Micromanagement!
Micromanagement!
(OP)
All-
I am having a problem with one of my managers. He is an extremely knowledgeable engineer; however, he micromanages the department TREMENDOUSLY.
He is my boss' boss, and should not concern himself (in my opinion) with daily tolerance analyses, limits/fits calcs, etc. It is getting to the point where things are not shipping out because there is always a philosophical engineering argument to be had about a design. He also, for some reason, feels that if he did not create a specific design that there must be something wrong with it, and that he can do it better.
Am I crazy? I feel like my company should just hire monkeys that they can train to use CAD instead of hiring engineers.
Is there anything I can do to shield myself from some of his micromanagement? Should I look elsewhere for a job?
Any advice is greatly appreciated.
I am having a problem with one of my managers. He is an extremely knowledgeable engineer; however, he micromanages the department TREMENDOUSLY.
He is my boss' boss, and should not concern himself (in my opinion) with daily tolerance analyses, limits/fits calcs, etc. It is getting to the point where things are not shipping out because there is always a philosophical engineering argument to be had about a design. He also, for some reason, feels that if he did not create a specific design that there must be something wrong with it, and that he can do it better.
Am I crazy? I feel like my company should just hire monkeys that they can train to use CAD instead of hiring engineers.
Is there anything I can do to shield myself from some of his micromanagement? Should I look elsewhere for a job?
Any advice is greatly appreciated.
V





RE: Micromanagement!
Your bosses boss should not be coming to you on a regular basis. Rather your direct supervisor should be shielding you from such non-sense.
I would speak to your direct supervisor and ask for his guidance / opinion first.
RE: Micromanagement!
I'm jealous.
Seriously in this place our senior engineering management are the other end of the spectrum. I don't know about your site but most of the engineers here don't worry about these things and it causes issues.
As regard micromanagement, I'll be interested to see what others say. If you get on well with your direct boss talk to him as mechengdude says, however depending on politics (I assume you have politics like our site) this may not be a good idea.
Perhaps you could mention it to John if you bump into him in the corridor
KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...
RE: Micromanagement!
RE: Micromanagement!
There is one thing worse than an engineer micromanager. It is a non-engineer micromanager. Unfortunately, all sorts of people can look over your shoulder and conclude that they understand what you are doing to the point that they can take charge and make decisions. We all know what plates and screws and gears do. What could possibly go wrong?
Electronic and software designers have it easy. Even if they are trained to do the work, it is not worth the micromanager's trouble to figure out the awful gibberish on the computer screen.
I think the best argument against micromanagement by qualified professionals is that some decisions require analysis and careful thought. Four years of college and twenty years of experience is no substitute for having lived with the design and the drawing package for the past month. As the designer, you know what the part is attached to, and what your error budget is.
A fundamental problem with mechanical design, that non-designers do not understand, is that everything is attached to or affected by everything else. This is especially true if the assembly is to be small and light, and you are doing DFMA. Micromanagers usually focus on a detail somewhere, and if it is something you did a month ago, it is hard to remember the big picture issues you worried about at the time. This is a good way to cause mistakes.
If this manager wants to review design concepts, he should do it early in the design process while you are still flexible about changes.
Perhaps you should talk to your boss, and have a careful, diplomatic chat with the manager.
JHG
RE: Micromanagement!
The downside is that if you annoy him he can hurt your prospects. The good side is ...(fill in the dots)
Cheers
Greg Locock
SIG:Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
RE: Micromanagement!
Not that this helps your situation...
RE: Micromanagement!
That way when the real work needs to get done you can safely hide the little creatures in your draw where they will do the least amount of damage!
RE: Micromanagement!
RE: Micromanagement!
If he needs to direct the engineers technically, then:
> his hiring of your boss was a BAD decision
> the engineers need to either be fired or sent back to school
> the hiring of such bad engineers was due to HIS BAD management and his direct submanager's BAD management
Unfortunately, many technical people who become managers can't seem to get it through their thick skulls that the engineers they hired are either competent, in which case they should be allowed to do their job, or they're not, in which case they should be fired.
We used to have GM of a 5000 employee division going to technical presentations and arguing arcane technical points with the presenters. Naturally, he got his division stolen from him because he was too busy playing with technical things instead of minding the store.
That's one reason why I consider my current GM to be the best GM I've ever had in 27 yrs. He's a finance guy, but he's not one of those dorks that think that putting timers of copy machines is an effective means of saving money. Moreover, he keenly knows his limitations, and while he'll challenge his engineers, he accepts the basic concept that they were hired to engineering jobs and should be allowed to do so without interference. I just hope that he won't retire before I do...
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Micromanagement!
That's so ANNOYING.
If that's not enough... my boss' boss' boss (yes, that's right) doesn't seem to care about anything.
What a world...
As Rodney Dangerfield says, "No Regard! I get no regard!"
Keep the advice coming... I really appreciate it, all.
V
RE: Micromanagement!
"The status of Project X is that it is pending review by Mr. Y. If you would like a specific date when that task will be completed, please contact Mr. Y directly."
Professional, concise, factual.
RE: Micromanagement!
I think I'm just getting tired of thinking I'm done with a project when, all of a sudden, it needs to be reviewed by Mr. Y... even though we've had numerous design reviews on the project that he's been a part of.
V
RE: Micromanagement!
I am in a similar position. My Mr. Y always disagrees with me. He isn't even involved in the projects but he still makes me get approvals on the simplest things.
For example...Pretend I'm in a situation where I could pick either option A or option B, and say I pick option A. I then take my choice to Mr. Y and he will make me switch to option B. However, I have recently noticed that if I give it a week or so and go back and tell him I picked option B, he will have me switch it back to option A. I am certain he doesn't remember the initial conversation and he just considers the second conversation as another opportunity to prove how smart he is. Anyway, this new method has saved everyone a lot of time now that we no longer have to change our drawings, orders, etc.
Having said that, I do need his help for some aspects of our projects on occasion and I treat those times differently.
But the micromanagement drives me insane. What can you do though?
Other then look for a new job...
RE: Micromanagement!
RE: Micromanagement!
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Micromanagement!
I know that usually being a very good engineer makes you a bad manager (I know there are exceptions), but this is ridiculous.
The latest that he's disagreed with me on is a stack-up where he's convinced that I need to take into account that the vendor may not make the part correctly, to the print! WTF?
Sorry for the rants, I'm just frustrated.
Thank you for all your advice/comments. Keep 'em comin'.
V
RE: Micromanagement!
So he obviously doesn't get tolerance analysis then.
It's one thing someone butting in all the time if they're usually right (still annoying to some extent), but if he's frequently wrong or just arbitrary...
You could always start planning your schedule with a week for him to review it at the end and a week or two after that to make (or not) his requested changes. At least if people are expecting it up front it wont be a shock.
Can't you somehow get him distracted by the outsourcing issue, seems an easy target here at the moment?
KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...
RE: Micromanagement!
IRStuff's recommendations sounds good and is similar to tatics I have used in the past. Recently I have used a tatic where I chose not to speak during an entire meeting. I found even when asked direct questions, if I paused long enough, there were enough people in the meeting that liked to hear themselves talk enough that they would begin to "answer" their own question.
My point is that when dealing with poor managers, folks with self esteem or ego issues it is sometimes less painful when you just smile and laugh inside to yourself.
Good luck.
RE: Micromanagement!
He loves, neigh, ADORES hearing himself talk, so it shouldn't be too much of a problem to get him going.
I will start planning my schedule to include "Mr. Y's Review Time", and see how it pans out.
KENAT-- don't even get me started on the outsourcing...
I will let you all know how I fare in the coming weeks. Thanks very much for all your help, and if there are any other pearls of wisdom, please feel free...
V
RE: Micromanagement!
That way he'll be far to busy to interfere.
KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...
RE: Micromanagement!
Then, there are those that can't let go, and can't delegate, so they slave away, while their subordinates twiddle their collective thumbs.
TTFN
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies
RE: Micromanagement!
If all else fails, just do it his way, after all that's what you're paid for. Write down what kind of stuff he likes to see, and do it. And if he complains, you can always say, well, a while back I was working on this drawing, and you had me do this (then pull it up).
You'll be surprised how differently, different companies do things - even in the same industry. So a lot of times you just have to give in and do it the way boss said, even if it's against what you've leaned in last 30 years. It's his dime. As long as he takes the responsibility for it, you're good. Eventually as he realizes you're doing things his way, he'll leave you alone.
RE: Micromanagement!
1) get him an attractive new secretary. That should distract him for a while, and the consequent divorce proceedings for some while longer.
2) go ask if you can "represent the company" at a really good conference somewhere. Monte Carlo etc. Your industry will have at least one or two a month somewhere round the globe.
Now when you make your pitch, make sure that everything you say points toward not an engineer going, but a senior manager.
So long as you sell him on how important you think these conferences are, and so long as you emphasise the calibre of people there, he will agree the company should be represented but that it calls for a senior management representative... him.
Now, while he's somewhere else you can get on with your work.
JMW
www.ViscoAnalyser.com
RE: Micromanagement!
IRStuff, that's me. I nearly started a thread on how not to be a micromanager, maybe I will. I keep trying to let go but then it keeps coming and biting me in the a$$ later.
KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...
RE: Micromanagement!
Anyway, I am trying to say, this type of stuff is done everywhere and its a pain. Try not to let it get you down. You know you are doing a good job.
When Mr Boss Man take your work, write down when he took and what time and when someone ask you about it just let them know he is reviewing it and you are waiting for him to give it back. When you get it back you will give it to them. If you don't get it back just call that person and give them a heads up that you are still waiting. Like keeping a little log book. Trust me I know its an extra step but it might keep some sanity.
I ended up doing that and when eventually I wasn't the middle man anymore. My upper management people went directly to the people who held me up and my work ended up getting done faster because they pushed all those others who I waited on. I still do it today and my new job.
Hope this helps a little. Good luck!
Thank You
CNCMILL
RE: Micromanagement!
The thing is... He's right. Nobody uses paper anymore, and you can't really think in terms of scale when you're on a computer.
Then I feel lucky that working under a true engineer(60's), not some 30-40 something Wanna-be senior engineer.
RE: Micromanagement!
Secondly, it sounds like the micro managing boss may actually be trying to nurture and coach his staff. He may have been bitten by parts not being made to drawings in the past, and knows how to get around this. He may realise it will cost the company more to get the manufacturer to re-make the part than to adjust the drawing to allow for the manufacturer's mistakes.
RE: Micromanagement!
Handy design tip:
Draw, xerox and trace, or otherwise acquire some scale views of people and relevant body parts. Insert these on to your drawings as scale references. I insert my old AutoCAD 2D views onto my SolidWorks drawings. There are 3D models of such stuff for SolidWorks and other 3D CAD programs.
Your boss is right about the lack of scale drawings, but the problem is solvable. I hang E_sized drawings on my wall, and I keep my old scales from my drafting board days.
JHG
RE: Micromanagement!
The more skilled the engineer is in communicating his/her competency and knowledge of the whole picture, the more likely (s)he'll make the manager trust on him/her, then going back to the manager's desk.
I guess most of those folks just like to be in control, or having some bad experiences with bad engs. Often, some managers may be actually revealing a jealous, "wanna-be-engineer" behavior, or inner feelings of not being up to the task, while in charge of a skilled eng. team.
RE: Micromanagement!
You could communicate directly with BossOfBoss. If he feels he can come directly to YOU, why can't you go directly to HIM?
Forget the turf/territory issues, forget the "he's a manager, he should manage!" attitude, and all that other non-productive thinking. Perhaps you can (in a nice, human, diplomatic way) confront him on the issue and find out what's really going on in his head.
"Hey, um, Fred...I need to clear the air with you. When you come over and triple check my work, it makes me feel like...um...well, like you think I'm not capable of doing my job on my own. Is there a problem with what I'm doing? This kind of behavior is really starting to get me worried about your perception of my capabilities."
Don't mention "micromanager" because that's negatively judgemental, but it certainly is IMPLIED. Maybe the poor schmuck is so clueless that he doesn't realize what he's doing. If he's a demagogue incapable of delegation and no one on the planet can do it as well as he can, then absorb what you can from the organization and move on. That guy will kill the company.
TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
www.bluetechnik.com
RE: Micromanagement!
RE: Micromanagement!
Guess what I've done when invited to go work on that site?
I moved on and changed company...