×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

(OP)
I am trying to model a structure with steel rod x-bracing in RISA 3D but having some problems.  I have made the members tension only and made them weightless (density=0) (as recommended in the help manual).  When I run the analysis and show the deflection diagrams the rods look like bungee cords.  Can someone help me out?  Thanks

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

what do you mean by look like bungee cords?  Did you put the right material?

Never, but never question engineer's judgement

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

(OP)
They look like they are deflecting into infinity.  I have them entered as 36ksi steel.   

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

what are the forces in the rods and what size rods are you using?  If you are using small rods and have high axial forces, it could be distorting your deflected shape.   

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

(OP)
I am using 3/4" rods but I have increased the size to check if that was the problem and it does not seem to be.  It seems to be treating the rods as beams.  I don't have it assigned as a beam.  

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

I would look to units, units, units.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

(OP)
I am not exactly sure how units would be causing this problem.  I believe it is something I am missing in how I am assigning the members in RISA.  I figured someone would know something to do besides make them tension only members and weightless.  Thanks for everyone's input and please keep it coming.  

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

Is it both rods in the x that have this shape?  If it is only one of them, it might be the one that is trying to take compression (but obviously can't), and is showing its buckled shape.
Try clicking on the member and looking it's moment diagram.  If it is truly a tension-only member and the self weight is 0, then there should be zero moment.  I would look at this under the dead load only case (assuming there is no lateral dead load that would put any stress on the x-brace.
 

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

Only slightly off-topic: These types of problems come up from time to time, and I have only once had to completely restart a model from scratch, HOWEVER, these problems are important to remind us of the limitations of the software:  We must be certain that the answer is in the probably correct range, rather than just the possibly correct realm.

I would check the stability of the surrounding members as well; In some structural analysis packages if you have nearby columns deflecting in under some load combination the software will ignore your "tension only" member setting and show the element as buckling.  I would suggest trying adding a restraint at each side (one at a time) to see if this corrects the issue.

Good luck, and remember this problem when you review your next set of output sheets prior to desiging members from the results.

Cheers,

YS

B.Eng (Carleton)
Working in New Zealand, thinking of my snow covered home...

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

youngstructural beings up a good point.  

In both RISA programs, as with any matrix based solution to pinned and fixed structures, each and every joint must have at least one degree of freedom fixed in ordr to solve the joint forces.  otherwise the joint will spin in space, giving you infinite deflections, i.e., being unsolveable.

Check your member end pin/fixed window.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

Did you enter "-1" under Y GRAVITY for your DL case?  If so, delete that and enter the selfweight of the structure by hand.

DaveAtkins

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

(OP)
DaveAtkins,

That solved my problem and led me to the real reason for the deflection.  I created a "rod" material with 36ksi steel properties but made it weightless.  I messed up by  assigning my rod section set material as 36ksi steel instead of the weightless "rod" material I had created.  Thanks for everyone's assistance.  There are many opportunities to design junk with these programs if you are not very careful.       

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

McQSE -
I'm late to the table here, but you obviously found the flaw.

I did just want to point out the proper thing that you did in this issue -that is to always...always....look at the deflected shape of a new model, when you've run it for the first time.  Checking the deflections first, before diving into the forces and stresses, is the proper first step.

 

RE: Rod X-Bracing In RISA 3D

So it was an input error...

Yes, these programs solve the problem you tell them to solve. It's the engineer's job to make sure the correct problem is being solved.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources