×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008
3

SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

(OP)
SW recently changed something with their copy protection. Now even if you have saved the past updates for SW2008. If you are no longer on subscription they will not install. It states you must be on active subscription service to install service packs. What a load of BS. I had a active subscription including SP1.1 for 2008 and now it will not allow me to install on my new computer the 1.1 service pack just because we are no longer doing the subscription service. So beware to all that just downloading and keeping a copy of the service pack will not allow you to install it if you no longer do the subscription service. I have a big problem with this since I had paid for this service pack already while still on subscription.

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

!

Jeff Mowry
www.industrialdesignhaus.com
What did you dream?  It's all right--we told you what to dream.
    --Pink Floyd, Welcome to the Machine

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

I've said it before and I'll say it again.  Service packs should in no way shape or form be tied to subscription service.  If SW were releasing bug free software at Sp 0.0 it would be justifiable but they are not and never will be able to do this.  Can you think of any other software comapnies that require you to pay for bug fixes other than CAD companies?

Rob Rodriguez CSWP
www.axiscadsolutions.com
www.robrodriguez.com
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/rob_rodriguez/
Eastern Region SWUGN Representative www.swugn.org  www.nvtswug.com
SW 2007 SP 2.0

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

(OP)
Well said Rockguy

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Sounds like typical BS to me.  I wonder why they would even care?

Dan

www.eltronresearch.com

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Rocko ... a simple phone call to SolidWorks support to explain your situation should be all it takes to allow re-installation. But just remember, it's not the person at the other end of the phone who makes the rules.

cheers

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Rockguy or anyone else,

If you're going to SW World please ask SW to explain that one. Then post the reply to this fourm.

Thanks.

---SW 2008 SP1.1---

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Perhaps their goal is to keep companies with multiple seats honest, I.E. having 1 subscription and applying the service pack on multiple seats or otherwise distributing the service packs in the same manner?

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

That's why they went to Activation, because so many users were buying one seat and putting it on 10 seats... not a great way to run a business... when they got caught they paid a healthy fine. Thanks to the few bad apples that caused this to happen we all have to suffer from their stupidity.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

(OP)
That still doesnt answer why they cannot know when the SP came out and when you stopped your subscription service and allow you access to that sp. It sounds like SW being lazy and taking the easy way out! I mean they go to all the trouble of checking over the internet your license from time to time (oh yeah , you didnt know that did you). So perhaps they should do what they were paid for and provide access to features that I legitimately should have access too!

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Without upsetting you further... SW has a Database that tracks entitlment dates and the activation is part of it. I am not going to get into this issue with you or anyone else, because I have spoke my mind about this before many times.

But SW has ways of tracking users and their seats like other software companies do. Unfortunately there is nothing more that you can do at this time in regards to SP.

Maybe instead of making a bold up front question to SW, try asking your question in a different way and maybe you will get the answer your looking for.

I wish someone would answer it so these posts would get some closure... will probably make it worse though

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Can anyone answer my question?  What other software companies charge for service packs pertaining to bug fixes.  I'm not trying to stir the pot here.  I'd really like to know if there are sofwtare companies doing this other than CAD companies.

Rob Rodriguez CSWP
www.axiscadsolutions.com
www.robrodriguez.com
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/rob_rodriguez/
Eastern Region SWUGN Representative www.swugn.org  www.nvtswug.com
SW 2007 SP 2.0

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Your papers, please?

Rob--I know of none.

Jeff Mowry
www.industrialdesignhaus.com
What did you dream?  It's all right--we told you what to dream.
    --Pink Floyd, Welcome to the Machine

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

I can't give actual software names (they don't blatantly advertise their shortcomings), but I believe that many data management and financial applications (health, MRP, HR, etc) suffer from the same affliction.

cheers

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Actually, Rocko, I would contact your last VAR about your original question.  It may be a bug, or may be that they need to refine their activiation licencing scheme a little better.  Maybe someone at SolidWorks just didn't think the decsion through when they made the choice to work it that way.  Technically, you are entitled to install at least the SP you already obtained from them.

BTW, I don't know how others feel, but if you bought the software, you should be entitled to any SP's that come along for that version.  It's not piracy to install updates to your software where you already posess a current licence (having nothing to do with whether or not the subscription is current).  Some companies place a new license on the SP's, and of course, this is a sneaky and hostile act.  A subscription is not a license.  A license is a license.  I think SolidWorks is trying to blur the lines so that you have to keep paying them in order to keep the license you already own.

Matt Lorono
CAD Engineer/ECN Analyst
Silicon Valley, CA
Lorono's SolidWorks Resources
Co-moderator of Solidworks Yahoo! Group
and Mechnical.Engineering Yahoo! Group

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Actually you can get them through your VAR if you found a bug in that SP and the next one fixes it... I know that... its not that I don't disagree with any of you... I just don't see it changing anytime soon. Sorry just trying to give you guys the facts from my stand point. Been a user of SW for many years... so many I don't want to count anymore. But its what it is.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

To anyone that feels it is inappropriate to tie licensing to subscriptions, I would suggest putting in an ER that states your problem/concerns/opinion.  There is a category in the ER list for Licensing.  Like Scott said, there's prolly not much we can do, but if they see the complaint often enough, they may feel compelled to do something corrective.

Matt Lorono
CAD Engineer/ECN Analyst
Silicon Valley, CA
Lorono's SolidWorks Resources
Co-moderator of Solidworks Yahoo! Group
and Mechnical.Engineering Yahoo! Group

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

fcsuper ...
I haven't met Scott in person, but I've probably read every post he's submitted to these fora, and I can't remember him ever using the word "prolly". poke

cheers

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Well if the Joke I was told yesterday was true then you "prolly" could have met me then. I was told SWWC is in Ontario next year "As a joke". Not going this year, but suppose to next year.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

I think it was something to do with hijacking threads. wink

cheers

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

"Can anyone answer my question?  What other software companies charge for service packs pertaining to bug fixes.  I'm not trying to stir the pot here.  I'd really like to know if there are sofwtare companies doing this other than CAD companies."

Rockguy, to answer your question in a broad sense: Apple is the most obvious offender. They charge extreme amounts of cash for point releases of their OS. Apple charges full "upgrade" price to their users, even the user has a service subscription.
Similar, but not exactly the same model.

"Never offend people with style when you can offend them with substance." --Sam Brown
http://www.danielanderson.info

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Several automotive parts database softwares charge extreme amounts for database updates as well.  Starting out at around $400 a month, and it's just a database.

Cole M
CSWP, CSWST, CSWI, CPDM
HP XW4300, 3.4g proc, 2.5g RAM, ATI Fire GL 3100
Dell M90, Core 2 Duo, 2g RAM, Nvidia Quadra FX2500M
Equus (custom), P4, 3.4g proc, 3g RAM, Nvidia Quadro FX3400

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Thanks for the answers.

Are these upgrades in the sense they are new functionality or in the sense they are bug fixes?

It just seems wrong to me, no matter what the software that the user is required to pay for fixes that shouldn't have been in the softare in the first place and is clearly the fault of the software manufacturer.  If it's an upgrade or extension to existing functionality then yes the user should pay.  Along the same lines, users shouldn't be forced to upgrade for software compatability reasons.  In SW case version 2008 should read and write previous version files.

Rob Rodriguez CSWP
www.axiscadsolutions.com
www.robrodriguez.com
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/rob_rodriguez/
Eastern Region SWUGN Representative www.swugn.org  www.nvtswug.com
SW 2007 SP 2.0

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Quote:

If it's an upgrade or extension to existing functionality then yes the user should pay.  Along the same lines, users shouldn't be forced to upgrade for software compatability reasons.  In SW case version 2008 should read and write previous version files.

Not that I want to get into this debate again, but there's a bit of a contradiction there, no?

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Not necessarily. Adobe has kept it's format for PhotoShop flexible so that version 8 can read version 9 files.  The desire to upgrade is generated by adding features to the program instead of demanding upgrades to maintain file format compatibility.(As for CAD, Rhino allows version 3 to read and edit files generated in version 4.)

Getting back to the topic as a whole, I would agree that it's ludicrous to pay for fixes to a faulty product. Held to regular consumer goods standards, the Better Business Bureau would be shutting SolidWorks down and other agencies would be removing the product from the shelves.

"Never offend people with style when you can offend them with substance." --Sam Brown
http://www.danielanderson.info

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Seeing as SW is owned by Dassault, we should Blame it on the French!

Maybe if everyone protests they'll get it.

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Rockguy

You mention that SW should read and write other versions.  Do any other 3D modeling associative cad softwares do this?  I think it would be nearly impossible as new functions that require the new code may be included in the model and if you opened it in the older version those functions would fail.  Seems like common sense that that wouldn't work.  So then the complaint would be you made a model in 2008 and you want to open it in 2007 and features fail so code needs to be added to 2007 so now are you entitled to an update to 2007 b/c you were on subscription when you bought 2007?  I think if we all take a look at the big picture it's obvious the line has to be somewhere.  We're not talking about word processing or simple lines here where the code is minimal in comparison.  And it all comes down to if people weren't trying to skirt the system and "steal" software and upgrades this functionality wouldn't of been necessary.  I would think the paying customers are comforted knowing that their dollars aren't going to support those that aren't paying.

Cole M
CSWP, CSWST, CSWI, CPDM
HP XW4300, 3.4g proc, 2.5g RAM, ATI Fire GL 3100
Dell M90, Core 2 Duo, 2g RAM, Nvidia Quadra FX2500M
Equus (custom), P4, 3.4g proc, 3g RAM, Nvidia Quadro FX3400

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

I'm not aware of any other 3D CAD modeling companies that have backward compatability (although a previous posts says Rhino 3 and 4 can do this).

"So then the complaint would be you made a model in 2008 and you want to open it in 2007 and features fail so code needs to be added to 2007 so now are you entitled to an update to 2007 b/c you were on subscription when you bought 2007?"

This is not what I'm saying at all.  What I'm saying is if I purchase SW 2007 then all bug fixes released for SW 2007 should be available to me free of charge.  I should have to and would expect to pay for the upgrade to SW 2008.

As for file compatability.  If I create a file in SW2007, open the file in SW 2008, make NO modifications and save the file it will no longer work in SW 2007.  I agree it's difficult to push new functionality back to an older release and I wouldn't expect that type of compatability between versions.  However a cut extrude in 2007 is a cut extrude in 2008 and so is a boss extrude and so is a fillet and so is......well you get the point.  I see no reason why "the basics" can't have version compatability.  The simple example of opening a 2007 file in 2008 and saving rendering he file useless in 2007 is absurd to me.  This is a great example of forcing the user to upgrade to the newest version.  If you work totally by yourself and never have to interface with another computer or human staying with an older version that meets your needs is fine.  If you work with the rest of the world not upgrading means not working.

Rob Rodriguez CSWP
www.axiscadsolutions.com
www.robrodriguez.com
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/rob_rodriguez/
Eastern Region SWUGN Representative www.swugn.org  www.nvtswug.com
SW 2007 SP 2.0

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

(OP)
sldwkmin,
  How about in the case that started all this. I paid for up to SP1.1 for 2008 and now, it will not let me install it because I am no longer on subscription. This is both unethical but illegal in my opinion. I would hate to be someone who later on is on SW2008 SP?.? and no longer does the subscription(extortion as it is currently being utilized on reinstalling SP's) then gets a new Computer and reinstalls SW2008 and is stuck with SP0.0 and cannot access their designs created with SW2008 SP?.? because they were created with a later SP. That is total BS and SW needs to be nailed for this.

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

As long as the file is an '08 file, you can open it in '08 without worrying about the SP. SP's have no bearing on the ability to open files, only what version you're on.

Jeff Mirisola, CSWP
Certified DriveWorks AE
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/jeffs_blog
Dell M90, Core2 Duo
4GB RAM
Nvidia 3500M

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

sldwkmin, by "associative" do you mean parametric?

I guess that's where I see the difference in the market right now. As for other high end apps, whether it be graphics, CAD, or audio editing, the compatibility issues are not prominent enough to demand a subscription service for fixes. In these instances, there is little or no "patching" of the older program needed to read newer files.
Application development for other disciplines offers precedent to support the idea that compatibility can be built into a file format.

Perhaps parametric relationships inside a SW file is indeed complex enough to merit upgrading your core engine code in order for version files to be compatible.
Personally, I think this could be solved if Dassault ever wanted to cut this very lucrative income generator.

Finally, back to the big picture, this isn't about being able to open 2008 files in 2007. It's about having to pay through the nose for fixes. If you bought a new tv and audio only worked on the odd channels, you'd call the manufacturer or retailer and demand compensation or exchange for a faulty product. Would you be alright being told that the only fix for the problem was to pay a subscription fee?

"Never offend people with style when you can offend them with substance." --Sam Brown
http://www.danielanderson.info

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

(OP)
JMirisola,
  That is not always the case, I remember back last year on SW2007 their was an issue with changes to an SP that would not allow a previous SP open them. I am not trying to instigate an issue with you , just pointing out that it did happen one time during SW2007 numerous SP's.

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Ok, generally, SPs don't cause that problem. Obviously, it was a case of "fixing this, breaking that".

Jeff Mirisola, CSWP
Certified DriveWorks AE
http://designsmarter.typepad.com/jeffs_blog
Dell M90, Core2 Duo
4GB RAM
Nvidia 3500M

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Just a FYI...updated to SP2.0
No problems.

Chris
SolidWorks/PDMWorks 08 2.0
AutoCAD 06
ctopher's home (updated 10-07-07)
ctopher's blog

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Quote:

If you work totally by yourself and never have to interface with another computer or human staying with an older version that meets your needs is fine.  If you work with the rest of the world not upgrading means not working.

Rob,

If you work with the rest of the world and need to upgrade to keep pace, is that not a function of the business model?  I fail to see how that is the fault of Solidworks.

I'm strictly speaking of upgrades here.  IMO, this is a completely separate issue than service packs/bug fixes.

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Folks, there is a cure for all this angst;

Step 1:  put in an enhancement request, as suggested

Step 2:  take a deep breath

Step 3:  Switch to CATIA V5 for a year or two

Step 4:  Switch to Solidworks

Now your software will be far, far cheaper, less buggy, with great support and far easier to use than what you've been on for the last year.  Oh, and did I mention that you will now get technical support with your subscription?  That will be a nice change for you after using V5...

Life is good!

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

FYI, there is some new functionality added in SP's that most of you are not aware of. its minimal stuff, but there is still new stuff added in Service packs.

I noticed you complaints are more about fixes and you think that fixes should be free. I had forgotten about this during my last post, but there are new slight enhancments per service pack. See the Release notes. That is where you can find other improvements that are not in the What's new.

If they were just fixes, then this would be a different post.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: SW New Copy Protection Is a Big Problem Beware for 2008

Also from my understanding now SW is allowing users to DL the full version off the web if you choose too. You don't need the DVD's anymore. So if you don't have access to a DVD-Rom, they say you can DL the full version and install SW to any machine. The service packs will also update the 0.0 install without first updating to the DVD like we had too before.

So if they made this site available to everyone without subs, then they would be giving the software away for free then!

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP pc2
www.scottjbaugh.com

Quote:

"If it's not broke, Don't fix it!"
FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources