×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
As an automotive technician, and NOT an engineer, nor someone with even the slightest ability to draw I often have ideas for a tool to make my job easier but no way to create them. Frankly I don't really care much about the process required for patenting etc. anyway so tell you what. Here's what I want, someone make it!

Air Chiesls (hammers) have been around for a while. But there is one specific use that they would be great for, but the repeating nature of the tool defeats any real chance of doing so because you cannot control it once it starts hammering. The use would be to install freeze plugs in the side of the engine block, which often means the tool would have to operate at an angle. It also must be able to hammer in single shots per trigger pull for precise control. One added advantage would be if the hammer strength could be adjusted as well from a slight tap, to the equivelent of a full arm swing with a 20oz hammer. When confined by clearances, many times a technician cannot get any room to swing a hammer, but a properlly built tool would not need the space that a regular hammer would. As far as the "angle" portion of the tool goes, I have some ideas but they would need drawn and tested for practicality as well as durability.

OK There it is, You build it, you can claim it. But someone build it for me!!!!

There are more ideas from where that one comes (VBG)....

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

I just watched "No Country for Old Men"---Seems like someone has something similar available.  Use a pressure regulator and don't go off killing folks for fun and it might just be the hot setup. winky smile

Rod

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

A 3X rivet gun ( an aviation tool, not an air hammer, tho they have a similar appearance) can be regulated down to very low cyclic rates. The trigger, plus a valve on the air inlet allows very easy "taps". I'm not sure it would meet your needs, but they are available fairly cheap on ebay, under "aviation tools". You could make the 'set' according to your needs on a lathe.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
Thanks for starting to at least talk about this. I have not seen the movie, but it's on my list....

As far as I know, there is no tool beiog produced that would act as I have outlined. The single hammer hit is simply not in use at this time, and a low cyclic rate, simply wont work because of the precision that must be used with each strike. The tool must be positioned precisely, then struck, then repositioned, and then struck again until the task is completed. A multiple strike could allow the tool to be misspositioned and then the soft plug or surrounding material damaged when the next cycle automatically occurs.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Try posting on practicalmachinist.com.

Folks there know an awful lot about tools.  

All I can think of is the nail driver that uses something like a .22 blank.  

Thomas J. Walz
Carbide Processors, Inc.
www.carbideprocessors.com

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

evelrod, haven't seen the movie but would that be a 'bolt gun' typically from a slaughter house?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captive_bolt_pistol

Be careful when you google this, you'll get a bunch of sites by PETA and the like showing animals mistreated etc. in slaughter houses.  Might put you off burgers for a few hours.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Nice one ivy, I was thinking something like this must exist for Peening/Staking and that's listed as its use on one of the sites you gave.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
Wow, that's a start. Now we just need to be able to use it at an angle, instead of only straight on. This is where the real engineering comes in, we not only have to operate at an angle, (several different angles potentially) but the tool must be able to control recoil away from the assembly, without using up too much of the operators skin.  VBG.. For generic starters I'm thinking removeable heads to transfer the impact to 30degrees, 45 degrees 60 degrees, and 90 degrees from the initial tool stroke.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Unless you can wedge the tool into place, you're going to have a difficult time getting anything to transfer energy around a 90-degree corner winky smile

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

could just use the big one, and put it against the side of the car in approximately the right location...

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Hello, Isaac. Still up there in snow country?

I think the 'big one' against the side of the car would work but would necessitate a dramatic change in the shop's liability insurance policy! winky smile

Rod

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
That big one is an amazing piece of equipment. I can say it could be somewhat gratifying to get to use it on a few cars that I've dealt with in the past, but that has nothing to do with "fixing" them, VBG...

Anyway, I hope someone can figure out how to make the tool that I would like to have. The current tools designed for this operation are terribly inadequate, and there has never been a real solution except for removing the engine so that there is straight on access to drive in the replacement plugs. (FWIW, bolt in plugs have a high failure rate)  

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

so how often do you come across cars where the block core plugs have come out?

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
Often enough to justify improving the methods available to service them. Even with a small shop like mine it can range from as high as one to two times a month, and then of course drop down to as few as only a couple of times a year. There are many soft plugs, such as the ones at the rear of the block (flywheel area) that simply cannot be serviced without removing the engine or transaxle. But there are far more on the sides of the block, either above part of the transaxle or in the front of the vehicle (radiator side) where there is as little as 5 inches clearance which means there is no room to drive the replacement soft plug in.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

I just push them in with a tyre lever if space is restricted.

I have never seen one come out of it's own accord. I have only ever replaced them because of corrosion. I only ever use brass replacements. I do play with boats that are cooled with raw water, sometimes salt water.

Regards

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
Cars use steel (?) ones and they are quite stiff. I rarely if ever see brass ones. As far as prying them in that would still require room to do so as well as something to pry against that wont break. Both restrictions that make that method quite unlikely to succeed. Oh, and yes the primary failure is corrosion. If someone manages to freeze an engine and have push them out they likely have even greater problems than the loss of the plug. Soft plugs never get re-used, new would always go back in.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

OEM plugs are usually steel, replacement ones brass.

I have replaced them  many time using a socket of the appropiate size, and a heavy short handled square headed hammer,  only need an inch of room to swing one enough to fit them.

I have heard of an expansion plug, rubber with a screw that is tightened to expand them.  No idea how well they last.

www.retallickeng.com.au

Was told it couldnt be done, so
i went and did it!

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

when I worked at an auto parts store, we carried the rubber plugs in addition to steel and brass ones.  Steel ones were the most commonly sold, according to my rusty memory.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

I have tiny a bit experience with core plugs.  The socket/hammer works for me.  Tried the rubber plugs on the cylinder head of a 360 Dodge (on the front) as an emergency...Not very good as they came out in short order, even with the rad cap loose!  I have successfully used the Dorman three piece brass plugs...never had a failure and they can be installed with a wrench...little pricey, though. Where Welch plugs are used, it's steel only.

My race engine plugs are usually steel, cup or Welch and, "set screwed" or tapped and plugged.  The only street failure I have had in recent times was on a '95 Chrysler LHS V-6---all six OEM plugs failed under warranty.  No explanation from the dealer.

Rod

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
When room permits, the socket and hammer method does work. There are other tools sold for the purpose of installing the plugs that attempt to allow the mechanic to be able to drive the plug in at an angle or from some distance to the actual plug and they are a help in some cases, and at best simply aggrevating in others.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Mate I know your frustration....Core plugs really suck.
I have gone away from the gruelling frustration of fitting these bastard things.I now freeze them with liquid nitrogen,carbon dioxide or dry ice.I find it sooooo much easier compared to not doing it this way.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

From Practical Machinist

Do you mean core plugs in an engine block? (Sometimes misnamed the freeze-out plugs.)
For any oddball automotive tool, try Snap-On.
JRR

Use either a proper fitting socket or a seal driver kit. The socket can shrink the plug if not used properly, causing faulty sealing. We use Permatex Aviation Seal on the plugs before installation.
Perry Harrington  

Just went through it with a Rover V8 not too long ago. Just clean up the recesses, coat the plug with a good grade of sealer (I used Permatex 2a - non-hardening) and tap it in square using a driver that is a close fit to the inside of the plug (I turned one from scrap).

As said above, don;t hammer the center down or the plug will "shrink" - you want the sides to remain parallel, hence my comment about a close-fitting driver.
Alan

Thomas J. Walz
Carbide Processors, Inc.
www.carbideprocessors.com

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
I appreciate what you wrote there Tom. As far as accomplishing the task, I've done it enough times to know what to do and what not to do. This is why I outlined what I would like to be able to buy and if someone would take the request serious enough to built it, it would assist all technicians in doing a repair that can be very difficult from time to time. Imagine driving a soft plug in when there is only 3 inches of space between the engine block and some other surface. Rubber plugs tend to leak as has been described by others, even the bolt in brass ones can occasionally leave one dissapointed, especially if the subsequent failure leaves a customer stranded, or worse results in engine damage. One solution that has been used on occasion is to install a bolt in block heater, and then leave it up to the customer to decide if they actually want to be able to plug the car in if they want to. You have to compare the expense of the block heater, to the total labor that could be required to remove the engine to install the soft plug if there isn't sufficient room to do so otherwise.

If no one is interested in designing and building a tool that can do as I ask then this thread is pretty much done.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

OK, on the design side then, how is the recoil to be handled?

Pushing a device like this up into a gap where you can't directly support it will most likely limit its effectiveness wont it?

Perhaps you could design it to brace against the body work but you'd need to be careful.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
The recoil is clearly one of the big hurdles. Keeping the actual stroke of the tool as short as possible will help. Utilizing both tool mass, and from there the tech will have to brace the tool either by hand, or with mechanical means. Frankly we actually are not talking about a large force, but many times the force require to install a freeze plug is greater than what can be achieved by a technician swinging a hammer in one to four inches.

I can envision the fact that the tools needing to change mechanical direction could be used in some fashion to dampen the shock load. Something like the throw on a crankshaft. I can envision the hammer power traveling slightly past the actual impact point and then the motion being levered so that the piston would hit the freeze plug and then timed instantly afterwards, the crank throw would then attempt to move away from the block, which would cause it's own momemtum change and dampen the thrust.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

The OP obviously is in a position where he must install a lot of core plugs in his business.  A good Port-a-power with a small cylinder might work.  Make a threaded device to wedge between the plug and some near surface. A long bent bar for leverage in some circumstances.

Like I said, I've done a few in the last fifty years and, even the 'easy' ones can present problems. I prefer NOT to use a sealer unless there is corrosion present in the hole. Also, there is a world of difference in the installation of a 'cup' plug and a 'Welch" plug.

Finally, I have had two engines freeze and break, a six cylinder 48 Plymouth and a four cylinder English Ford. Neither of these engines pushed out their "freeze plugs"!

Rod

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

I still say a tyre lever or two and a strategically placed block of wood or two and maybe a piece of rubber or carpet under the wood can do the job without body damage if care is taken. Push against the rim, not the flat so the plug does not shrink.

Regards

eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

(OP)
Imagine doing this a few hundred times a year, not one or two times in a lifetime. Then imagine doing it on all different makes of cars. There are too many easily breakable parts to make prying the plugs in feasable and rarely are you going to have a good fulcrum point exactly where you would need it to be. BTW you won't really know if another structure is strong enough to pry off of, until it proves that it wasn't. Trying to press it in with pressure also requires some other surface virtually as strong as the block is press off of. That's why the plugs are normally driven in. The part that only people inside the field understand is quite often labor guides are used to estimate repair times. Most of the time services like this one are not actually performed and researched, and are widely left up to assumptions. Rarely does a shop ever charge more than these guesses, and that usually ends up leaving the shop and the tech underpaid when the task simply does not get completed easily. If a tool was made that would do what I have outlined, it would sell because taking a hit one time (the price of the tool) is a lot better than taking repeated hits throughout ones career. That's why automotive techs with 20+ years of experience usually have more than 50K in their tool boxes....

Some of us have much more than that!

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

I keep coming back to the idea of a hammer mass working against a separate inertia mass of some sort (rather than primarily using the entire tool for that function) and using shop air and some user means of controlling the pressure to the tool.  But I have no idea how well you could guarantee square 'hits' on the plug each time.  Toggle action?  Really short air cylinder?  Means of limiting the stroke?  Just tossing out thoughts.


Norm

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Norm, you mean something like a recoilless rifle?  Send equal momentum both ways?

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Tools I would like to be able to buy !

Something along that line (I guess, never having seen a recoilless rifle up close).  

Might want the hammer to open a port on the air cylinder so that mostly it's only hammer momentum that gets applied against the plug.


Norm

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources