×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

100 amp low voltage power source

100 amp low voltage power source

100 amp low voltage power source

(OP)
I'm looking for a low dollar method to provide 100 plus amps,  either AC or DC, probably for an extended period, to test some bolted connections' resistances.  With the connection likely having a small fraction of an ohm resistance I think I don't need more than a volt or 2.
I've been thinking of tranformers or one of those 6 volt car battery with the external series connector links cut and run in parallel.

I bet many of you have much more clever ways to accomplish this.

Thanks,
Dan T

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

You could try a high ratio current transformer with a few turns of heavy cable through the window. Energize the 5 amp winding with a variac. The combined resistance of the cable and the joint under test must be low enough that the 1^R of the circuit does not exceed the rated burden of the CT.
respectfully

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

A big CT is a definite possibility - ideally make sure it a Class X type with a high kneepoint voltage so you can connect it to the mains supply through a Variac. The thing to look for is basically cross section area of the core and the weightof the CT. More cross section = better. More weight generally = better.

I recently picked up an Agilent 6681A 8V 580A DC power supply for £750 if the DC route is more appealing. It is 'transportable' rather than 'portable' at over 50kg, if that is a factor.
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

AC test current will give you impedance readings, not resistance unless you do some fancy phase angle measurements.  Use DC test current.  

There are low resistiance tests sets available for rent that are designed to measure resistance of high-ampacity, low-resistance bolted connections.  (Biddle's -Digital Low Resistance Ohmeter - DLRO is one unit.)  They read directly in micorohms or milliohms by pushing 10A or 100A DC current through the connection, measuring the millivolt drop and calculating the connection resistance.  The portable tst sets are momentary units and cannot be used to heat up a connection with a continuous current.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Arc Welder?

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

I like the welder. That and a mili-volt reading with a DVM.
I would not expect a bolted connection to exhibit much induction but if it did I may be more interested in the impedance than just the resistance. Also, the impedance will always be equal or greater than the resistance so if it passes an AC test (based on voltage drop across the joint under test) it should also pass the DC test. Granted, in many instances such as motor or transformer windings the difference between a DC test and an AC test is considerable.
respectfully

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

(OP)
waross,

Were you refering to the .707 differenced in hipot testing with AC vs DC?  That makes sense to me, since it is the voltage that stresses the insulation, and an AC signal is briefly 1.4X the nominal voltage.

In my test the insulation is of no concern.  We just need to be sure the joint/contact resistance is low and stays low.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Hi Tmoose;
I was referring to the difference between impedance and resistance. In a motor or transformer winding there is a significant difference between resistance and impedance.
An AC test will measure impedance, a DC test will measure resistance.
Impedance (Z) = (R^2 + X^2)^.5
Resistance = R
Reactance = X
A bolted joint is not expected to display reactance so the impedance should equal the resistance.
respectfully

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

I think was Waross is saying in a round about way is that if these bolted connections are being built to carry 60hz AC current then you should test with 60hz AC current. If they are being built to carry DC current then test with DC current.

Buy a 200VA, 120VAC to 1VAC transformer and feed it with a variac. Might be cheaper than the CT.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

A resistive joint - negligible reactance - will measure the same using an AC or DC source. At power frequencies a bolted joint in a busbar will have no appreciable reactance. An AC source will be easier to build cheaply than a low ripple DC source.
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Buy a microohmeter! Or IR scan the connections under full load coniditions.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

(OP)
I think we suspect a low resistance measured by tiny test voltages might not force the joint to reveal its true feeling about high current.

That's why we are pursuing the big amp power source.

The technical leader just upped the ante, to ~1000 amps,  for a many hours.  (!!)

Considering I (a short timer) had not heard anyone mention aggressively testing our joints before I started whining about it, this is in some ways a surprising development.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Depending what size busbar you are measuring a micro-ohm meter might not be good enough. We struggle to get reliable readings on generator busbars unless there is something desperately wrong with the joint. A nano-ohm meter would be nice, but commercial products are rare and have poorer resolution than a heavy current source and a laboratory class multimeter. Watch for thermal EMFs at low volt-drops if you use a DC source.

I've successfully used the big DC supply to measure the resistance of the 2500A conductor on a 275kV bushing at the request of the manufacturer and I needed every amp I could throw at it. They were demanding 10nΩ precision to give us a go / no-go on a brazed joint which had failed on one of the other bushings from the batch - easy in their test facility with a 7.5 digit meter, a stable temperature, and a huge DC source, but bloody hard with the bushing on the transformer!
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

NETA World, the magazine of the interNational Electrical Testing Association, recently ran an article talking about using AC millivolt drop testing in lieu of the traditional method of using DC via a digital low range ohmmeter.  

The gist of the article is that there can be sizable inaccuracies hidden in the AC millivolt drop test due to the unmeasured power factor components.  A relatively small increase in the total millivolt drop may be entirely due to a significant change in the resistive component of the measurement.

In other words, mV drop readings of 130, 150 and 130 may have within them resistive components of 15, 35 and 15 micro-ohms resistance, and this might be overlooked instead of investigated and corrected.

old field guy

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Hi Scotty
Thanks for the heads up on the thermal voltages. Am I correct in surmising that the thermal voltages will reflect the difference between the temperature of the joint and the temperature of the meter?
Respectfully

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Go back to why are we testing?  If the concern is how well has the joint been assembled in a design that has already been proven, then a resistance measurement of a joint may be all that is needed.  Results can be compared to tests on similar joints or compared bewteen phases.

If you are trying to decide if a new connection design will carry 1000 amps AC in your machine, running 1,000A AC through the joint and monitoring temperatures with thermocouples or infrared would give better data.

The micro-ohmeter check we used was always to verify the condition of a joint or a contact in a system whose design had been proven.  We were just checking the quality of the installation or the condiiton of some aged equipment. (Examples- checking intercell connections on battery banks, contact resistance on disconnect switches, bolted joint connections on smaller bus bar.)

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

olfieldguy,

It really comes down to understanding the item you are testing and picking the appropriate test method. It is certainly possible to get erroneous results though poor choice of test method.

rcwilson,

Can I add to your excellent question 'Why are we testing' some others: 'What exactly are we testing' and 'How accurate do you need the results'. The latter inevitably leads to a third question, 'How much are you prepared to pay for that accuracy'?

waross,

The thermal EMFs occur due to the thermocouple effect of dissimilar metals in contact where the test probes meet the object being measured, where the probes meet the test leads, where the leads meet the instrument, etc. A few microvolts of thermal EMF causes havoc when it is large percentage of the volt-drop you are looking for! Good commercial micro-ohm meters use an automatic technique where the voltage probe connection is reversed during the test so the thermal EMF cancels when the two readings are averaged. Home-built test rigs for special or awkward jobs don't have the luxury of this feature so it has to be done manually.
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Simple, find an old transformer about 1 KVA, remove the secondary and replace with a few turns of welding cable in parallel. If you have a variac available this will give you a nice smooth power supply and should put out about 1,000 Amps for a short period. I have used this to test switchgear. Figure out the Volts / turn by counting the secondary turns or with about 10 turns of 18 gauge wire
Roy

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

After six months does he still care? And I think this solution was suggested in the first reply, with some good discussion of some of the shortcomings of using an AC test source followinbg in later posts. The problem is 'Simple' if you don't care about accuracy.

Did you read any of this thread?
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Advanced Test Equipment Corp. offers on rental low voltage but high current test set for circuit breakers. Maybe they can help.

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

ScottyUK,
         Then why are you still reading it? I fail to see how using a low burden CT can be any more accurate, surely you would be doing a Drop Test . I agree if you kept the leads real short and voltage very low a CT would work but surely the core will saturate fairly quickly. I have used the method I proposed to test switchgear trips up to and over 1KA.
Yes I did read the previous old posts, lots of people do, to get ideas, otherwise they would be taken off after a few days.

Regards
Roy

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Roy,

Who mentioned a low burden CT?

A typical Class X CT is capable of producing some fairly large voltages at currents considerably in excess of the nominal secondary current rating. It isn't uncommon to find them with a kneepoint voltage of 800V or so, which means they will connect directly to a voltage source up to (say) 415V in the UK or 480V in the US. I have one which needs either a fork lift or four men to lift, to give some idea of scale. In the mode of use Bill and I suggested the CT is behaving just like a voltage transformer, but is physically more amenable to having a few turns of heavy cable or bar looped through the aperture.

There really isn't any difference in what we are proposing other than the hassle of chopping the secondary windings out of a power transformer varies between time consuming to outright difficult. We have successfully got over 5kA out of  the protection CT mentioned earlier which was rescued from a transformer bushing. We were driving it from a large 415V variac and could have gotten a fair bit more than 5kA if we had wanted to. You are right about keeping the connections short and thick, but this applies to any transformer based solution unless it involves a very high power source capable of delivering a lot of voltage at high current. If you look back in the old threads this type of high energy test has been done a couple of times to carry out primary injection on a large transformer's protection scheme - the last one I was involved with used a 1250kVA generator with the load directly strung across two phases.
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

ScottyUK
                  The original request was for a low dollar solution. Your CT sounds awesome, unlike anything I have seen lying around spare.  I was picturing something 500:5 or there-about. Either way I think we agree a transformer is more practical than a DC solution for a long term test. My experience was testing low voltage switchgear where the client insisted on testing the protection by injecting through the busbars to verify CT wiring. The usual low current test set was useless for that. An old 1KVA trany, hacksaw, welding cable and a couple of hours later we had a workable low cost (Kiwi) solution.
Cheers
Roy

RE: 100 amp low voltage power source

Low dollar is so open to interpretation - we saved ours from the skip so it was pretty close to a zero dollar solution!
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources