×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Solar Panels for farms
2

Solar Panels for farms

Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
How much of a good idea do you think that solar panels are good to water the crops in a field?

I think its great as when it is sunny, the pv cell will generate enough power to water the crops, and when it is not sunny(possible raining) the fields would require less watering..

am i forgetting something? what are your ideas?

thanks and regards
Luke from malta(eu)

RE: Solar Panels for farms

How does a PV cell create water exactly?   

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
The pv cell will provide the electrical power to a pump which will extract water from earth(that is, below ground).

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Negatives:

>  Dust
>  Other contaminants, like crop dusting
>  Damage from farm equipment getting around the panels
>  You'll need batteries to store the energy that need maintaining, since the power availability does not always correspond to watering schedules.
 

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Solar Panels for farms

People in the hurry to do PV panels forget the dust thing. IR has most of the cons listed. Keeping up with the electronics, access to service people in rural is more difficult.  Put the solar on your house, I'll bet you get a better rate on an industrial/farm meter than your house.

 The huge solar farms in CA have special wash systems that clean the flectors with DISTILLED WATER as a film of calcium deposites will knock the effiency down.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
Put the solar on your house, I'll bet you get a better rate on an industrial/farm meter than your house.

that is contradicting .. is better to put it on a house or in a farm?

than agian, its not that much of an option putting it on a house as it is to be used directly for farming, far away from houses..

regards

RE: Solar Panels for farms

I was thinking he may have a seperate meter on the water system.  A lot of the farmers in CO and KS have this. The farm use gets a different rate and may be tax exempt.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
The whole point of this process is not to pay less money (tax) but to reduce the amount of electricy used, and therefore reducing the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere..

so, basically the pv cell has to be put up on the farm's roof to generate electricity for the water pump.

What I would like to know is what I have to take care of (and possibly how). For example things like dust etc.

thanks!

RE: Solar Panels for farms

The real advantage in using a solar electric system for agricultural water pumping is when grid power is not available.  The cost of a PV system is often less than the cost of running grid power to a remote grazing site.  

Contrary to IRStuff's comment batteries are not typically used in a water pumping system.  The water is pumped into a cistern or holding tank during that day, then drawn out as it is needed.  

John  

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
hmm ok.. soo what ur saying is that the pv cells would be used to their full while there would be sun, so when they do not have enough energy they would not need alternate form of energy to extract water out of earth..
good point..thanks


any more suggestions/problems that might be encountered?

RE: Solar Panels for farms

lukedesira, this is an engineering site, we base our recommendations on economics and the correct application of the laws of science.  We don't take into account a monetary advantage of "it feels good" so it's worth more.  If you feel better about cutting CO2 then no amount of engineering will change that.

I've stated that you must clean the surface with distilled water to keep salts from building up.  Since the panel must face the south and most places have winds from the south, you might keep this in mind so that you place it on the southside of a dirt road, not the north.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
huh? what about environmental engineering? i mean.. if you can you try to hit 2 birds with 1 stone..

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Just as a sanity check, you might want to check the power output of solar cells and compare with the power requirements for whatever pumping system you would need.    If the area of solar panels needed is too large, you won't have enough space left to farm.   

RE: Solar Panels for farms

How far down is the water and what is the flow rate you can get.
How big is the field? Or
They still make these http://www.aermotorwindmill.com/Index.asp

The question is how far down in the water ( the head the pump will have meet) and how much water do you need. You can calculate the power you need and size your collectors.
What are you growing? A strorage tank and a drip system makes more sense in a solar powered irrigation system.  

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Environmental engineering is an extension of all engineering and cost analysis.  It would go against my PE to tell a client to spend $1,000,000 on a solar panel system to save $1,000/year in energy.  If it was $100,000 per year, I'd give them an option.

Environmental Engineering is not an end unto itself.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

I'm going to pipe in with my two cents since I actually operate a system like this.

I manage an olive processing plant and our irrigation system is off the grid. We water about 6 acres of trees with pumps running off of a battery-PV system. The max output of the system is 3.6 kW and we have 8 deep discharge batteries that actually run everything to do with irrigation. I don't remember the total amp hours stored by the batteries, but it's enough to run the irrigation for about 3 days if the panels were to fault and not charge anymore.

Running a pump directly from a solar panel will indeed allow irrigation to regulate itself as far as how much water is pumped, depending on the insolation that it's recieving. However, depending on the crop and the actual temperature it may be too little or too much water, if you get heavy rain and then a sunny week after that you can add water on top of already saturated soil which could be bad (again, depending on your crop)

what is your irrigation method? what size area are you trying to irrigate? and what is your crop and what kind of pump are you trying to run? PV pumps usually only trickle water unless you have a large PV array and even then finding a DC pump that can handle the power fluctuation is going to be hard. This is the reason we use AC pumps and an inverter to power our irrigation.

 

RE: Solar Panels for farms

One point first.  Non-environmental engineering can be an end to itself.  I would not want to be an engineers blinded by the idea that money is everything.  In addition to maintenance costs of the equipment commonly taught in engineering economics, there may be something else called "maintenance cost of the world", if you like, which has been for the most part totally ignored by engineering curricula.  IMO, I think its about time that some less myoptic engineers step up to the plate.

Correct solar panel sizing procedures include a 5 to 10% efficiency reduction for dust accumulation between rains.  If you live in an area where rain is scarce and 10% efficiency reductions can be exceeded, they should be manually cleaned at that point.  Natural rainfall will be sufficient for cleaning purposes except in the most extreme climates or immediately after plowing activities in the area.

I would want to have some relay that would deactivate the pump circuit at power outputs less than required for efficient pump operation.  No point spinning equipment just to increase maintenance cost without getting a sufficient water flow to make it worthwhile.

I think crops can survive without batteries.  Not many commercial solar irrigation pump packages come with batteries, so that should be pretty much indicitive of the lack of their necessity.   

 

http://virtualpipeline.spaces.msn.com

"What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know, its what we know for sure" - Mark Twain

RE: Solar Panels for farms

"maintenance cost of the world" . . . pure piffle.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

(OP)
thanks to everyone who has contributed in this forum..

I really appreciate all the help

regards,
Luke

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Pure piffle?  No!  Simply ANOTHER case of myopia.  

Pat, you obviously don't understand my perhaps somewhat exadurated analogy.  Should I scale it down for you?  Would not pollution from a leaking valve, or single hull tankers, or unlined sedimentation ponds, or gasoline vapors escaping from vapor control systems be a very tangible easily understood example of those hard to define "costs" that most engineers would rather ignore until forced to recon with by the general public that is sick and tired of these kinds of attitudes??????

 

http://virtualpipeline.spaces.msn.com

"What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know, its what we know for sure" - Mark Twain

RE: Solar Panels for farms

I was looking at a system like this over the weekend located in the Channel Islands.  The electrical components were by a company called Outback Power Systems.  They had roughly 48 sqft of panels, 48 batteries, and dual electrical and controls.  Not sure of the power output of the system though unfortunately.

I think that a solar charged battery and inverter system is a fine way to gain some independance from the grid.  But if you have access to the grid, it is a hard decision to spend the money required to break away from it, and requires commitment to the maintenance.

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Tie into the grid and use a netback meter. If that is allowed by the local utility, you sell any excess electricity to them and take when gen capacity is down.  You then only pay for the net electricity you use.  It also saves the batteries for times when you really need them.

--------------------------------------------------------

I suggest all remaining myoptics reading this thread catch up on some news and have a read of this AIChE mag article here,

Grand Challenges for Engineering
Twentieth-century engineering enabled life as we know it. The National Academy of Engineering looks at what is needed in the future.
http://www.aiche.org/uploadedFiles/CEP/Issues/2008-04/040811.pdf

http://virtualpipeline.spaces.msn.com

"What gets us into trouble is not what we don't know, its what we know for sure" - Mark Twain

RE: Solar Panels for farms

I agree that we need to be mindful of the "big picture" when engineering solutions to teh problems we encounter.  Sure you are not going to sell design A that costs 300% more than design B just because design A reduces energy consumption by 10% over design B, but we need to keep in mind that it is everyone's responsibilty to help do what we can, if option B exists it should be at least looked into.

 

RE: Solar Panels for farms

The defination of a good engineer:  "Someone who can do for a dollar what anyone else can do for two."
It may be fun and green to irrigate a crop with a solar power system but your own  may be the only one you will do. Most people (especially real farmers who are in it to make a living. ) would rather spend the one dollar and keep the other one.  

RE: Solar Panels for farms

Re:  "It may be fun and green to irrigate a crop with a solar power system but your own  may be the only one you will do. Most people (especially real farmers who are in it to make a living. ) would rather spend the one dollar and keep the other one."

There are more and more LEED-rated buildings going up all the time.  LEED often involves additional costs.  Turns out that in some peoples minds, there actually is a value associated with saving the environment, reducing global warming, etc -- a value they'd even cough up a few bucks to help pay for.  Similarly, the Prius seems to be a pretty hot car right now, despite being more expensive than other non-hybrid cars (and even despite the environmentally ugly batteries that it contains).

I certainly agree that it would be unethical to "sneak" energy-saving ideas into a project without first discussing with the client.  But I believe it is also unethical to assume that no rational client would ever pay for environmentally-friendly installations and to assume that no-one would ever find any merit in any sustainable design that had any additional financial cost associated with it.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources