×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

MCC Low Megger Reading

MCC Low Megger Reading

MCC Low Megger Reading

(OP)
We were taking megger readings (phase to ground and phase to phase) for an MCC before first-time energization, and the results that we're getting were below 1.0 gega ohms. All the other MCC's on site registered greater than 2.2 gega ohms for the same test. We noticed that once we start pulling out buckets one by one the megger reading started to increase. Eventually, the megger reading was greater than 2.2 gega ohms when about half of the buckets were pulled out. Do you know what could be causing this current leakage and how we can fix it? Thanks

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

Just a question: are all the fuses pulled from the PT's?

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

(OP)
We have a voltmeter on the horizontal MCC bus that is fused.  Other than that we have no other PT's in the MCC.  Does that answer your question?

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

Are the readings the same for phase to ground as they are for phase to phase?  There could be some kind of circuit in your buckets that obtains power from two phases which has an extremely high but additive parallel resistance (they also may be toast by now).  Is there anything different about the type of starters or other devices that you have in this MCC versus the other MCCs?

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

(OP)
gepman, the phase to ground reading are pretty much the same as the phase to phase (minor difference).  The MCC's contains a mix of E3 Plus type overload starters and fuse disconnects ... same as the other MCC's we have.

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

Is the reading different with the fused disconnects open than with the fused disconnects closed?  Do you have more buckets in this MCC than the other MCCs?

I don't see anything in the E3Plus manual that would indicate that it would be a problem but it is a self powered solid state device.

If the readings change with the disconnect position then you know that the problem is after the disconnect.  You could remove an E3Plus and check the resistance between phase leads.  

If that doesn't narrow it down or solve your problem then I would contact A-B.  

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

Whats the voltage rating of the MCC's and the Megger test voltage? 1.0 G isnt bad with several buckets in the circuit.

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

After thinking about it some more I am inclined to agree with Zogzog that the value isn't bad.  The relative values between the different MCC's tested (depending on the type of megger test) should be somewhat proportional to the size of the MCC or the number of buckets.  It would be expected that the this latest MCC would have a lower reading if it had twice as many buckets.  Were the environmental conditions the same for each test especially humidity and dust?  Was this a 30 or 60 second spot test or was it a 10 minute test?

If they were similar sized MCCs in similar environments then I would contact A-B about their recommended test procedure and minimum test results.

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

I am going to assume we are talking about a 480/600 volt class MCC. Insulation resistance values this high are of little concern. Accurate resistance measurements of several hundred Mega ohms and higher are very dependant on a number of conditions. Environmental conditions can play a big role. Is this section of MCC a little dustier? Is it a little warmer? Is it a little more humid in this location?

Come back when you have resistance values in the 1Mega ohm range and we can talk. Accurately measuring resistance values in the Giga ohm range requires precision equipment, controlled environmental conditions and a skilled technician.

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

(OP)
Thank you for all your responses.  The MCC is 600V, 800A bus rating, 3 wire, 3 phase,  and it is 7 section long.  The MCC is located in an electrical room around 10 degrees C (50 F).  We have MCC's that are 12 sections long and they all meggered aboved 2.2 G-ohm. When the MCC's are meggered all disconnects are in the open position.  

We initially thought that there could be some moisture in the MCC, so we directed warm air from a unit heater inside the MCC bus and left the starter buckets open. The megger reading was taken and it was even lower than before, around 300 M-ohm (which doesn't make sense to me).  We kept the heat running for 24 hours and the reading stayed the same.  Then we removed the heat, waited few hours, and the reading went up to 700 M-ohm.

I hope this helps. Thanks again!

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

Did you tempature correct your readings after using the heater? If not, then thats why they appeared to go down and back up after the heater was removed.

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

(OP)
Zogzog, no I didn't correct @ different temps.  But should the resistance go up when the temp inceases?

RE: MCC Low Megger Reading

With 600 V equipment, I don't bother as long as the values are over 600 MOhm.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources