×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

(OP)
Hi:

I have a small engineering company and am searching for stormwater modeling software.  I've been out of stormwater design for a while and used to use HEC-1, TR-20 and Intelisolve regularly.  

I am looking for a different solution now.  Anybody have any experiences with Carlson or Stormnet?  They seem to have some integration with older AutoCAD.  Maybe someone has other suggestions or experiences?

Important things that I would be looking for in a software would be good documentation (so I have some understanding about how the calculations are being performed), hydrology and hydraulics calculations based on established methods, integration with ACAD 2007 or earlier (to make data input easier), good reporting for regulatory review and acceptance by regulatory agencies.

Look forward to your comments.  Thanks

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

Information: Intelisolve has been acquired by Autodesk.  I do not know how well it is integrated with AutoCad but one would hope it is. I still use the older, standalone version of Hydrographs 2007 and Storm Sewers 2008. Both are pretty good, in my opinion, but have some bugs and annoyances. With the acquisition,O'm afraod, the formerly excellent support will probably disappear.

HydroCad works well for lots of things. Good documentation.

HEC-RAS is a good choice and is FREE.

Some people like SWMM,also FREE. I find it obscure but that may just be my lack of familiarity with it.

TR-20 and TR-55 should also be in your library as should the National Flood Frequency (NFF) program.

I also like SMADA;a poor man's version of SWMM.

There are many others so your choices may depend on what is accepted by regulators in your area.

good luck
     

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

HydroCAD is the best in my book.  Not only does it offer great functionality and is easy to use, it is based on TR-20 and TR-55.  This is essential for permitting around here.  The documentation and technical support is outstanding as well.

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

(OP)
Thanks for the information.  I downloaded the demonstration HydroCAD and used it for a few simple analysis.  For a lot of projects, this may be all the software that's needed.

I tried to get Intelisolve, but, as it was pointed out, it was swallowed up by Autodesk and you can only get it through updating the ACAD software through its subscription service.  I'm not comfortable with Autodesk's new marketing process.  It feels almost like an protection racket.

Any one having any experience with the MS4 permitting process and using stormwater modeling to make a retrofit plan?  This type of modeling is beyond HydroCAD and Intelisolve.

Thanks

 

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

ClarkBart,

I am not familiar with requirements of MS4 permitting, yet I get the impression you need to model catchbasin/stormdrain systems by this reference.

If this is the case, I would definately check out Carlson.  I used to use Stormcad, but it's cost is ridiculous for size models we need.  The latest Carlson package (2009) is definately meeting our needs.

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

TerryScan - You'll be interested to know that Carslon is developing linkages to HydroCAD that will allow you to automatically extract watershed data for use in a HydroCAD model.  This will make Carlson + HydroCAD a powerful set of tools covering a wide range of H&H applications.

For details please see www.hydrocad.net/carlson.htm
 

Peter Smart
HydroCAD Software
www.hydrocad.net
 

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

Hydrasolve is the best in my book for being user friendly and creating great reports.  

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

I had been using HydroCAD previously, but now I'm being asked with my new firm to recommend whether we stay w/ Hydraflow - that they had been using - or switch to HydroCAD.  Hydraflow is now part of the Civil 3D software that we are using.  However, there is virtually no tech. support.

Also, when running both programs to compare, I'm getting 2 times the pond size required by Hyrdaflow than HydroCAD requires.  Maybe there is something wrong in the inputs.  I am using the free sampler from HydroCAD right now.

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

stormnet does not have full integration yet with autocad, however pricewise it is somewhat cheaper than stormcad and more full featured from the hydrology side.  Neither one can stand up to the ability of HEC1 for pure hydrology.

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

What about HYDROCAD VS. HYDRAFLOW???

I really like HydroCAD's modeling (more user friendly) as well as the look of the print outs.

Also, I just don't understand why the pond size required by the two programs would be off by a factor of two!

RE: Stormwater Modeling Software Opinions

SCEngr1:  Pond sizing will depend on virtualy every aspect of the model.  Are the pond inflows the same?  Be sure to check the volume as well as the peak flow.  If the inflow matches, compare the stage-storage and stage-discharge curves.  Keep looking and you'll find a difference somewhere.

If you have further questions, please start a new thread in the HydroCAD forum so this thread can stay on-topic.


 

Peter Smart
HydroCAD Software
www.hydrocad.net
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources