PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
(OP)
I read a good exchange on functionality and merits of DCS vs. PLC (see thread698-161284: DCS or PLC?). Now that DCS functional often includes logical controls, instrumented process trips (i.e. interlocks) can be easily programmed into most DCS systems. However, as noted in referenced threads, critical trip systems are often implemented in dedicated PLC, particularly when high reliability is required (e.g. emergency shutdowns - ESD).
Is anyone aware of instrument symbology to differentiate operational interlocks that may be implemented in DCS from safety-instrumented interlocks (SIS) that must be implemented in ESD or PESS (programmable electronic safety system)? We have been using standard ISA symbology for all interlocks (using boxed hexagon)on P&IDs. However, creates ambiguity on whether trip system is SIS or an operational interlock or sequential control element. I have asked a couple of instrument engineers, but apparently there is no standard ISA symbol for differentiating a PESS from a PLC. Has anyone found a good way to do that short of labelling each symbol on the P&ID?
Is anyone aware of instrument symbology to differentiate operational interlocks that may be implemented in DCS from safety-instrumented interlocks (SIS) that must be implemented in ESD or PESS (programmable electronic safety system)? We have been using standard ISA symbology for all interlocks (using boxed hexagon)on P&IDs. However, creates ambiguity on whether trip system is SIS or an operational interlock or sequential control element. I have asked a couple of instrument engineers, but apparently there is no standard ISA symbol for differentiating a PESS from a PLC. Has anyone found a good way to do that short of labelling each symbol on the P&ID?





RE: PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
"Do not worry about your problems with mathematics, I assure you mine are far greater."
Albert Einstein
Have you read FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies to make the best use of Eng-Tips Forums?
RE: PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
RE: PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
Sorry for the cut and paste error in my reply
RE: PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
I have thought about using a boxed diamond (i.e. diamond within a square) for SIS rather than boxed hexagon which we use as our standard symbol to denote PLC I/O on P&IDs.
I can define symbols on legend sheet, but am interested to learn if there is a common practice in the absence of ISA standard for designating PESS input/outputs.
Thanks for feedback so far!
RE: PES vs. PLC vs. ESD
______________________________________________________________________________
This is normally the space where people post something insightful.