Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
(OP)
Dear all ,
The technical specifications in my water project call for butterfly valves operating with manual hand wheel actuators, BUT valves shall have provision for electrical actuators . my concern is about the provision for electrical actuators ???? I need to know if all butterfly valves can be connected to electricl actuator or this is something optional and we need to ask the manufacturer for ,so as to manufacture the valve to match and to be compatible with electrical actuators ?
Any inputs regarding the future connection with electrical actuators and what things I should take care about and consider them , will be highly appreciated ?
Thanks
The technical specifications in my water project call for butterfly valves operating with manual hand wheel actuators, BUT valves shall have provision for electrical actuators . my concern is about the provision for electrical actuators ???? I need to know if all butterfly valves can be connected to electricl actuator or this is something optional and we need to ask the manufacturer for ,so as to manufacture the valve to match and to be compatible with electrical actuators ?
Any inputs regarding the future connection with electrical actuators and what things I should take care about and consider them , will be highly appreciated ?
Thanks





RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
Preggys answer is OK as long as you do not have to bind yourself economically or technically to what actuators added and mounted to the valves will actually cost, or bind yourself any description or limitations on what type of electrical actuators are to be used or interfacing cost or guarantee.
Be careful here. If you get involved in theese questions, you will actually have to go 'the whole way' dimensioning and select the correct actuator for each single valve.
Electrical actuator selection is a case for electrical actuator experts and will involve among other things a full access of the electrical data and control schematic for the valves. This is very often not ready in the early stages of a water project, when the valves have to be selected.
Actuators will vary in price and size according to torque, closing time, current and voltage, extra possible gearing can size actuators up or down according to brand of actuator, mechanical detailed adaption to available mechanical interface on valve must be controlled - (often different adaption plates, or bosses must be detailed). In addition special details for electrical requirements may add to cost of the actuator, like position givers included etc.
Closing time requirement will vary according to waterhammer prevention, type of valve (on/off, regulating, pipebursting protection etc..)
... se the traps?
I can ensure you this has cost some too eager bidders money!
Many more should have done like you, and asked some questions.
Also important: for water mains and electrical actuators note that double eccentric butterfly valves will give less torque requirement for same size compared to centric BFL.
Gear quality has a very wide range for both type of valves.
For selection and bidding both price/lifetime cost comparison should be an issue!
Lifetime expectance should be a part of the description both for valves, gears and actuators.
RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
RE: Butterfly valves with electrical actuator
1) Please ask a new question rather than posting at the end of someone elses.
2) Your question is too broad. You need to refine it as to what you really need (there are a LOT of websites out there). The material chosen for a valve depends on a large number of factors and you haven't provided any information to help anyone help you.
3) What steps have you taken to find the information yourself? (i.e., did you try a web search engine)?
Patricia Lougheed
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.