×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

5 story wood building

5 story wood building

5 story wood building

(OP)
We just got a new project, and it happens to be a  4 & 5 story wood apartment building.  We've never designed a 5 story building and I've been tasked with researching the topic.  Particularly, the lateral stability aspects of a 5 story wood structure.  Can you point me somewhere?  Thanks.  

RE: 5 story wood building

Been doing a lot of those recently, and many contractors are specifically asking for the ATS Holddown system in lieu of other holddowns.  FYI.

Mike McCann
McCann Engineering

RE: 5 story wood building

As stated previously, make sure that you have some way to account for the shrinkage of the wood when it comes to the hold-down anchors.

RE: 5 story wood building

(OP)
Thanks guys for the help.  I'll be sure and post when I'm done with my research.  

RE: 5 story wood building

Skicat,
The "2006 IBC Structural/Seismic Design Manual, volume 2", which is published by the SEAOC has a detailed example of a 3-story, light framed hotel structure. In fact, there are two example designs; one for a wood framed building and one for a cold formed steel structure.
The book cost about $70.

RE: 5 story wood building

5 stories seems like a hugh amount of vertical load to have to bear on wood studs. I'd be very careful about that too. It seems that the lower floor will be solid studs. Openings would have so many jack studs... seems difficult.

RE: 5 story wood building

To add: When you start getting into 5 story wood buildings you need to be confident the contractor has had experience in commercial wood structures.  Otherwise you'll likely end up with someone who's done small crap and has squeaked by with poor details.....who will likely be a pain throughout the entire process.  complaining about overdesign and "why do I need that blocking", "how come there's so many straps", "is it really a big deal to take a chainsaw to your shearwall?"

Need to make sure the species you're using can handle 5 stories.  I dont think the typical SPF will work in most cases.  Note plate crushing too especially around areas where you have stacking elevator lobbies, etc where you get larger loads.

RE: 5 story wood building

To be honest, I have never heard of a five story wood framed building.  Before the IBC came out, you could not build higher than three stories with wood, not for structural reasons, but due to the risk of fire.  This is why most of the hotels you see along the interstate are only three stories tall.  I think the IBC allows five story wood structures only if they are fully sprinkled.

But, even if the Code allows it, is it a good idea?

DaveAtkins

RE: 5 story wood building

DaveAtkins

Can you tell me where the IBC Code allows a 5 story wood building. Typically its 3 stories max.

RE: 5 story wood building

(OP)
Thanks again for all of your help.  We've never seen a 5 story wood structure before.  There seem to be 3 main areas of concern.  First, the fire protection.  I think we have to use fire retardent material.  Second, lateral stability.  5 storys of wood in 100 mph wind is difficult.  Finally, as previously mentioned, the ability for wood studs to take the huge gravity loads.  Thanks again for all of the helpful ideas.  I'll be sure to post when I start to crunch some numbers.  

RE: 5 story wood building

cap4000,

I did not research the IBC regarding how many stories a wood framed structure can be.  Maybe it is only 4 stories--I don't know.

But your link references the IRC, not the IBC.

DaveAtkins

RE: 5 story wood building

Sorry--my mistake.  I did not read the whole article.  The article does reference the IBC.

DaveAtkins

RE: 5 story wood building

Try LSL studs toward the bottom if you are worried about capacity.  They are much stronger, but probably about twice as expensive.

RE: 5 story wood building

A few notes for taller timber buildings:

* point loads on your top plates get more important and these need to be specifically checked. You may need triple top plates in some cases.
*a change of stud spacing can also effect the top plates.
* ensure that all point loads are followed down to ground.
* transfer of axial loads through floor plates needs to be carefully looked at.
* axial effects from wind overturning can be significant.

csd

RE: 5 story wood building

I designed a 5-story wood building several years ago under the UBC code.  It was difficult to make the bearing walls on the first floor work because of the strength reduction in Chapter 7 for fire resistance.  Many structural engineers seem unaware of this reduction.

In the IBC it is found in footnote m of Table 720.1(2).  You should check whether this reduction applies to your project.

RE: 5 story wood building

Remember that cross grain bearing is often the limiting fctor. Not sure of the capacity for LSL's if used as plates but that may be as much the issue and the actual stud itself.

RE: 5 story wood building

City of Seattle does allow 5 story wood structures, but must be fully sprinklered.  Usually, overall, they are 7 to 8 story structures, with 2 to 3 stories if PT slabs for parking and the podium slab.

Mike McCann
McCann Engineering

RE: 5 story wood building

Portland, Oregon allows 5 story under the UBC and IBC. Special inspection is required for nailing, stapping, holdowns.

Studs on the lower two floors will be 4x or 3x's depending on the wall layout, height. Regardless the shearwalls will require a wider nailing to work with the tighter nail spacing.

We try to utilize kiln dry plates, or engineered lumber to minimize shrinkage. Typically the majority of the shrinkage over the floors comes from the plates, two top plates and a sill per level at 1/8" per plate (approx) adds up to 3/8" per floor times five levels fairly significant.

If you are putting this on top of a concrete podium it is important to use line loads in lieu of a estimated projected surface load. We have reviewed projects were a non-conservative psf load was use and deflections were a big issues.


Recently heard that lumber is at a 20 year low due to the surplus due to the downturn in the residential market. So good time to go to wood.

Regards,



RE: 5 story wood building

Contact the Western Wood Products Association.  In the past they published several case studies on four and five story buildings.  

In Minnesota prior to 1990 there were probably over a dozen 4 story wood frame apartment buildings built in the Minneapolis area and at least one five story building.  

For the last 13-14 years I have not been dealing with the code requirements for heights and area so I don't know what the current limits are.

There are several things you can do when designing this type of building.  One is to run your floor joist parallel with the outside walls.  This puts less weight on your bearing walls and more dead load on the shear walls pependicular to the outside walls.  Most contractors do not want to do this instead they want to run long span floor trusses and dump all the load into the corridor and outside walls.

When roof and floor trusses are used at 24" o.c. place a stud at every truss location.  16" o.c. spacing can be used adding an extra stud every 4' of wall at the truss that doesn't line up with the 16" o.c. spacing.

To properly detail the building you must accurately calculate the wood shrinkage and if you are using brick veener you must also calculate the brick expansion.

Plate crushing often is a problem because in many areas of the US they use SPF studs for top plates.  In the past when I have designed multstory wood framed buildings I specified that the bearing stress under the roof trusses was to be less than 425 psi.  If you don't do that the truss designer will base his bearing on the bearing stress of his bottom chord which will probably be 625 psi or higher.
 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources