Testing relays
Testing relays
(OP)
Can someone give me procedures for the testing of Distance protection relays, generator load unbalance protection relay, gen. undervoltage relay
When was the last time you drove down the highway without seeing a commercial truck hauling goods?
Download nowINTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
|
RE: Testing relays
Usually they provide some guidelines.
Please remember that you don't have to test the relay firmware but that the relay is getting the right input signals and is able to send out the right trip/alarm signals
RE: Testing relays
For the first, consult your test eqpt manual and the relay under test manuals. They will provide how to set up for testing.
For the second, it's basically injecting test signals that correspond to the relay set point and verifying that it trips. There is an acceptable band around the test point.
RE: Testing relays
RE: Testing relays
RE: Testing relays
Could you please will more clear.
Are you ask about primary generator protection test?
Are you would like check this protection w/o injection test set with some manipulation on the CT/VT of runnig generator?
Regards.
Slava
RE: Testing relays
If your relay installation incorporates test switches and/or test blocks, you can configure test plugs to shunt currents or disable potentials to cause relay operation. This is the way, for example, that pilot wire "end to end" tests are done. You can look at the user manuals for GE or Westinghouse pilot wire relays for a description and examples.
Shorting one CT in a differential circuit MAY work, but it also might not, depending on the the way the circuit is set up and the way the relay works.
relay testing (bench testing) and relay function testing (as you seem to wish to accomplish) are technical tasks that require a good amount of technical expertise to do well. I see a lot of cases where it's done, but not well...
old field guy
RE: Testing relays
Good point. I didn't think about that the OP may be asking about functional testing which would test not only the relay but the entire trip circuit.
RE: Testing relays
For example as, you say, for generator differential relays, short one CT and increase current, until the relay trips. Load unblance, by which I take it to mean negative sequence relay (46) swap two CT leads and increase current. Over and undervoltage relays increase/decrease generator voltage until relay trips. Some relays may require test settings to prevent operating the unit in a dangerous zone (40 relay for example) Of course all trip outputs must be disabled. These tests are better done during generator open and short circuit tests.
RE: Testing relays
That's what I was referring to when I said that shorting CT's may not work in a differential circuit.
For relays such as the newer microprocessor based things that take the inputs from two separate and isolated CT circuits and evaluate them numerically, shorting one CT, thereby killing one input, will result in a differential element operation.
On older electromechanical relays where the CT's are connected together in the circuit through operate and restraint coils, short in one CT of a differential pair shorts the circuit out and no operation results.
That's why it is essential that the engineer or technician understand how the particular equipment operates, instead of taking a "cookbook" approach.
I've been called in to troubleshoot problems with relaying that was directly traceable to poor test techniques. Fortunately the company that did the original testing was not able to fix the problem, and I worked for a different company...
old field guy
RE: Testing relays
RE: Testing relays
I made mediocre bucks... Do you have a lead on the 'big bucks'?
Right now one of my former co-workers and good friends is getting his feet on the ground at a new employer's facility. He's found a good amount (a SCARY amount) of protection disabled because it was giving erroneous trips. Nobody on the staff knew how to troubleshoot it nor did they have a real idea of what it was supposed to do anyway, so they just disconnected it from the trip circuit and made it an alarm.
I responded to a call at a facility where a fault had cleared by blowing the fuses on the incoming ustility feed outside the fence. Since inside the fence was a line-up of 13.8 switchgear that should have tripped before the fuses blew, I was interested in what went wrong. I found the instantaneous overcurrent elements had flagged on the electromechanical relays (Westinghouse CO's) but the breakers had NOT tripped. A minute later I found the battery charger had been de-energized and disconnected from the station battery bank, and that had been the situation for years. Nobody in the (state-run) facility had the foggiest idea of how the switchgear worked or what the battery bank was supposed to do. All they knew was that things ran just fine without the batteries. And it did, until that fault downstream. They'd been closing breakers with the manual maintenance bar, and tripping them using the manual trip on the front of the breaker. Again, incomplete knowledge of the system that went un-detected for years, because the facility staff did not even know which questions needed to be asked until somebody showed up that was familiar with the equipment and how it was supposed to work...
These are but a couple of examples of problems that can arrise from incomplete knowledge, so be careful. If you have the slightest doubt, talk with others.
old field guy
RE: Testing relays
You are right!!!!
Agree with each your word and I think all others commissioning guys too.
"big bucks" what is this??? How much??? 100$ or 100k$.
"big bucks" we pay not for work, for knowledge of the system, for responsible, for warranty. you need calculated how it's save: unwanted trips, no trips, damages, etc..
Regards.
Slava
RE: Testing relays