×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

(OP)
I can find model threading for holes, but I cannot for external surfaces.  Can external threads be modeled?  If not what does one do to have a thread specified on external surfaces?

Gary Ashby
Designer

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

the search button works pretty well.  I typed in "external thread" and found this thread thread559-198008: Threading a rod to make a bolt....  It has a bit of information.

dsgnr1

¿)
Version of SolidWorks: 2007
SolidWorks Sercive Pack:sp5
Operating System & Service Pack: winxp pro v5.1 (sp2)
Graphics Card and Driver version: Nvidia Quadro fx540, 9.1.3.6
Amount of installed RAM: 1GB
Virtual Memory settings: APPS, total paging = 1024mb
CPU Type & Speed: intel pent 4 / cpu 3.00GHz


RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

(OP)
Thanks dsgnr1, I will look at that thread more closely. I have been using this forum for a while in the UG/NX area and thought I had read the search function did not work. Glad to see it does.

UG/NX allows the user to create external and internal  threads within one feature function. I was hoping SolidWorks would have a similar function since it already lets the user create internal threads easily.

Having to create a helix and cross section of the thread can be time consuming, but if that is what is required in SolidWorks that is what I will have to do.

By chance is there an external add-on program that can be added to add this thread feature to SolidWorks?

Gary Ashby
Designer

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

4mranch1,
Are you talking about Cosmetic Threads? If so just select the leading edge of the shaft and open the Cosmetic Thread tool from the Annotations toolbar.

Or just apply a texture to the shafts' face if you don't need the dashed root circle.

cheers

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

In my opinion this by far the biggest failing of Solid Works compared to other similar software.

Making external threads in Solid Edge was a few mouse clicks, even to make tappered threads.  It was a real eye opener the day I realized how much work was involved in doing something that every other modeler I have ever used can do with ease.

What I have never understood is why they don't fix this.  This issue of external threads has been around for years with nothing being done from Solid Works.  Maybe 2009 will be the year.

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

If you believe it is a limitation, then you should put in the enhancement request.  The squeeky wheel gets the oil.

Dan

www.eltronresearch.com

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

Being a cynical person by nature I feel that my time would be better spent poking myself in the eye with a stick then sending in an improvement request.

Perhaps this time will be different so I'll give it a try.

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

Quote (JamesBarlow):

In my opinion this by far the biggest failing of Solid Works compared to other similar software.

They can't please everybody I guess.   That is the biggest failing for you?   I haven't seen a survey, but I would guess that 99% of Solidworks users do not NEED the actual threads modeled on a part.   On the rare occasion that I needed to show threads, I simply revolved a v-shape around a shaft and then made a linear pattern.

As was stated earlier, make an enhancement request or you'll be back in 2010 complaining about this "missing" function.

Flores

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

"Being a cynical person by nature I feel that my time would be better spent poking myself in the eye with a stick then sending in an improvement request."


was the funnyest thing i read all day!



RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

I have never seen a purpose to model threads on a part, unless for a manual. Then it would just be a revolve.

Chris
SolidWorks/PDMWorks 08 2.0
AutoCAD 06/08
ctopher's home (updated 10-07-07)

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

JamesBarlow,
Are you saying that SE and most other solid modelling programs have a function which creates true helical threads?

cheers

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

(OP)
CorBlimeyLimey,

I use UG/NX5 and SolidWorks and UG/NX has had that available feature for some time. The user selects the surface and UG will allow a cosmetic thread or a fully detailed helical thread. UG even identifies a possible thread to the diameter feature chosen.

Gary Ashby
Designer

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

4mranch1,
It doesn't surprise me if NX5 (or even Wildfire) had that capability as they are (or are descended from) high end systems.
I would be pleasantly surprised though if SE has this function. It didn't when I was using it a few years ago ... leastways it wasn't shown to me and I didn't see it mentioned in the Help files.

cheers

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

Does your company manufacture screws or similar parts?  I can see the need if this is the case.   For over 10 years (since the AutoCAD days) there have been many users who wanted to model the actual helix on a screw just for visual purposes.

In SW, throw 50 screws made with actual helices into an assembly and the system will start slowing down.

Flores

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

(OP)
Those detailed threads will slow done even the high end programs so I have never used them except in a few areas like for the ballscrews used on our actuators.  All fasteners are shown in their simpliest form with no detailed threads (A common and prefered modeling practice.).  Thanks to this forum I have found where external threads can be represented thru SolidWork's Insert / Annotation / Cosmetic Threads and this will do just fine for the majority of our parts.  It would just be nice to have the capability of detailed external threads if it was needed on a model.

Gary Ashby
Designer

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

You absolutely can create detailed external threads.  You just have to do the math.

Dan

www.eltronresearch.com

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

I wouldn't be surprised if someone has created a macro to generate the geometry.  Though I have never come across said macro.

-Dustin
Professional Engineer
Certified SolidWorks Professional

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

(OP)
Eltron,

I realize that detailed threads can be created, I have just gotten spoiled with UG/NX doing the math for me.

Gary Ashby
Designer

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

I would not be surprised if SW deliberately kept helical thread modeling a slightly difficult task.  If it were made too easy, every idiot using SW would put actual helical threads on all their fasteners, then complain when their assembly performance absolutely tanked.  Making it more difficult to do makes you stop and think, "Do I really need this level of detail?"  99% of the time, the answer is "No."

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

In my company we use actual modeled threads quite a bit.  Especially when you are building models and prototypes using SLA or other 3D printing methods.  I have been giving feedback on wanting this feature for years.

RE: External Threads Possible On Solid Models?

ArcheryKinetics is right.  I have modeled threads on parts quite a bit.  Mainly for SLA and castings with large a OD.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources