×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing
2

Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

(OP)
I have a deaerator with a surge tank below to serve as Boiler Feedwater to gas fired boilers. We use a sulfite for oxygen scavenging. The deaerator has a continuous blowdown line for further non-condensables removal.

Somewhere along the line, someone advised the plant population that a 18-inch plume should be visible to confirm proper oxygen removal. I am guessing that this was a rul-of-thumb that just confirms that there is a bleed off point, but I would like to know anyone else's experiences with this.

Furthermore, I am wondering what sizing criteria should be used for this removal line. We were planning on creating a gravity separation of the condensate and non-condensables using a vertically aligned Tee. I am unsure of the guidelines for sizing this line and if there is some plume length required.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

Where is this "blowdown" line?  Blowdown usually connotes a liquid line at a low point in a process or vessel.  Might you mean a "blow off" line located at the top of the deaerator?

If so, it was common in the old days to have a gate valve in this line with a hole drilled in the gate so that it would continuously vent while the valve was closed.  The valve could be opened during start up conditions when there was lots of non condensables to vent and closed when in operation.  The size of the hole was determined by the deaerator manufacturer.  The piping size wasn't very large, normally 1/2" or 3/4".

I like the 18" rule of thumb although I never hear it before.

rmw

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

dogbertcountry2:

With all due respect, your use of the words "blowdown" and "non-condensibles" is confusing. As pointed out by rmw, there is no "blowdown" from a typical deaerator. Instead there is a vent on top of the deaerator.

The function of a deaerator is to use steam to strip dissolved air from the incoming boiler feedwater (so as to lower the the oxygen content of the boiler feedwater). The stripped-out air exits via the vent. We don't usually refer to that stripped-out air as "non-condensibles" in this context.

Perhaps the very simplified diagram of a typical deaerator shown below will help:

Milton Beychok
(Visit me at www.air-dispersion.com)
.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

(OP)
rmw, thank you for your response and demonstrated ability to understand a problem and answer the question, despite the phrasing. I did indeed mean "blow-off" from the top of the deaerator. I was unaware of the history progression that you offered. Again, many thanks.

mbeychok, thanks for the lesson, but an answer would have been more helpful. You misspelled and misquoted "non-condensables" by the way. Furthermore, air, in a typical manufacturing plant, is considered a non-condensable. I recognize the use of the term "blowdown" is inappropriate - as noted by rmw by correcting to "blow off". Perhaps you are unfamiliar with un-exact plant jargon. Neverthelless, thanks for the response. I asked for what other people thought.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

dogbertcountry2 (Chemical)
I have no comments on size/length of plume.
Other than rule of thumb or recommendation of DA vendor, the sizing of vent line should be based on max expected flow rate of air in a line with 100 %RH. Of course upstream and downstream pressures/temp and friction effects will also guide.

Regards

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

dogbertcountry2:

I did not misspell condensibles. My Webster's dictionary has both spellings ... condensible and condensable.

When a condenser is involved (as on the overhead of a distillation column, for one example), we speak of condensibles and non-condensibles. A deareator is not a condenser, it is a stripper and it is removing air from the incoming boiler feedwater... and, therefore, I found your use of the word non-condensibles (or non-condensables) to be somewhat inappropriate. Hence, I decided to include a sketch. I regret that my response seems to have offended you for some reason.

You may be right, perhaps after 50 years of designing and operating oil refineries and other plants, I may not be familiar with industry jargon.

I really appreciated your gracious thanks.


Milton Beychok
(Visit me at www.air-dispersion.com)
.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

Wow Dogbert,

Based on your original question including the apparent misunderstanding of a blowdown vs. blowoff, I thought MBeychok's first response was completely appropriate providing you with the most basic information required.

You ask for help, he attempts to provide it, and in return he receives an insult.  Good luck getting advice from this site in the future.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

ditto toothless's comments!

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

(OP)
Dear mbeychok,

I am humbly writing in response to my inappropriate response from a few days ago. Please accept my sincerest apologies. I am sure that given your wealth of years within both industry and in life, that you too have.... reached a breaking point. Indeed, I have met mine. I have prided myself in rising above such hurdles in years past, but alas, I have fell victim to...... stress. And my reply was given during this breakdown.

Regardless, this does not excuse nor justify my behavior. I only hope that you will to coninue to help those who request help and do not let my demonstrated foul spirit keep others from benefitting from your experience and wisdom.

Again, I offer my apologies.

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

I'll give you a star for that.  A really professional post.

rmw

RE: Deaerator Blowdown Pipe Sizing

dogbertcountry2:

Apology accepted.

Milt Beychok

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources