×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?
3

Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

(OP)
Hello,

I have 5 well pumps ranging from 25HP-60HP. The 5 pumps are being fed from 5 VFD's. The closest VFD to a pump is 200 feet the farthest is 400 feet. The control of the pumps is from a pressure transducer the pumps try maintain a setpoint. Only 1 pump is on a PID, when called the other 4 run at 100% speed. The second pump will turn on if the PID pump runs at 100% speed for 1 minute and then  1 minute later pump #3 and so on until all 5 pumps are running. To shut off the reverse is true if PID pump falls below 95% speed for 1 minute it turns off pump 2 a minute later until all pumps off except PID pump.
There is also a low pressure cutout switch if PSI falls below 30 no pumps can run unless done manually.
Does anyone have any suggestions as to why 2 pumps have failed in the last month?

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

What do you mean by "pumps failed"?  Do you mean damage to the pumps or damage to the motors or something else?  Long distances between VFD and motor can cause problems with the "reflected wave phenomena" which has been discussed in many threads in this forum.  Search the forum for those and other similar words.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

(OP)
VFD would fault off.I had continuity between pump motor leads and ground(earth)

Thanks

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Any chance the two that have failed were on the longest two cables?

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

OK, when the pumps “failed” you had conductivity from the motor leads to ground. This means the motor insulation has been pierced.  Find the Emerson submersible motor site on the web and look at their requirements for load side inductors for use with VFD’s. The fast rise times of common VFD (dv/dt) cause extremely high momentary voltages every 120th of a second on each phase wire. The load side inductors round the corners of the pulses and remove, or lessen the high voltage transients. The problem is at it’s worst at 480 volts and load conductors over 75 feet, getting worse as voltage increases and distance grows. With submersible well pumps, it is VERY easy to lose motors when load side inductors are omitted.
Steve

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

OK, I know I am going to catch it from the VFD guys here but, this is the kind of problem I deal with everyday.  Yes the VFD is causing motor failures.  The longer the wire, the higher the  voltage spikes to the motor.  Load side inductors only lessen the problem, and is just one more expense added to an already expensive and complicated installation.  Motor manufacturers love Drives, because that means they get to sell you motors more often.

Submersible motors can last 20 to 30 years when installed correctly, and running on smooth sinusoidal AC voltage, as with an across the line starter.  Of course motor manufacturers don't like this so, they are always going to suggest a Drive.  

This is a case where you don't need Drives.  Four of the five pumps run at full speed all the time anyway.  Which means the drives are costing you extra energy, and reducing the life of the motors.  The one pump that does use a PID loop, could easily be controlled by other means like, dare I say it, a simple control valve.

I would solve the problem by removing the Drives.  As someone on this forum keeps reminding us, "you can't solve the problem by using the same kind of thinking that caused the problem in the first place".

Of course in some states they give you cash incentives to install Drives, which creates the kinds of problems you are having now, and usually doesn't save any energy.  Even in a different situation where a Drive might be able to save some energy, there is no way to do the math which shows the effect of short life of the motors and other equipment.  A Drive would have to save a LOT of energy to be able to justify replacing the motors so frequently, not to mention frequent replacing of the Drives themselves, when otherwise all the equipment should last decades without the least bit of maintenance.  

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Amen.

Yes, you probably need to install motor reactors.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Valvecrazy is correct that if the pumps are running at full speed that you shouldn't be using VFDs, it is a waste of energy and money.  I will reserve judgement on the last pump which varies its speed to maintain pressure until you give the system hydraulics.  There is a very long thread regarding this if you care to read it, http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=205555&page=3

I was so interested in answering his question that I didn't pay much attention to his initial statements.  That being said it is most likely an incorrect application of the VFD that caused the problem.  I recommend that you read the following application guide for VFDs.  http://www.nema.org/stds/acadjustable.cfm#download

This guide will NOT apply exactly if you have a submersible pump motor since this is not a standard NEMA motor configuration however the general principles apply.  If you have a submersible pump motor then follow the recommendations of the motor manufacturer (not the drive manufacturer, which is probably written for NEMA motors).  

You can get some information on VFDs and submersible pump applications at http://www.goulds.com/product.asp?ID=174&MASTERID=2 and http://www.goulds.com/product.asp?ID=281&MASTERID=2.

Constant pressure control may not be the best control algorithm to accomplish your objectives.  If you look at the Gould's Aquavar VFD control they have an algorithm which varies the pressure with the flow so that there is always sufficient pressure to meet demand without providing excess pressure which wastes energy.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

I know that there is a voltage loss when using a line reactor or filter, which increases the amperage and heat.  The last line filter I observed reduced the voltage coming into the Drive from 480 volts to 462 volts, and increased the amperage proportionally.  I also observed considerable heat coming from the line filter itself.  How would you figure heat or power losses from the line or load reactors or filters?  Also when you have a voltage drop because of a line or load filter, how does the increase in amperage and heat affect overall power consumption, compared to a Drive without any filters?

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Valvecrazy A "line filter" can mean almost anything.  If it was a line reactor that you observed on the output of a drive it was probably due to your measurement device which will not work well on the output of a VFD.  Or there could have been poor connections.  

You can see what the loss is for typical line reactors at http://www.mtecorp.com/instr-011_line-loadreactor_060227.pdf, see pages 25 and 26.  The losses are relatively low.  

The drop in voltage and increase in amperage does not affect the power consumption by the motor unless the voltage goes outside the typical rated limits for motors.  The increase in power can be measured by the loss in the filter/line reactor which can be measured by I2Z or I*DELTAV*SQRT3.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

I was reading voltage and amperage on the input to the drive, before and after connecting the reactor.  So the supply voltage to the Drive was reduced by the reactor, which increased the amperage.  This increase in amperage must increase the overall heat losses but, I don't know how to add that back in to the equation.

Thanks for the link Gepman.  If I am reading it right, it shows about 40 watts loss for each reactor on about a 20 HP load, and the losses increase as the FLA increases.  Just something else that should be added back into energy use calculations.  There is also a little less than 1% loss on an active harmonic filter as discussed in a previous thread.  Every time you add a filter, you are losing something.  These numbers may seem insignificant but, when there is only a few percent difference in power consumption between a drive and no drive, they become very significant.  

However, a percent or two extra power consumption by a filter or reactor, is much less significant than the motor and or Drive, not lasting as long as an Across The Line Starter, and a motor running on smooth sinusoidal AC power.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

powersoff, we have similar problems at our facility.  Check your VFD’s operational manual for the recommended carrier frequency, and verify this setting on your drive.  I found several good references on IEEE Xplore, but really haven’t determined the best design approach for today’s IGBT VFD(s).  The two best reads I've found are:

1. Reflected wave modeling techniques for PWM AC motor drives, By Skibinski, G.; Kerkman, R.; Leggate, D.; Pankau, J.; Schlegel, D. This paper appears in: Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition, 1998. APEC '98. Conference Proceedings 1998., Thirteenth Annual,Page(s): 1021 - 1029 vol.2, 15-19 Feb 1998
Volume: 2 Issue

2. Cable characteristics and their influence on motor over-voltages
By Skibinski, G.; Leggate, D.; Kerkman, R.
This paper appears in: Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition, 1997. APEC '97 Conference Proceedings 1997., Twelfth Annual
Page(s): 114 - 121 vol.1, 23-27 Feb 1997
Volume: 1 Issue

Currently, I’m waiting on more information from Southwire (www.southwire.com).   They design a triplex conductor interlaced with grounding conductor system.  From what I gather the peak voltage destroying the motor systems is due to twice the dc bus voltage times the impedance mismatch ratio of the motor and cable.  There is nothing you can do about the motor impedance (short of inverter duty design motors), but the cable impedance can be altered (i.e. line reactors). Filtering does costs and will reduce the system performance. My preference is not to filter.

Good luck.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

I found a comparison between motor voltage and the Rema curve showing typical peak voltages. This is an 800 kW dynamometer machine for truck motor testing. Grid is 690 V and standard cables have been used. No screen, no symmetric PE.

The peak voltage is very close to the theoretical limit and the motor had problems with insulation faults after only a few month's operation.

I think that reactors have been installed now. But have not done any measurements after that.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

What brands of equipment are involved in this installation.  Some brands of vdf already have output filters build in.  Also you need to look very closely at the nameplate info for the subs and conpare it to the vfd's.  sub motors as a rule of thumb pull more amperage then an above ground motor. For example the Ugly book give the fla of a 50 hp 460 vt motor at 65 while the Franklin motors o& m manual states that a 50 hp 460 volt 6" motor can pull as high as 77 amps.

Also per the manual Filters or Reactors: Required if (1) voltage is 380 or greater and (2) Drives uses igbt or bjt switches (rise-times , 2 msec) and (3) cable from the drive to the motor is more than 50 ft.  A low pass filter is preferable.  Filters or reactors should be selected in conjunction with the drive manf. and must be specifically designed for vfd operation.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

I'm still not clear on what the actual "fault" is.
The last post by powersoff mentioned "VFD would fault off.I had continuity between pump motor leads and ground(earth)"
The description of the VFD "fault off" tells me that there is a problem that the VFD is picking up. Nowhere have I seen that the motor has failed. All points mentioned so far are very valid but until we know more details from powersoff on what is the actual problem, a lot of what we say could be meaningless. It is quite possible the user has used screened cable and over such a long cable distance the screen creates a high capacitance and the VFD sees this as an over-current fault. Or, the stray capacitance due to a motor that is 400feet from it's ground point could cause the VFD to see this as a ground fault.
It is quite common that "faults" indicated by the VFD are seen by certain users as "failures" of products whereas a fault indicated by a VFD is an indication that whatever it is measuring (current, voltage, temperature...etc) has simply been measured outside the tolerance of the VFD. It doesn't always mean something had "failed".

So, powersoff, perhaps you'd like to expand further on the fault then these fine brains in VFD's and valves can provide more accurate tips before we end up saying get a bucket on a piece of rope and get your water up that way.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

(OP)
The pump motor leads  had continuity to ground causing the VFD to fault.Apparently the VFD does not like a .019ohms measurement to ground from motor lead. The wires between well head and vfd are meggered and test o.k.
The wire is direct burial cable in pvc conduit to well head.
The VFD brand is Altivar.

Thanks

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

If you checked continuity with the motor connected you could have a short (or fault) in either the motor or the motor leads.  Hopefully it is not the motor.  As I and others have mentioned the reflected wave phenomena plus the dv/dt of PWM drives can cause burn through of the insulation either in the motor or the motor leads.  Allen-Bradley does not recommend THHN/THWN conductors for their PWM drives in wet conditions which is anything underground or obviously in a well.  

The brand name Altivar is I believe a Square D brand and although not my favorite, I have used hundreds without any problems when my clients want them.  I, like others, prefer to use what we are most familiar with.  

To summarize the above replies, your best solution is to determine if the fault is in the motor or the leads, remove the VFD's where you don't need them, follow the manufacturer's recommendations for the motor if it is a submerisble pump motor (you never have really said), and install some type of attenuation device for any VFD's that remain including load reactors.  The motor leads should be rated probably at least 1000V, I usually use something like a Belden or Olflex VFD cable or at least XHHW-2.  Shielded cable as ozmosis says can cause high capacitance problems.

Let us know what your resolution is.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

A question for Gepman.  I'm going to assume (I know) that powersoff is referring to a submersible well pump. You suggested that 1000v cable be used in this application.  I'm would guess that this is so the cable does not fail due to spikes.  I would think that it would be cheaper to have the cable fail due to spike than the motor.  Therefore, my guestion is why up the cable rating?

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

thewellguy
Yours is an interesting concept but if you really want to design the system so that one component fails before the other (similar to a shear pin) then you need exact information on the dielectric capabilities, capacitance, etc. of both the motor and the conductors.  This will probably be hard to get.  Also powersoff may replace the submersible pump motor (now or later) with a better insulated unit later and then he wouldn't have to replace the cable or conductors.  

If powersoff installs a load reactor it is probably a moot point since the cable insulation would not be as much of a factor.  

My philosophy is to design the system so that no part fails.  I have used the "shear pin" method a few times but it takes good engineering information to be certain that your shear pin will fail with an overload but not with a normal load.  I don't believe that information is available in this case.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

(OP)
Just to be clear the submersible pump is smoked/fried/junk/needs to go to a motor shop to be fixed.The VFD is good and is currently controlling a brand new submersible pump.
I am grateful to all who replied and am researching options.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

I would advise a dv/dt filter between the VFD and motor in this case, as already pointed out. Submersible motors often have lower class insulation and rely on the cooling effect of the water around the motor than the typical fan cooling. It is typical that dv/dt filters or sinus filters are fitted in this case.

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Also some companies have special VSD application motors, with higher insulation class (specially made).
Also VSD manuals have guide to include dV/dt filter when the the cable lenght is over a limit and the motor is over certain HP.
Some other special guides talks about symmetrical and shielded cables (shield that is the earth conductor) and local PE.
In the mill I work for we have for all VSD, special VSD application motors (w/more insulation).

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Powersoff,  what brand and size of motor are you talking about?  Most of the submersible well pump motors of this size are not rebuildable.  Also Martinrelayer is correct all sub motors have minimum flow requirements so that there is enough water flow past the motor.  This can be reduced in some cases if a suction sleeve is placed over the motor when it is istalled.  For example a 6" motor (at full speed) in a 10" hole requires 520 gpm flow rate while the same motor in a 7" hole reuires 150 gpm flow rate per Franklin O & M manual

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Hi, I am new to the group and found this site searching for info on drives and well pumps.  I provide power quality and harmonics testing and am working on a site with two 60 hp submersible well pumps on 6-pulse VFD's.  The client is having problems with fiber optic communication interfaces that keep locking up.  The external communication interfaces are powered from the VFD's internal 24 VDC power supply.  It appears that the lock-up happens when the input voltage THD exceeds 4-5%.  My question is if anyone has seen similar problems with auxiliary equipment such as communications equipment?  Is it common to use the drive’s internal DC power supply to operate other equipment?

As a separate comment, I have used a lot of harmonic canceling transformers including phase-shifting and zig-zag type.  The phase shifting technique can work well if the loads are balanced by creating a 12-pulse load with about 12-15% current THD as compared to a 6-pulse load with 30-40% current THD.  The challenge is finding balanced loads that are on the same power source and utility and meter.  The predominate harmonics with a 6-pulse system are 5th and 7th and with a 12-pulse are 11th and 13th.  Utility primaries seem to be particularly sensitive to resonance issues at the 5th and 7th harmonics.  In my area (Nebraska and Iowa) the local utilities have adopted IEEE-519 into their rate tariffs and are now going after customers that are producing harmonic currents that exceed the standard.  The new tariffs are creating problems for sites that use VFD’s as simple line reactors and drive isolation transformers will not meet the standard.  We have had to use a passive harmonic filter made in Canada that will make a 6-pulse VFD meet the IEEE-519 standard.  We have found the passive filters are lower cost than active filters and are more reliable.  I suspect that utilities in other parts of the USA have or will be adopting the IEEE-519 into their tariffs to address the issues raised in this forum so be prepared for more challanges!

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Interesting stuff mconroy.

And welcome to Eng-Tips!

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

Welcome Mconroy
Do you know how they decide on the amount of the rate tariffs?

RE: Could distance from VFD to pump cause problems?

mconroy
welcome to Eng-Tips.
It might be better if you create a new thread concerning your posting. It means that the original post by powersoff is not hijacked.
It is possible to redflag your own thread and put a comment in for the administrator, then re-post in a new thread. You then get full attention from other users on your specific question/points.
regards
ozmosis

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources