×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"
4

Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

(OP)
Over the years I have heard some interesting arguments about what falls under the practice of engineering and what does not.  I've know non-registered engineers who offered design services.  They always argued that they were not offering engineering services, just providing designs.  I always believed when an engineer provided a design they were practicing engineering.

Today you here a lot about "Value Engineering".  In some cases that service is being offered by registered engineers and in other cases by non-emgimeers.  Since it appears in most states that you can be a computer engineer with out being registered maybe the same thing applies to "Value Engineers"

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

In my opinion, the best "value engineer" is an estimator who is closely connected to the present day material and labor costs AND has a good knowledge of structural design.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

I did one of these 20 years ago or so, and it involved a look at the project, a government project, by another complete design team - Architects, Civil, Structural, Mechanical, and Electrical Engineers, Estimators, and Contractors...The whole ball of wax.

So, in answer to your question, no, but it helps.

Mike McCann
McCann Engineering

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

I don't know that you have to be a PE to be a value engineer but I do that there are certified value engineers and many times a client will specify that in RFPs.  

now, how one deals with the terminology certified value engineer and is not an engineer, well that's what most state boards of licensing chase after....

Regards,
Qshake
pipe
Eng-Tips Forums:Real Solutions for Real Problems Really Quick.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

RARSWC,

You could propose an alternative design, but could you stand by the validity of your design and issue signed and sealed calculations - no. This could be a problem.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

(OP)
csd72

If you mean could I personally stand by the validity of my design and issue signed and sealed calculations, the answer is  yes for the states that I am registered as a P.E.

My involvement with "Value Engineering" usually comes after the fact.  I will get a system that has been changed, through value engineering, from the orginal design.  My job then is to actually do the design.  Often times I end up going back to who ever did the value engineering and asking them how in the world did they expect their alternate design to work.

I deal with a lot of cases where people down size glulam beams because they were oversized to begin with.  However often when I try to detail the connections I deal with problems that would not have existed with the orginal deeper beams.
 

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Greetings:

I am not a lawyer but I do know that in the state of Arizona, that if a firm or individual (by the way, I have never even heard of value engineers, certified or otherwise) makes any changes or revisions to a registrants construction documents he or she must not only be duly registered but must & shall, under the law also be fully liable for said changes or revisions.

       Best regards, registeredpe in AZ,

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Greeting again:

I just retrieved my quarterly newsletter from my mailbox from the Arizona State Board of Technical Registration and under their mission statement it reads,"The purpose of this agency is to protect the public by setting appropriate registration qualifications and enforcing state statutes relating to the practice of all Board-regulated professions and occupations.
Any person who does any of the following is acting in violation of the law and is guilty of a class 2 misdemeanor:

1. Practices, offers to practice or by any implication holds himself out as qualified to practice any Board regulated profession or occupation if the person is not registered or certified as provided by this chapter.

2.Advertises or displays any card, sign or other device that may indicate to the public that the person is certified or registered or is fully qualified to practice any Board regulated profession or occupation if the person is not registered or certified as provided by this chapter.

3.Uses "certified", "professional certified", "professional", "registered", "registered professional" or "professional registered" in conjunction with any Board regulated profession or occupation if the person is not certified or registered as provided by this chapter.

So it is my humble opinion that if a "value engineer" performs any work for the public(at least in AZ)he or she must be duly registered.

For additional Info. go to www.azbtr.gov

   Thanks again, registeredpe in AZ

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

"Value engineering" is not usually performed by professional engineers.  As someone else said, it is usually done by an estimator, quantity surveyor, or construction consultant.  It really just involves making recommendations for improving buildability and economy, and whether or not the recommendations are accepted usually involves additional work for the design engineer and negotiation with the owner or builder.

The widespread use of the word "engineer" is the problem.  At least in Australia we don't call a train driver an engineer.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

RARSWC,

That is exactly what I mean, I did not intend to question your capability. If you were in their situation and you didnt have a PE, then your suggestions would hold no weight.

But if you are a PE but not in that state, then I would think you could propose alternate designs that the original engineer would have to engineer.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

(OP)
csd72

Ok, I understand the idea, you were trying to convey.  If some one provides "Value Engineering" by proposing an alternate strutural system the value of their service is dependent on their qualifications.  If they are a PE qualified to practice structural engineer then the value of the service they provide is probably going to be fairly high.

 

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Greetings:

csd72, it is against the law to provide structural engineering services in a state that an engineer is not registered in (at least in the good ol' U.S.A).  

Additionally, it would be nice to know what part of the globe posters reside in to get a feel for their question/comments.
  
   Best regards, registeredpe in AZ

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

registeredpe,

But part of the question is is value engineering engineering. As many have said the final design of the revised scheme is usually carried out by the original engineer, so the 'value engineer' is usually there for a cost efficiency prospect only. PE laws dont necesarily apply.

I am in NY, previously residing in Australia and the UK.

RARSWC,

I meant more along the lines of competency and understanding of the implications of the changes. If a carpenter proposed changes to the structural frame then no one would listen to him because he obviously doesnt know what he is talking about.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

CSD72,

I hope you were being sarcastic with that last comment.  I've met several carpenters who knew alot more about structural design and buildability than alot of newly minted PEs (or SEs).  They may not know the difference between ASD and LFRD or have any letters after their name, but that doesn't make them incompetent.  If I were building an engineered structure, I'd definitely ask for my carpenter's input before I approved a design - I've seen way too many engineers try to get cute or just have no idea how their design would actually be built to not get some input from the man in charge of erecting it.  In that sense, a carpenter can be a great "value engineer".

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Greetings:

Then it is my humble opinion that you have not met nearly enough carpenters, I would say.

 Best regards,registeredpe in AZ

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

in my experience with value engineering (in Arizona) it has always been done by a team of engineers.  Occasionally, a contractor might also be on the team.  A certified "value engineer" might facilitate the session or not.  The result is simply a proposal which the owner and the engineer evaluate for possible implementation in the design.  This process is often required for projects receiving any federal funding.

Now, a second method of value engineering is also used here in construction contracts. It is much more informal. A contractor may make a "value engineering change proposal (VECP)" to the owner.  He will do this to lower the cost, speed up the construction or make his job easier and hopefully save some money for himself and the owner in the process.  The owner is then bound by the contract to review the VECP and possibly issue a change order to the contractor to make the change.  The review of this VECP (from an engineering standpoint) and any modifications to the plans again should be done by either the original designer or by another engineer.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

A "Value Engineering Proposal" is usually submitted to the Engineer by the contractor suggesting a change in the original spec or plans which will bring a saving to the owner.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

the contract is between the contractor and the owner, so it is always submitted to the owner.  hopefully, the owner is sophisticated enough to have an engineer review it to render an opinion on the technical merits.  However, in my experience, that unfortunately is not always the case.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

What is this "Engineers unite in support of carpenters" day? Was I meant to give a case of beer to the nearest carpenter? Or was I meant to give them a hug?

Anyway, I agree that some carpenters do have valid opinions on things to do with wood construction, but in my experience most dont. I always listen to the guy on site and if feasible, I will follow their requests.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Greetings:

csd72, I am sorry for the misunderstanding. My post was supposed to be directed to the post made by patbethea(mechanical). I agree with you on this and to further expound on the topic, it is not just limited to carpenters.

Best regards,registeredpe in AZ

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

(OP)
I live in Minnesota.  I think the answer to my question can be summed up by saying it depends on what state you live.

I posted this thread after reading another post about sealing drawings.  I didn't add this to that post because this seems to be more of a seperate topic.

May be I should have expanded my post to include other areas where people are close to the boundary between offering engineering services and not.

What I was looking for were some opinions on what a person can or can not do if they are not registered.  Again it can vary from state to state.

I do some  "engineering" for people in states where I am not registered.  However I would not consider what I do as offering engineering services for several reasons.

First of all I never represent may self as being registered in that state.  Seccond of all I never charge a fee for what I do nor do I ever solicit work.

Most of what I do would be preliminary sizing of glulam arches, beams or trusses.  I don't provided calculations and I never say that what I propose would work.  In general what I would say is that you probably need an 8 3/4" glulam between 30" to 36" deep.

On projects where the company, I work for  is supply the glulam material I will  occasionally sumbit calculations to an engineer firm in a state that I am not registered in.  However the calculations are for approval by the EOR and this is only done when the specification do not require the work to be done by a PE registered in that state.

It is rare, however, where specifications do not require the work to be done by or under the direct supervision of a PE.  Also the above rarely comes up because a large percent of projects I work on are in Iowa or Minnesota where I am registered, or in Wisconsin where another engineer I work with is registered.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

2
The term"value engineering" does not involve engineering. It usually refers to ideas or suggestions made by persons involved with a project that could save money or time.
These suggestions can be made by ANYONE but will be reviewed by the design professionals before implementation or rejection. The term value engineering should be replaced by a more approprite name.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

slien,

a star for you, short and concise

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

RARSWC, sizing framing members is considered "engineering" even if it's preliminary design work.  

As far as "value engineering" in concerned, that's a generic term for cost-evaluation and cost-cutting, which do not always add "value" and "engineering" makes it sound more important to the owner/client.  The VE recommendations are generally made by the estimators and construction management people who want to save the owner $$ and/or pad their own bottom line.  I gave the owner/client what they asked for and when the owner sides with the estimator/construction manager, it costs me $$ because I have to redesign something for free.  That's my opinion anyway.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Archeng59, if the suggestions made by the "value engineering" do not give a cost/time benefit they should not be approved. If they are beneficial, at the clients discretion, they can be implemented.
 The changes should be reviewed by the architect and structural engineer of record and they sign off.
 The changes are an addition to the original design and the professionals should be remunerated for the extra work. The cost/benefit analysis should include for additional design work. The owner/contract documents may provide a reward for these savings.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

One problem area that I haven't seen mentioned yet is the case where the owner takes the position that he/she should not have to pay for the EOR's review fees since they didn't provide an economical design to start with. Prior to doing any "value engineering" a meeting should be held among the interested parties to define the process to be followed and any expected outcomes.

I live and work in the northeast USA.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

slien, I agree with what you say.  It is my experience that getting compensated for the extra work is easier said than done.  In 15 years of providing consulting structural engineering services, I have yet to be paid to perform design changes caused by VE recommendations.  Sometimes, the changes are minimal.  Sometimes, the changes are significant.  For example, I worked on a multistory cast-in-place concrete project where we met several times during the schematic/design development phase with the CM to discuss formwork.  The CM agreed, based on their experience and cost studies, that steel pan forms and skip-joists were the most economical formwork.  When the project was finished and the bids came in from various subs, the CM decided that plywood forming would be less expensive based on one subcontractor's bid.  The CM requested that the project be redesigned to accommodate standard plywood sheet sizes could be used and eliminate ripping/cutting the 4'x8' panels.  We refused to redesign without being compensated.  The owner refused to pay extra design fees and said we did not do our due-diligence in exploring the cost-savings of the various formwork.  That claim was false, based on the SD/DD discussions and the cost estimates provided by the CM.  We redesigned the building after threats of a lawsuit.  After it was all said and done, it turns out the subcontractor lowballed the bid, submitted several change orders that the owner paid and the final costs were much more than pan forming would have been.  The owner sued the design team for failure to recognize the lowballed bid and for construction delays.  He lost but we didn't get paid for our redesign efforts either.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Make sure to put re-engineering due to VE studies in the contract as extra compensation.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

At GE, the best value engineers were very experienced on the shop floor, and we design engineers enjoyed their company. I'm sure they were not PE's or graduate engineers, either.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

archeng59,

That situation stinks. Just goes to show that we have to cover our ass all the way.

I hope you are not going to do work for them again.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

One problem with VE is that the architectural contracts typically have one or more statements about the architect providing the owner with a design that fits within the owner's budget and that the architect (and consultants) will do whatever is needed to make that happen.  There are some weasel words that might help get you paid, but it seldom happens in my opinion.  You can sue the architect and/or owner to get paid, but our fees are seldom worth the legal fees to collect.  The architects and owners know that.  Luckily, there is plenty of work to go around so we can refuse to work with the jerks on other projects.  Doesn't help our bottom line, tho.

A person doesn't have to be PE to recommend VE items, but a PE must evaluate the effects of the VE on the overall structural system.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

Apparently every state has its own definition of 'engineer.' So let me just talk about Missouri-if you aren't covered by the big umbrella "exemption" (manufacturing exemption, working for someone else exemption, etc.), and you are offering any service you are calling 'engineering', regardless of whether it actually is engineering (for instance, sales people sometimes try to call themselves 'sales engineer'), you cannot do so without having Professional Engineering (PE) license. That's the law. In practice, of course, if no engineer turns you in, you never get caught, you can do whatever you want, call yourself whatever you want. In Missouri, the Board so far can't even do much to you, other than try to publicly humiliate you in publications only a few engineers, surveyors, etc. will read; they can't even fine you (they are working to change that).

BTW--the PE laws were enacted to protect the public, so that customers shouldn't have to be savvy enough, or double check everything an engineer tells them, to trust the work of someone calling herself an 'engineer.' I would think it's unfair to expect the customer would be savvy enough to catch problems. With the degree of specialization these days, I am not sure I would catch things myself--I do a lot of structural analysis, on airplanes, but if someone told me the gusset on that bridge over there was thick enough, I can only assume the engineer who designed it knew what he was doing, and that the gusset was indeed thick enough.

May I ask about the phrase 'design services'? I have seen the phrase, not really familiar with the specifics. Is this any more than just CAD drawing services? If it isn't more, than I would think you wouldn't even need an engineering degree to sell those services. But if it is more, such as supplying estimates of fatigue life, than doesn't the engineering registration law apply?

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

In my opinion, if calculations to size structural components are not required then a person does not need to be an engineer (PE).  I meet alot of people producing house plans and small commercial projects that are not licensed architects, but call themselves "designers".  Would rebar and structural steel detailers be considered "designers" with respect to engineering related services?

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

archeng59--By 'design' do you mean 'sizing' in addition to producing a pretty picture? That is, are they making basic engineering calculations to make certain the structures don't fail? If so, sounds like you are meeting a lot of people who are breaking the law, at least they would be in Missouri and I am sure, in other states. But of course it would depend--are they working for a company, or are they doing this design themselves, one man shop, that kind of thing? One man shop, no PE, in Missouri that's against the law. If working for a design company, the owner is supposed to a) supervise the design, and b) have a PE license.

Even for projects that typically don't have 'sealed' documents, such as widgets and thingamajigs, products that are manufactured, if you are designed, doing more than drawing, in Missouri you have to have a PE because you are offering your services as an engineer. Of course that doesn't mean the law is enforced, as I said before.

RE: Does one have to be a P.E. to do "Value Engineering"

the "designers" I'm talking about are producing architectural plans, elevations and sections for houses or small commercial projects where by state law an architect is not needed.  The designers cannot produce foundation plans, framing plans or any structural details.  Many municipalities are requiring sealed and signed foundation plans prepared by a licensed structural engineer even for the projects where a licensed architect is not needed.

In Oklahoma, anyone can design things like machine parts and electronics without a PE license, but cannot call themselves an engineer.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources