×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

location of shear wall in multistory building
3

location of shear wall in multistory building

location of shear wall in multistory building

(OP)
In a 12 Story building with a very irregular grid rectangular in the middle then circular at one end. What are the factors that should be kept in mind when placing shear walls at a certain location in this or any other building?

is there any reference/code stating or justifying the location of a shearwalls in a building.
 
where should a shearwall be placed in any building?

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

To avoid unnecessary torsion, the center of stiffness of the shear walls should be at the center of the applied load (wind/seismic).

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

Yes, I'd just look at trying to make the layout of shearwalls as balanced and uniform as possible, looking at both orthogonal directions and trying to keep the center of rigidity and the center of mass as close together as possible.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

JAE,

that is assuming it is a seismic area, if not the ceneter of wind load is more relevant.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

CSD72, true.

At least in the US, everywhere is a seismic area, though..some more severe than others....but your point is a good one.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

(OP)
JAE and CSD72 , you both are senior engineers and structural engineers, i am just a civil engineer and not much experienced with structures, its not that i am designing anything but i want my concepts more clear about structures, so please dont mind me asking ABC questions of structural engineering in this respect.

1) what is "center of loading" ? how do you find a center of loading in a building?

2) i know about center of gravity or mass, but what is center of rigidity ? and how do you find that out in a building ?

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

I think what csd72 is stating for "center of loading" is that for each story, either seismic or wind loading is applied to the structure and there is a resultant and effective center point where the load acts as an equivalent point load.

For wind:
  Say you have a 40 ft. wide building.  The wind would typically be centered at 20 ft. from either end and in the center of the wall surface vertically.

For seismic:
  For a uniform building shape, each floor's center of mass is located in the center of each floor..assuming all the floor framing is uniform and all the walls are uniform.

If they are not uniformly laid out, then you have to calculate where the center of mass at each floor is:

   Σ(weight x distance)
   ------------------------------------  =  dist. to c.m.
          Σweight


RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

(OP)
thanks !

what is center of rigidity ?

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

You might want to look this one up or have someone show you - essentially it is the geometric point, in each direction, that represents a location where a load, applied laterally to the diaphragm, will not induce torsion in the floor, only lateral translation.

You have to determine the rigidity (kips/inch) of each brace or shearwall line and then find their weighted center, again - in each direction.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

As was stated previously, try to align the maximum loading condition such that the center of applied loads align with the center of rigidity of the resisting elements.  Keep in mind that you will have some partial loading conditions that will be eccentric to the center of rigidity.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

The center of rigidity is only really important when you have more than two rows of shear walls/bracing or are in a high seismic region.

If you only have two rows then the horizontal loads are distributed according to simple statics (somewhat akin to a point load on a beam).

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

If your shear wall are located around the perimeter, you may need extra steel adjacent to the walls to limit the crack widths in the slab as the slab tries to shrink when it cures. The shear walls will try to restrain the shrinkage. Aalami and Barth wrote a good paper, "Cracking in Prestressed Concrete Structures" that talks about this.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

Put your shear walls half way along each side and this is not so bad.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

I think what tngolfer is referring to applies primarily to basement walls.  He is correct, but that is a different topic from the OP.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

(OP)
Does IBC2006 addresses this issue ?

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

Hokie, it applies to any concrete framed slab but is generally worse the closer you get to any point of high restraint (the ground for example). Granted, the restaint is much worse if the shear wall is part of an elevator/stair box-shape or in it's strong direction though but it will still try to restain the shrinkage.

I have uploaded the article if you are interested. (Sorry for the picture quality - scan of a copy.)

http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=ce017cf0-a21f-4753-9fde-ebf3a2d22116&file=Aalami_and_Barth_-_Cracking_in_Prestressed_Concrete_Structures.pdf

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

tngolfer,

Thanks for that.  Restraint is always an important issue.  I have not read this particular article, but will do so when I get a chance.  Looks like one a lot of people on this site could use, as I have the impression that some think that concrete just cracks for no apparent reason.  By the way, and you probably know this, but the reinforcement doesn't "restrain the shrinkage" or prevent cracking, it controls the cracks to an acceptable width.

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

tngolfer,

I did read the article, and it is an excellent, largely non-technical explanation of restraint cracking with a lot of examples.  It correctly discusses the problem as being worse in unbonded post-tensioned slabs than in conventionally reinforced slabs.  What is not said is that bonded post-tensioned slabs work better than unbonded slabs, but even so, deformed bars are required in many cases for effective crack control.  

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

zeeshanahmed,

There is advantages in locating your shear walls (where possible) to correlate with your gravity load structure. By that I mean selecting walls with sufficient compression in them due to dead load / self weight so that overturning moments induced by lateral loading do not result in tension (or very little) across the section. I have found large compression is easier (and more efficient) to handle than large tension.  

RE: location of shear wall in multistory building

Whooa! placing shearwalls are for really experienced structural people. also to consider ARCHITECTS restrictions.

Where the objective is that center of load should
coincide with the center of rigidity. which is very tricky to do and takes a lot of experienced Engineering Judgement.
we know we cannot in reallity made this perfect,
dont hesitate to do "trial and error" using a good 3d analysis software.

I learned a lot in this thread (thanks to all).

one question....i know it is logical to loose the 5% eccentricity as required by code when your structure is irregular. has anyone tried? coz I havn't.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources