×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

4160V motor feeder

4160V motor feeder

4160V motor feeder

(OP)
I have 4160v motors that are fed with amored cable.  My question is about unwiring the motor.  Is it necessary to install personal protective safety ground to unwire the motor?   I've heard two different stories.

1.  Always ground
2.  No need to ground since the armored cable prevent any induced or impressed voltages and any built up capacitve charge is drained thru the motor.

Any input, opinion or thoughts is greatly apprciated.

RE: 4160V motor feeder

At that voltage things exist in one of two states - energized  or visibly grounded.  No such thing as "deenergized".

RE: 4160V motor feeder

Agree with davidbeach!  I think it was one of the original Ten Commandments of Electrical Engineering that went like this:  

"Tarry thou not amongst conductors of the thousands of volts if thou hast not witnessed their grounding with thine own eyes, lest thy widow make merry with thy buddies in ways of which thou wouldst not approve."

Goober Dave

RE: 4160V motor feeder

I believe you'd ensure the motor cables are dead and grounded at the switchgear. This seems to be the accepted safe way to do work on equipment and should be considered as the best practice for any new installation. Some places will just pull the breaker and test the cables for no voltage before working on the equipment.

 

RE: 4160V motor feeder

DRWeig--

Do you have link for the other nine commandments?

old field guy

RE: 4160V motor feeder

Hi All,
Dealing with high voltage eqipments you got to follow saferty norms
1)proper Isolating  procedures involved you can't make mistke of doing the way you want to do when you follow Isolating procedures.  withdrawing the breaker you have to earth the motor tetminals  before you can get acess to the motor terminal cover A key is involved,this key makes sure you have grounded the motor terminals before you start working. do not get mixed up with  Drives where you have discharing resistors.
High voltage please follw proper procedures
Alex   

RE: 4160V motor feeder

Wolfie1A,

Hope you take all of the "safety first" notes to heart.  You might save a little time if you can convince yourself that grounding isn't needed, but at what risk?  

It's kinda like the people you see trying to beat a train to the crossing.  Might save a person five or ten minutes, but actually risking one's life to do so?  Not me...

Good on ya,

Goober Dave




Old Field Guy --

I did that one from memory, so it's probably a contortion of some sort.  I'll start a search in my archives, will post in Electric Power Engineering forum if I find it.

Good on ya,

RE: 4160V motor feeder

"Tarry thou not amongst conductors of the thousands of volts if thou hast not witnessed their grounding with thine own eyes, lest thy widow make merry with thy buddies in ways of which thou wouldst not approve."

Please do post those, that is the funniest thing ever. (Well, in here anyways).

Seriously, "If it isnt grounded, it isnt dead", our service vans have that bumper sticker.  

RE: 4160V motor feeder

Group:

As I stated, I got that commandment kind of twisted up with another one.  However, since this is a safety thread, I feel it's appropriate to post links to the originals.

Here's a purist version:
http://www.cyberslayer.co.uk/jokes/joke0636.html
  
And here's one with a Naval twist:
http://www.goatlocker.org/resources/nav/safety.htm

Hope I don't need to do anything else with the links, this is my first try...

Goober Dave
 

RE: 4160V motor feeder

In my experience (industrial plant), feeders at this voltage range have insulated or covered (taped, booted, etc.) terminations at the load and at the source.  

How do you apply grounds as 5kV motor starters are not typically outfitted with grounding switches?

RE: 4160V motor feeder

The last time I recall seeing a MV motor unwired, the breaker was opened, racked out and tagged.  I don't recall seeing any temporary grounding applied at the motor.  

Times may have changed, but in the past, temporary grounding was not routinely done for indoor MV plant distribution systems within one facility where the breaker could be racked out and tagged.  For major work on a switchgear bus, a grounding device was generally used.

 

RE: 4160V motor feeder

(OP)
I've contacted the MV starter mfg (AB 1500) and ask them exactly where the best place is to ground the load side of the starter.... still waiting on a reply.   

RE: 4160V motor feeder

The application of protective grounds on medium voltage systems in industrial plants can be challenging. Often little consideration was given to this requirement when the systems were designed. However, modern safe work practices dictate the use of having protective grounds installed prior to working on medium and high voltage circuits.

Older motor circuits in some of our facilities seemed to be the most difficult to work on. Often these motors were switched with power circuit breakers at the 6.6kV level. The motor connections in the motor junction boxes were taped with rubber tape and completely insulated. The back of the power circuit breaker cell had fully insulated bus and the cable connections were often taped with rubber tape also. The only answer for these types of installations was to employ what was known as a grounding truck. This device racked into the circuit breaker cell once the truck mounted power circuit breaker was removed from the cell. Once installed the grounding truck engaged the load side tulips in the back of the switchgear cell and shorted them to ground. Effective but one needed a unique truck for every model of switchgear that was on site.

On newer installation we address the problem two ways. All new motor junction boxes are now ordered with large junction boxes that have a small section of bare bus for each phase mounted on insulators inside the box. Motor leads are connected to one end of the bus and feeder cables to the other end. Adequate clearance between bus sections in the junction box means no taping of joints is required and it's a lot quicker to remove a motor when required. These short sections of bare bus also provide a convnient location to install ground balls (http://www.hfgp.com/ProductDetail.asp?ProductNumber=21706) that allow the motor circuit to be grounded. Cable circuits leaving power circuit breaker or contactor cells also have the grounding balls  installed on the load side of the breaker /contactor at some point were they accessible once the circuit is isolated and locked out.

I must caution that work on medium and high voltage circuits should only be performed by qualified personnel who are thoroughly familiar with the equipment involved. I cannot stress this enough, I have seen fatalities, injuries and numerous near misses while working on this type of equipment. If you make a mistake while you often don't get a second chance.




 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources