×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
Hi all,
In order to check a compressor offer I want to calculate the kW needed to raise the pressure.
In short, I do not trust the stated 480 kW of Horsepower.

The compressor needs to compress 10.000 kg/hour CO2 @ 55 C saturated with water (about 670 kg/hour of water --> Total flow is 10.680 kg/hour) from 1 bar(a) to 2,75 bar(a) @ 180 C (Compressor 1)

Then the flow is cooled to 50 C so approx. 470 kg/hour of water is knocked-out making the total flow 10.200 kg/hour.


And then compression from 2,5 bar(a) to 7,2 bar(a) @ 180 C (Compressor 2)

For Compressor 1:
If I see it as a blackbox with input and output the Enthalpy is reased and to raise the Enthalpy 365 kW is needed. (1.314.360 kJ/hour devided by 3600 --> 365 kW)

For Compressor 2: 345 kW

In total the Enthalpy raise is 710 kW, which is far more than the stated 480 kW. Can anyone tell me what I am missing here.

I do also have a centifigal compressor calculation sheet, but this is a new type of compressor which claims to have less energy needs so I wanted to use a complete other approach.

Greetz,
Eltjo (From the Netherlands)

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

I ran numbers here and I get the same 710 KW for the system.  When I back into the polytropic efficency I get 66% for the first stage and 60% for the second.

To achieve 480 KW, the polytropic Eff would be about 89%.  That would only be achievable with a very tightly build, huge valve area reciprocating compressor.

I might call foul on this myself.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


I didn't take the time to do a full calculation, but it seems to me the outlet temperatures for an adiabatic compression are too high, probably by some +/- 50 deg C. Correct me if I'm wrong.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
Thanks for the quick answers!

@25362: As it is a new design for a compressor I can't tell if the outlet temperatures are too high. That's why I am threating it as a black box and use data provided to me.

@dcasto: Since compressor calculations are not my specialty this might seem a stupid question...(Excuse in advance) but if the system is reased 710 kW, this energy must come from somewhere, how can I get 480 kW with polytropic Eff 89%? Where does the other 230 kW comes from?

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


By adjusting the temperatures to values obtained by adiabatic compression, the kW obtained from enthalpies drop by about 60%.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


I suggest you recheck discharge temperatures. They may be the result of a typing error.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
@ 25362 You mean that if the outlet temperatures are adjusted downwards the enthalpy will also drops?

I just did a "micro-calculation" for an isothermal compression (n=1) (This is the most optimistic calculation right?)

Pisoth = Qme * R * T1 * LN (P2/P1)
Where:
Qme = 10.000 kg/hour --> 2,78 kg/s
R = 287 J/(kg * K)
T1 = 323, 15 K
P1 = 1 bar(a)
P2 = 7,2 bar(a)

Pisoth = 508 kW

This is without correction to CO2 which is heavier and without the saturated water.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


Yes, by dropping the temperatures to, say 140 deg C the enthalpy differences drop to about 60%.

In your formula R = 8314.5/44 = 189, not 287 J/(kg*K).

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


Apparently, you have used R for air, not for carbon dioxide.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
Yes, thank you for the notification.

Ofcourse the R is not correct because there needs to be a correction for the water too.

I am going to email the supplier. For information I will post their response here.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

eltjo, there are at least 3 methods in frequent use nowadays:

Method 1 - Use a simulator. They do the calc in two steps.
Step 1. Starting at known inlet conditions, they do an isentropic flash to the outlet pressure. Then they calc the outlet enthalpy based on the outlet pressure and entropy.
Step 2. They now calc the actual outlet enthalpy by dividing the enthalpy change in step 1 with the adiabatic efficiency. Lastly they recalc all outlet properties (including work required), based on the new outlet enthalpy and pressure.

Method 2 - Use the well known compressure head/power equation based on adiabatic efficiencies.

Method 3 - Use the well known compressor head/power equation based on polytropic efficiencies.

For recips you have to check the outlet temp (per API std) and for centrifugals you have to make sure your head is realistic.

In all cases you motor/turbine will supply all the power requires, including efficiencies not used above (seal losses, gear losses, etc).


RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
Dear people,

The answer was indeed as stated above the discharge temperature. They say it is 150 C instead of 180 C. This wil drop the enhalpy from 710 kW to 415 kW.

The overall efficiency must then be 92% to get the 450 kW. But I will look into that.

Thanx for al the answers!

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

Yes, 92% is to good to be true.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


I wouldn't be surprised if the correct again their discharge temperature to 140 deg C.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


Using the conventional formula for adiabatic compression:

kWad=[k/(k-1)] WRT1[p(k-1)/k – 1]

gives us an idea of the kW consumed in compression.

R=8314÷MW, and taking MW = 40 for the 1st stage and 43 for the 2nd stage, assuming k =1.3 for both cases, W=kg/s, T1=328 and 323 K, respectively, one gets:

For the 1st stage:  kWad  = 230
For the 2nd stage:  kWad = 212

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
This is correct, I have made some calculations with my old schoolbooks and it uses the same formula (and answers).

But when I make that calculation complete with the discharge temperature:

T2/T1 = P2/P1^((n-1)/n)

The discharge temperatures are lower than the stated 150 C.

With your numbers approx. 135 C.

And this calculation doesn't use the efficiency of the motor, right?

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy


The formula refers to the work of compression on the gas, nothing on the mover.

RE: Calculate kW of Compressor through enthalpy

(OP)
Yes, I thought so.
Thanx for all the replies. If I have news from the manufacturer I'll share the info.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources