×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Interesting power problem
2

Interesting power problem

Interesting power problem

(OP)
I have an interesting question if any one can help.
2 identical compressor motors with the following data.
600HP, 2300V, 390RPM, 152FLA
Both were run uncoupled to check the amps.

One being fed from Delta-Wye transformer with the following data
12470V-2400Y/1383
2000/2240(OA) KVA, %Imp 5.24, transformer tap is set at 12160V. The motor running amps are approximately 104A on all three phases.

Second Transformer is Delta-Delta 13200-2400V, 1500KVA, %Imp 5.43, Transformer tap is set at 12540V. The running amps recorded are approximately 65A on all three phases.

Both transformers are ungrounded, The system voltage is 12470V. In the past motors were exchanged but the amps stayed with the transformer, in other words on Delta-Wye configuration motor pulls more amps.
Any suggestion? I thought power requirement will be the same in any case and the motors will run identical on both systems.

RE: Interesting power problem

Strange.  Was the 2400V bus voltage measured?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Yes it is measured and is 2400V

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Although paperwork and nameplate proving to be identical motor. Can they be wound differently causing this issue?

RE: Interesting power problem

Delta-Delta or Delta wye connected transformer makes no difference to the motor if the voltage and installation are correct.
But,how many leads does the motor have? If the motor has more than three leads than each motor may have been wired incorrectly when it was put on the first transformer.
The no load amps on the first transformer seem too high even for a low speed motor. The amps on the second seem about correct.   

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Thanks alot, I am trying to get the original rewound reports (15 years old issue). There seems to be only three leads at the packerd head coming out from the motor casing. Quite possible one of them is wound wrong. What bugs me is the fact I was told that motors are switched around in the past and high amp issue seems to stay with the Delta-Wye transformer. If motor is wired wrong then high ampere issue will move as the motor is moved too?

RE: Interesting power problem

Quote:

If motor is wired wrong then high ampere issue will move as the motor is moved too?
Yes.  Miswound motor is not consistent with your original problem description (behavior stayed with the transformer)

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Interesting power problem

With a system voltage of 12470 V;
"transformer tap is set at 12160V." This should supply 2461 V.
"Transformer tap is set at 12540V." This should supply 2387 V.
This would be the cause of your current discrepancies.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

RE: Interesting power problem

Although unrelated, I would consider high resistance grounding the transformers versus ungrounded.

RE: Interesting power problem

Typically, the no-load current of motors varies from 20% for 2-pole machines to 60% for 20-pole ones. Thus, 104A no-load current, which comes to 68% of 152A (FLC) seems possible for a 390RPM motor.
Could it be that the 65A is being measured is not the line current but phase curren (inside the delta), in which a case the current measured would approximately be (104/Sqrt3)A.
I can't think of any other explanation, the location of CTs may be holding the key.  

RE: Interesting power problem

Waross or raghun have the most plausible answers. Either one could be the problem.

If raghun is right then check that your overload is actually set-up correctly.
 

RE: Interesting power problem

"Could it be that the 65A is being measured is not the line current but phase curren (inside the delta), in which a case the current measured would approximately be (104/Sqrt3)A"

That was my 1st thought too, seems odd that the 2 currents are sqrt3 apart.

RE: Interesting power problem

If there are only three leads coming out of the motor than how the motor is wound makes no difference since you can't hook it up wrong.
 Have you looked at the CT ratio of the first transformer and compared it to the meter scale.  I would try primary current injection on the CT's to verify the installation.  

RE: Interesting power problem

I would like to respectfully disagree with waross's answer on this one.

The ratio of Voltages and currents should be the same since power is constant, where as according to his explaination 2461/2387 = 1.03 and 104/65 = 1.6

Sincerely

Zazmat

RE: Interesting power problem

EE77860,

I too agree what Waross has pointed out.One of the motors is operating at 7% higher (2461 V)than its rated 2300 V and the other is 3% higher (2386 V) at nominal sytsem voltage of 12470 V.

So definitely the first motor might be out of its performance range and drawing higher current. My advice is

1) Check the motor test data sheets
2) Contact manufacuterer for the motor operating voltage range.

Hope this helps.

Kiri

RE: Interesting power problem

Quote:

I would like to respectfully disagree with waross's answer on this one.

The ratio of Voltages and currents should be the same since power is constant, where as according to his explaination 2461/2387 = 1.03 and 104/65 = 1.6
I agree that the large difference in currents would not be expecteed to be explained by the small difference in current.  For uncoupled motor, I would say the current is primarily inductive and it acts more like a constant impedance (inductance) than a constant power load.    But still, the change in current should correspond to the change in voltage which is much smaller, so again I agree with the conclusion the transformer ratio doesn't explain the change in current.

But when things are unexplained, it is productive to check  what you ACTUALLY have instead of what you think you have.  That's why I asked about the voltages in my very first post.

Another thought - as several pointed out, the difference is a square root of 3.  I'm pretty sure that is not just a coincidence.  Somewhere among verifying the connections at the motor, connections at the transformer, and at the monitoring location, the square root of 3 will be explained.  

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Interesting power problem

Where are the CTs in the system?  Did you measure with a portable clamp-on ammeter or take a reading from the CTs in the system? Are the CTs the same ratio?
I would like to see the actual schematics of the system(S).
 

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Thanks for all the thoughts, the currents were measured directly at the cables through flex CT's. This eliminates the CT error or location issue. My initial thoughts were about transformer tap differences, but calculations didnt compensate for the approximate 40A difference. Since amps were measured at the packerd head via flex CT's, I dont believe there is an issue of line or phase currents there.

RE: Interesting power problem

any voltage monitoring on these buses?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Interesting power problem

Could you also tell us if there were any voltage measurements taken on the low side of the transformers?
I am starting to wonder if the Delta-Wye transformer is actually 12470V to 1383, that would explain the sqrt(3) difference.
 

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Yes on Delta-Wye,one can see the voltage through multilin 469 MPR relay and it stays 2400V. This particular motor is the only load on the transformer. The Delta-Delta transformer is also 2400V. Once a year voltages are measured at the secondary of the transformers. One thing i found out is one of the motor had some failure years back and both motors were then rewound to 600HP from 350HP. I couldnt find out if this amp problem happened after the rewound or it went unnoticed even when they were run as 350HP.

RE: Interesting power problem

Also, how are the two motors connected? Delta or Wye?

RE: Interesting power problem

Are the cables the same?  Shielded or unshielded?

RE: Interesting power problem

(OP)
Motors are connected Delta, and cables are non-shielded for both motors.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources