×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Max compression ratio for propane

Max compression ratio for propane

Max compression ratio for propane

(OP)
A question was asked of me  regarding the maximum compression ration for a propane fueled engine.
 I believe it to be 13 or 14:1. Anyway just hoping some one can help.
 thanks
 Gord  

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

propane is still under 100 octane, so maximum compression ratios will be about 10: 1.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

Propane is rated anywhere from 104 to 110 octane.
Max compression ratio will depend on many things including camshaft timing.


www.retallickeng.com.au

Was told it couldnt be done, so
i went and did it!

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

There are variables as listed above, but as far as I now, 11:1 is generally considered the safe everyday use limit, maybe a little more if long duration racing cams are used or the fuel is known to reliable be pretty much pure propane and not to much butane.

Regards

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

What anti-knock benefits propane gains from a higher octane rating, it loses from not having the charge cooling effect of evaporating liquid fuel.  Furthermore, at high load operation, gasoline engines are enrichened beyond the stoichiometric AFR -- in many cases down to around 12:1 -- so that the extra fuel provides even greater charge cooling for knock resistance.

Introduced as a carburated-gas, propane provides no evaporative charge cooling, and therefore running richer than stoichiometric further does not provide any further cooling benefit.

There are systems out that inject propane as pressurized-liquid directly into the inlet tract, and these do provide significant charge cooling like gasoline.  However, these systems are the exception rather than the rule of most aftermarket propane conversions, which pre-expand the propane before admitting it into the intake as a gas.

In summary, the tolerance for increased compression ratio in a converted propane engine is relatively benign compared to the baseline gasoline engine.  The exception is a system that injects propane as liquid in the intake; there you can easily increase the CR by 1 or 2 full points if everything else is equal.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

According to ASTM D357 motor method, Propane is 97.1 octane.  And according to the book by Edward F Oberty, "Internal combustion engines and air pollution", it would take 1.6 mg/liter of tetraethyl lead to raise the octane to ROM 100 per ASTM D909.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

Kinda hard to add tetraethyl lead to a gaseous fuel, though ... and kinda bad for modern O2 sensors and catalysts!

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

(OP)
Thanks for the comments.  Not sure where the 13 or 14 to 1 came from. The application is I believe a pulling tractor using a 60 year old engine design so chances of a long duration cam with overlap wouldn’t be likely.
Anbody know where Glen Sali of propane drag car era is these days?,
Thanks again
Gord

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

Here is some data I found.

                              methane        propane        iso-octane
RON                                 120            112           100
MON                                 120             97           100
Heat of Vaporisation    (MJ/kg)       0.5094         0.4253        0.2712
Net Heating Value       (MJ/kg)      50.0           46.2          44.2
Vapour Pressure @ 38C   ( kPa )       -               -           11.8
Flame Temperature        ( C )     1950           1925          1980
Stoich. Flame Speed.    ( m/s  )      0.45           0.45          0.31
Minimum Ignition Energy  ( mJ )       0.30           0.26           -
Lower Flammable Limit   ( vol% )      5.0            2.1           0.95
Upper Flammable Limit   ( vol% )     15.0            9.5           6.0
Autoignition Temperature  ( C )    540 - 630       450           415

Regards

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

One cannot rely on one fixed static compression ratio for any fuel, there are too many variables.  

Common logic would dictate that a fuel with an octane rating of 100 would work best in an engine with about 11:1, but here we go with race engines running 14:1, and they are making lots of power.  A friend of mine is a mud racer (big engine, little truck, 4 wheel drive) running a 540 CID with 14:1, on alcohol.  Another friend is a local drag racer and on 104 octane racing fuel, he chooses 13:1.

Most engines use a lower compression ratio for emission controls and engine longevity.  My lawn mower engine uses 7:1 as an example, and it runs, and runs, and runs, longer than I would care to admit, with minimal maintenance.

When we work on the engine in a dyno cell and are setting the initial timing curve, we work on a best torque limited curve, before detonation.  Increased compression will usually require a lower total advance and less agressive curve before detonation, at best torque.

Propane behaves like the other fuels, but as mentioned, since it is a dry fuel with practically no heat absorbtion or charge cooling.  When we have detonation from compression, reducing ignition timing will have little effect.

On a valve-in-block engine, one can tolerate higher compression ratio than a modern valve in head engine, due to a less efficient combustion process.  In this case, its the engine, not the fuel that is dicatated by compression.

Personally, on propane, in a modern engine since the early 1990's, 10:1 is a good starting place, balancing engine longevity and power.  11:1 would give a little more power but the fuel mixtures and timing will have to be monitored more closely, and 12:1 needs constant vigilance on the above.

Franz

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

So are those folks using propane as a power-adder for a diesel engine, pretty much running their engine on detonation??

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

They are adding fuel to fuel, on an engine already running on excess air.  The combustion pressure curve on diesel is different than on propane, as is the initial peak and drop.

Question to ponder:

Does a diesel engine run on a constant detonation mode?

Franz

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

There is an element of "detonation" involved in diesel combustion, but it only involves the first bit of fuel injected during the ignition-delay period. Following that, it is a more or less smooth combustion. But if you mix in a portion of fuel into the intake air, isn't that fuel going to self-ignite and "detonate" before the end of the compression stroke, if the temperature at the end of compression is above the ignition temperature?

I'm thinking those propane-injection power adders are sending peak cylinder pressure sky high.

For what it's worth, diesel engines seem to be moving towards a combustion system with more pre-mixed combustion (possibly entirely pre-mixed in the low-load regime), but with the rate of heat release (and peak cylinder temperature, hence NOx emissions) controlled by using extremely high EGR in these part-load conditions.

I somehow doubt that the propane power-adder folks are putting that much research into how the combustion is progressing.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

(OP)
Good comments! Learned more than I had hoped.
 Gord

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

More about LP gas fired IC engines:
If liquid state  propane is introduced to the engine, there is change of state heat of evaporation required to vaporize the liquid, and then also roughly isenthalpic expansion which gives further charge densification. Per the Classius-Clapeyron  relationship propane will have less cooling than larger molecular weight fuel.

I am guessing that the LP is vaporized prior to carburator so much of the cooling advantage is lost.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

All the propane fuel trucks I've run were started and run on gasoline until the engine water was warm enough to vaporize the propane.  I gues you could start on vapors off the top of the tank and switch to liquid when the engine is warm.

The rule of thumb for home racing was 12.5 : 1 compression on Aviation gas at 105 Octane.  My present car has 11.5  to 1 and requires 91 to 93 (depending on altitute). But it has more bells and whistle than you can believe. Thats how I got to 11 to 1 with you every day vehicle.

RE: Max compression ratio for propane

i wasn't aware of any low level compression issues for propane motors-engines when we built my 496 chev
  so it's 13 to one in a street and strip trailer towing package..
   works just fine, no detonation

cleanburner

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources