×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

how many circles can be contained within a rectangle
5

how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

(OP)
Hi All

I am trying to determine how many round cables can be contained within a rectangular duct.  I have found a formula for circles contained within another circle but would like to know circles within a rectangle.  Can anyone help me with this

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

I use CAD for this type of problem.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

2
Three.

 

Jeff Mowry
www.industrialdesignhaus.com
What did you dream?  It's all right--we told you what to dream.
    --Pink Floyd, Welcome to the Machine

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

Seriously, I do as GBor mentioned above--draw everything to true scale and check it out.

 

Jeff Mowry
www.industrialdesignhaus.com
What did you dream?  It's all right--we told you what to dream.
    --Pink Floyd, Welcome to the Machine

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

On further thought, it seems like it would be something along the line of:

Int(A/D) * Int(B/D) - Int(2B/D)

Where A is the length of the rectangle
      B is the width of the rectangle
      D is the diameter of the cable

Basically, you would stagger the rows to compact them as much as possible.  Because of this, you would have one of the following stacking sequences:

o o o o o o o o
 o o o o o o o

Or

o o o o o o o
 o o o o o o o

Either way, you lose 1/2 a cable diameter for each row.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

searcher123,

   Circles and cylinders pack most tightly in a hexagonal formation.  Draw a hexagonal formation with required number of cables and wrap a duct around them, to scale, as noted above.

   Of course, circles and cylinders do not have connectors and cable ties, and rectangles do have have flanges and embedded connectors.  Reality is usually messier and more complicated than theory.  Are you sure you are looking at the whole problem?

                        JHG

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

Are all the cables the same diameter?

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

I missed a cosine in there somewhere...sorry.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

You need to go look at the IEC, or whatever code governs your installation.

The answer is not "as many as you can possibly jam in".

 

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

If you're talking about electrical cables in a rectangular cable tray, then you need to go ask this question in one of the electrical forums.  The limitation is NOT the physical size of the cables at all.  There are significant concerns dealing with heat generation and cable ampacities that come into play.

 

Patricia Lougheed

Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

(OP)
Thanks for the info.  I realize that the corect anwser is not allways the largest number of cables that can be jammed in.  The customer was concerned that the number of cables they wanted to fead to there equipment would not fit within the cable managment duct that was part of our design.  I did end up finding my answer through soid works though.  I created a rectangel and cut a hole and used the fill patern to populate the area and let solid works count the holes.  I like it when I can get the software to do my thinking.  It looks like I will need a bigger box.

Thanks again for the sugestions.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

Just curious.

How did you account drawoh's condsiderations.  

Can you slide one out and another in under the current specifications?

Tom

Thomas J. Walz
Carbide Processors, Inc.
www.carbideprocessors.com
 

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

Easy solution:  To determine the highest packing ratio possible, bid out the duct supply on a fixed price performance based contract.

  

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

(OP)
Hi Tomwalz

The cableing will be installed by the customer when the rack is installed.  After cable runs are finished they will be terminated.  There is the possibility of future maintenance or additions but the likelihood is small.  New cable can be run alongside the original bundle and old cables can be left as is or marked as dead.

 

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

Kiwimace:

That sounds like an easy solution for you: get a contractor to bid on a frivolous job without providing guidelines. I don't like that kind of thinking.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

dvd:
You caught me.  Merely a jovial remark intended to portray unkindly some stereotypical contractor as one who is prepared to devise a complex mathematical maximal solution in order to improve the profitability of his project.  I apologise for my slanted take on the world.  

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

I tend to draw it in cad and then add 50% (space not cables)

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

A quick and easy approximate solution is to take the area of the rectangle and divide it by the area of the equilateral triangle formed by 3 adjacent wires and then halve that  number, since the tangent (hexagonal) stacking  takes up 60 deg of each wire, a total of 180 deg or 1/2 of a wire.
For example, say you have a duct 4" *6" and the wire size is .1 inch,then the area of each triangle is:
(d/2)^2*sqrt(3)
For d=.1 , this becomes
.00433
So 4*6/2/.00433=2771 wires approximately, but is slightly on the high side.
This compares with the rougher estimate of 4*6/.1^2=2400 wires where you do it by rows and on the low side.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

All cables do not have the same diameter.  Cable trays have rated maximum loads in pounds per foot and in number/size of conductors.  Access for replacement and labeling is standard practice and requires some available excess volume for pulling cords and connection sheaths.  Filling a cable tray to full is not a good idea.  

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

The Electrical Code is very specific on how many of each size cable may be in a cable tray, conduit, etc.  All cables need to be taken into account, whether energized at the time or not.  Even if it isn't energized now, at some point in the future some engineer may decide to use it.  Depending on the type of conduit and the specific cables, the cable fill may be as little as 40% of the available area so it might not be enough to use a CAD program to find out the maximum and then take 50%.  You REALLY need to refer to the Code that is applicable for your answer.

RE: how many circles can be contained within a rectangle

In Canada, I understand that there is a derating factor applied to the ampacity of the conductors but no limit to the number of cables in a tray if they are properly derated. I'm out of town so I can't check for sure right now.
In some industrial plants the cables are heaped in the middle of the tray like a load of gravel. But, due to inevitable crosses and tangles, the cables take more space than your calculation will indicate. Oh, and corners often take more again.

Bill
--------------------
"Why not the best?"
Jimmy Carter

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources