Thanks kslee1000 and JAE for the help.

Thanks to all of you for your time and the valuable suggestions you have given in the past few days. Looks like my staircase tower can be reasonably designed, and the anchor bolts carry reasonable tension.

Will look forward to your help in future too.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Chandan,

Why can't the building support the stair tower in both directions?

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
hokie66, my main structure spans North-South longitudinally. My staircase tower stands adjacent to the south end of the main structure, with the flights running East-West. The landings are connnected to the main structure in the North-South direction. Thus I am planning to take support from the main structure in the North-South direction. Is there any way that you think I can take support in the East-West direction also?

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

I see.  I would probably do it your way, with that southern wall of the stair tower diagonally braced, but you could consider diagonal braces horizontally outside the landings on each end at the levels where you are bracing the tower north-south.  

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
hokie66, thanks for the suggestion of horizontal bracing. Do you think X bracing has any advantage over K bracing in these type of structures.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

X bracing loads the members with axial load. K bracing induces moments.  No superiority either way, just added calculations for combined stresses.  

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

(OP)
civilperson, thanks for the tip about bracings.

RE: How to manage too much wind load on staircase tower

Just to be clear about your bracing method, K bracing can mean different things to different people.  To me, K bracing goes from node to node, and the members are designed for tension and compression.  I call bracing which goes from node to beam chevron or vee bracing, depending on its orientation.  X bracing, well that is obvious, and can be either all tension or T-C.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources