×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Transformer Burn Out Question

Transformer Burn Out Question

Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
Greetings,

I have a swimming pool UV Lamp sanitizer wall mounted 3 phase 6 KVA buck/boost transformer 480v Delta Primary to 208v wye secondary.  It is wired with the pri. and sec. reversed 208 v wye pri. up to 480 v sec..  
The amp draw (measured at 480v while in use) is Phase A 6.1A, Phase B 5.7A and Phase C 5.8A.  The secondary (208v) has no connections on the X0 tap.
This trans. has been in use for about two years, the outside of the case measured about 232 degrees F, this thing has burned out with no sign of lightning or other componant failure.  I am trying to figure out why it burned out so soon.
Any help is appreciated!!!!
jcall
 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

Wow, I'm not a transformer guy, but I can't imagine too many components lasting at 200+ degrees for a long time... personally, I think I would be amazed it lasted that long.  But maybe those things were designed for such high heat over the long haul...

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
This transformer has a temperature rating rise of 115 degrees celcius, housed in a NEMA 3R case, in a mechanical room that gets about 95 degrees F in summer.

jcall

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

No connection on the X0 tap?  You mean it is not being fed three phase?

Keith Cress
kcress - http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

X0 is the neutral, not needed for three phase.  That said it would have been far better to have gotten the proper transformer for the application, a 208 delta-480/277 wye.

It is probably a good thing the neutral wasn't connected.  We had a customer connect one just like this to feed 480V x-ray equipment from a 208V service.  We had a phase to ground fault on our primary, cleared almost instantaneously by a fuse.  Customer's wye-delta transformer (XO connected) continued to supply the ground fault until such time as X0-ground connection burnt open.  Excessive currents in the delta damaged the transformer.

Like I say, best to use the proper transformer.

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

Is it a heated pool...?
 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
OK engineers, help me out here,  if I am experiencing 6.1 amps/phasae A, 5.7 amps/phase B, and 5.8 amps/Phase C, at 480 volts, is a 6 KVA transformer cutting it too close for proper sizing?  Also I am told that a 480 V Delta primary and 208 v wye secondary transformer wired in reverse is suitable for this application.  Is thhis correct? Again my primary voltage is 208 wye.

jcall

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

Loading is in the 5kVA range, not inherently a problem.  Wrong transformer for the application - works in theory but not well in practice, see above.  Are you sure that it is a Y-Δ and not a T-T?

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
The manufacturer "Dongan" rep. says that this particular transformer is 480 V delta primary, 208 V wye secondary and it can be wired in reverse with no adverse effects.
He also says the 5 kva is big enough to handle the load.
So the unit will be wired 3 phase 208 V wye supply to the transformer "secondary" 208 V wye side and will get 480 v Delta output to the load.
I am thinking about replacing it with a 9KVA unit so as to laod the transformer to around 65%, less load/less heat generated.  Thoughts.....

jcall

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

Thought 1... as already posted by David

Buy a transformer with a 208V delta primary and 480V/277V star secondary. Earth the star point. Treat it as a separately derived source.

232F is about 111 celcius, not outrageously hot for a class F or class H winding. If you have a high ambient temperature make sure the transformer is adequately rated at the true ambient temperature with any covers on, panels closed etc. Elevated ambient temperatures require derating of the transformer.
 
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!
 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

I'd like to add that the temperature of a transformer in a closed NEMA box can take hours to stabilize.

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
Thanks folks for all the technical information !!!!  
A 208V delta primary and 480V/277V wye secondary will be the replacement unit enabling star point secondary grounding.

Great to have all this knowledge available to tap into.

Much Thanks,
Jcall

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

The delta connected secondary makes me highly suspicious about circulating harmonic currents flowing around the three secondaries. These currents obviously will not show up in the external load connections. That is the reason most transformers run delta/star, to reduce harmonic problems.

This could be producing quite a fair bit of mysterious hidden internal heating of the secondary.

Not sure if this is really the cause, but there are two solutions.  Run the secondaries in open delta, with a 480v load directly across each winding.

Run the secondaries in star, with 480v phase to neutral, and ground the secondary centre point.

 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

I second Warpspeeds opinion.  I've seen a power center transformer fail due to harmonics issues with UV banks at a water treatment plant, and this happens a lot if the correct type of transformer is not supplied.  We actually change the way we design now and specify that the UV bank suppliers also supply the power center transformers and warrant the installation, but they always seem to take exception to this.

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

(OP)
Looking back on this UV transformer failure, it gets me to thinking I might need to pass on this thread to them to consider a change in the way they are doing their UV instalations.

 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

If the current on the primary was measured you may have seen an overload in the transformer caused by some odd interaction between the power source and the transformer connections.
 

RE: Transformer Burn Out Question

Most UV systems I have seen use high frequency electronic ballasts that generates a lot of harmonics.  I agree with the others that harmonic currents could be at least part of the problem.  


 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources