×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
Hello All,

I have been asked to specify a motor for a new centrifuge.  It needs to be able to handle 9.4 lb-ft^2 of inertia and spin at 3425 rpm.  In order to cycle the number of parts that I need, I will need to be capable of cycling the centrifuge from 0 to 3425 rpm up to 30 times per hour.  The centrifuge will be driven by a VFD.  My plan is to direct drive the table using a flexible coupling.

As I have been studying the requirements, I have found the MG 1-40.40 table that seems to indicate 10 HP motor.  Since a VFD will be needed to control the speeds, I will pick an inverter duty motor.  However, looking around a bit more, I found MG 10-2001 which has table 7 "Allowable number of starts and minimum time between starts for Design A and B motors" which indicates that a 10HP 2 pole motor would not be able to start that many times per hour.  It shows a little more than 1 start per hour?

Can anyone provide some clarity and/or point me to a source that can help me with this spec?
   

Thank you in advance for your insight!

Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

With a start every two minutes, could a flywheel/clutch combo offer any advantages to you to offset the additional complexity: smaller motor, energy conservation etc

"I love deadlines. I love the whooshing noise they make as they go past." Douglas Adams

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

I believe that the tables to which you refer are based on full voltage starting with the attendant high currents/heating of that starting method. The VF drive should be able to operate the motor at 100% torque throughout the acceleration period with much lower heating than full voltage starting would produce.  A motor manufacture should be able to model this for you and advise regarding the temperature rise of the motor. Within you two minute cycle you will probable have two high torque phases (accel and decel) which will contribute to the heating.  You will also need to consider having a VF drive that has regeneration capabilities to dissipate the stored energy during stopping, otherwise you won't have much time left for loading/unloading of the unit.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

I concur with baxterdad - those starting limits are for direct on line start (DOL).  VFD start will be much less stressful for the motor.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Depending on the torque required at startup. Centrifuges often are designed to utilize the high starting torque to accelerate quickly. A VFD can give you 100% torque without stressing the motor, but if acceleration of the mass in the allotted time requires 160% torque, the VFD is going to stress the motor as well. Maybe not as much as DOL, but it's not to be totally discounted either. You also must consider the effects on the VFD as well, it may overheat if it has to supply excess current every 2 minutes, they are typically rated for 150% current for 1 minute, but with a specific rest period in between of maybe 5 minutes (I'd have to look it up).

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

The fact that the referenced tables apply to DOL rather than VFD start does not depend on anything.

"Much less stressful" was a poor choice of words on my part. The method of meeting the demands of this particular application are not so simple as described by Baxterdad and as you have further elaborated.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Is a vector drive (sensorless vector should be good enough for this application) within your budget? If so, this should be an effective solution to this application. You will have high currents on acceleration and deceleration, and you must size motor and drive accordingly, but it's to do real work, not lost in excessive slip.

For sizing, think of it more as a servo application, cycling through four states:

1. Accel (high current)
2. Constant speed (low current)
3. Decel (high current if you want to stop quickly)
4. Stop (virtually no current as you change samples)

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

recommend a braking resister package for this application with the VFD
I thought baxtersdad said this but not sure about the meaning of regen?

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
Very interesting comments all.  Thank you!

So using the equation relating inertia, speed change, time I get an average torque required of 3.5 lb-ft.  This should allow me to accelerate my inertia to my speed in the time frame I need.  

The way I understand this is that as long as my motor has a rated torque value in excess of the 3.5 lb-ft I calculated, the VFD should be able to drive the motor to deliver this torque thru the ramp up and ramp down of the centrifuge.  

Does this also mean that since the across the line starting torques that cause the excessive heat is eliminated and that the number of starts per hours is a non-issue?


Thank you,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Full load torque on this motor (10hp 3600rpm) would be around 15 ft-lbf, so that's down around 25% torque.

I'm not sure the torque tells the whole story.  The slip is quite an important part of the picture also.  If you immediately apply line frequency at reduced torque, you'd have a helluva lot more heating than if you ramped the frequency.  Most everyone here knows that as well or better than me... just wanted to mention it.

Have you figured out how you will accomplish deceleration?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

In fact, I would venture to say that applying the reduced torque at immediate full frequency is almost as bad as a DOL start. (The total time-integrated rotor heating will be at least as much as the final kinetic energy of the system in either case).  You need to ramp the frequency.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Please disregard my immediately preceeding post 19 Oct 07 13:14.  Let me rephrase it as a question:  

Does applying a specified reduced torque (for exaqmple 25%) cause the VFD to ramp it's speed to maintain that torque (controlling slip down somewhere well below 5% the whole time) ?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

a correction to the correction to the question:
"Does applying a specified reduced torque (for exaqmple 25%) cause the VFD to ramp it's frequency to maintain that torque (controlling slip down somewhere well below 5% the whole time) ? "

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
Electricpete,

Thanks for the reply!

I was going to let the VFD control the deceleration.

For your other VFD question - I do not have an answer.

I am being led toward a 3HP (8.9 lb-ft full load torque) or a 5HP (15 lb-ft full load torque) 4 phase(1750rpm) inverter duty motor by a manufacturer.  They indicate that since I need the faster speed the VFD will allow that.  They claim the motor can move at up to 6000 rpm (I am assuming the bearings is the limiter).  However, they initially only said 3-4 starts per hour!  I have given them more info about my requirements and am waiting for a reply.

So I have effectively put it into their hands.  However, I would love to know what they are using to determine the motor size I need.  Short of making the torque rating of the motor larger than the required torque, making sure the bearings can handle the speed, and using an inverter duty motor, I don't know what they are using to determine the size.  I would prefer them to teach me how to fish instead of giving me a fish.  Any ideas?


Thank you,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

At a minimum for this application, you will need to control the commanded profile of an open-loop VFD output quite closely. (The profile means both the voltage magnitude and frequency, roughly in straight proportion to each other.) The profile includes an acceleration ramp, a constant-speed portion, and a deceleration ramp. Either the VFD must be sophisticated enough to generate this profile itself, or you must externally command it, probably through an analog input on the VFD.

There are two reasons you need this. First, it permits quick acceleration and deceleration, which it seems like you need. Second, it dramatically reduces motor heating compared to step changes in voltage/frequency. A stopped motor given full AC voltage/frequency is almost a short circuit, which is why these motors only permit you to do this type of start a few times an hour. Ramping the profile eliminates this issue.

(If you plan to do much low-speed motion, a fan attached to the motor shaft may not supply enough cooling for the steady-state heating, something you should check.)

For somewhat more money, a closed-loop vector drive (with or without a shaft sensor) will provide even a more optimized capability, because it will modulate the output profile based on what the motor is really doing. You would undoubtedly be able to accelerate and decelerate somewhat more rapidly with a vector drive than a ramped VFD. Whether this is worth it to you is a different question.

Because you undoubtedly want to decelerate more rapidly than a coast down, you will be regenerating and so must consider where this energy will go. (By "this energy", I mean the full kinetic energy of motor and load at the maximum speed.) You have two choices. Either make sure your drive's capacitor bank is big enough to store the full kinetic energy without excessive voltage rise (which is nice because you get to reuse that energy for the next acceleration), or you must dissipate that energy in a shunt resistor (probably lower capital cost).

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

1) You will probably need to provide extra cooling for the motor. An auxiliary fan that can add cooling while the motor is even stopped.

2) You may need extra cooling for the VFD.  Another auxiliary fan.

3) You may not realize that 'just the VFD' may not be able to stop the the centrifuge as quickly as you you think by itself.  As the VFD slows the motor, the motor generates power which returns to the VFD's internal capacitor bank.  This raises the voltage on the capacitors.  When it gets a little higher than normal the VFD either trips on error,(you're screwed), or you must greatly reduce the deceleration rate and your 'grand scheme' takes a BIG hit.
  The required solution to this is the braking resistor.  As the voltage rises on the capacitor bank it is shunted to the braking resistor allowing a much much higher deceleration rate.  A better solution in your case may be a more advanced VFD that allows the energy to be shoved back out to the power source.  This is far "greener" and can save on power bills.  Likely a large amount of regeneration is available on your application since you will be getting back most of your input energy since your system is not very lossy but rather just inertial.

4) You mentioned flexible shaft...  Those can be very  lossy.  This increases the motor load dramatically by numbers like 20%, especially at higher speeds such as yours.  All this loss shows up as heat in the flex drive cable of course which can actually limit your entire throughput.  Also they don't do too well with accel and deccel which causes even more internal heating.   I would personally jettison any signs of a flexible drive from centrifuge applications.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

itsmoked is correct. Returning the regenerated energy to the AC line is another option. This too adds to the cost of the drive. Sometimes I'm surprised at how many people prefer to waste it in a shunt resistor, but I haven't cranked the numbers comparing added up-front capital cost to ongoing electricity savings in quite a while. In my experience, the first reason most people choose regen to line is when they can't tolerate the heat generated by the shunt resistor.

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Good point I didn't mention cswilson!  Think about all the accel energy showing up in the area of the load resistor.  

A ~3000w heater running all the time.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

1) Could you tell us how the inertia is determined.  lb-ft^2 can have different meanings.  I would much rather see inertia in Newton-meter^2.

2)For a TENV (Totally Enclosed, Non-Ventilated) motor driven by a VFD, you can accelerate and decelerate continously as long as you stay at or below FLA (Full Load Amps). Even with a fan cooled motor, you are accelerating to top speed (good fan cooling) and holding speed for a large part of the duty cycle so as long as the accel decel are kept to FLA, you will not overheat the motor.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

I can't agree w/ sried on the claim  "you will not overheat the motor".  If production and reliability are critical, plan on some extra cooling.  Of course all of us are assuming conditions of around 10-35deg C.

"flexible coupling" like a "Lovejoy"?  Shouldn't be a problem, just don't plan on using a couplings flexibility to compensate for poor alignment.

good luck!

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

From the data presented, I would use a two-pole 5hp TENV motor with a regen drive rated at 7.5hp heavy-duty (or constant torque).

A TENV cools itself about the same whether it is running or not which would be an advantage during the idle time in the application.

You will minimize any overheating issues in the drive by sizing it the way I suggest.  A regen drive would be the right choice because of the amount of energy being returned back to the line during braking.

Suggestion:  use a Marathon Black Max motor.  They may not offer a two pole version.  In that case choose a four pole 5hp and run it to 120hz.  The motor is guaranteed to be constant hp up to that speed.

Choose a drive with good sensorless vector capability.  Using flux vector with an encoder is expensive overkill.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

  I've worked with the Marathon Black Max motors before some years ago (just small ones, though... 2HP or so).  They are remarkably heavy for their size, and just give you a feeling of 'trustworthiness'.  I've never had a problem with them, and they certainly worked fine with inverters... I've run them at over 5,000rpm for long periods with no problems.  I can only assume that they are as good now as they were then.

Mike

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Quote:

A TENV cools itself about the same whether it is running or not which would be an advantage during the idle time in the application
I would be curious to understand the basis for that statement.  Even TENV still have rotor features to promote internal fan action which serves to cool areas such as the endwindings.  It does not sound logical that the OEM's would sacrifice efficiency for fan action if it doesn't have an important function.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

I should mention that I'm going by memory.  I have some photo's of a TENV rotor at work that I'll check on Monday

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

ePete,

My understanding is similar to yours - a TENV motor has an internal 'fan' on the rotor to promote air movement within the casing. I don't see many TENV machines but the handful of DC ones I have seen recently enough to remember definitely had this feature.
 

----------------------------------
  
If we learn from our mistakes I'm getting a great education!

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
Thank you all!

Very useful and helpful information.

The flexible coupling is indeed like a "lovejoy" flexible coupling.  I will make sure that the drive and load are well aligned even without the flex coupling - as well.

I have chosen a 5HP TEBC(Totally Enclosed Blower Cooled) motor.  It is a monster weighing in at 120lbs.  

I will start looking into the economics of regen vs using shunt resistors.


Thank you,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Are the motor and centrifuge on a common frame, so the alignment stays ~ constant?

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
The table is connected to the machine frame thru 2 bearings located on a shaft connected to the table.  The motor is vertically mounted and connected to the frame.  The frame will be welded together.  I am allowing adjustment room in the bearings and the motor for alignment.  

I am going to lock down any fasteners with lock washers or safety wire to keep them from vibrating loose.  This should allow the alignment to stay constant.


Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Just to address an earlier statement so that you don't go off half-cocked...

Your motor supplier told you that their motor could go to 6000RPM. Don't misconstrue this. Yes, the VFD can supply a higher frequency and Yes, apparently that motor's bearings and cooling system allow for the higher RPM. But in case you are not aware, as you increase a motor's speed with a VFD beyond its base rating, i.e. 4 pole = 1800RPM, you start to operate in a "constant HP" mode, meaning that your torque is decreasing at a non-linear rate. So taking an 1800RPM motor to 6000RPM is theoretically possible, as long as your load torque requirements diminish at a similar rate.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
Jraef,

That makes sense to me.  In order to accelerate my load up in the time that I need, I need a 1.7 lb-ft of torque on average.    The motors full load torque rating is 15.0 lb-ft of torque.

Which of course seems like way too much for the need.  Unless this diminishing HP with increasing RPM is taken into account.

Thank you for the comment.

Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

I like to use the European style motors for frequent starting and stopping applications. The smaller diameter (compared to the NEMA size) will cut down the motor inertia, a good thing when starting and stopping. SEW-Eurodrive as a reference.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

"Flexible drive"  just for the record, I thought you meant a cable in a housing.  Glad you didn't mean that.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
itsmoked,

I thought that was what you had meant smile


Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Yeah running a centrifuge thru one of those..

Just out of curiosity what are you centrifuging?

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
itsmoked,

Unfortunately, that is covered in the NDA with our end client.


Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

No problem.  Thanks.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

rglassburn,

The 5  or 10 HP motors were making some sense to me.  Assuming the 9.4 lb.-ft^2 units were Force-Length units, the mass inerta is about 0.3 slug-ft^2.  With,say, 2 lb-ft of torque, I calculate over 500 seconds to reach 3400 RPM.  This is why I asked what the Inertia units really are.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
sreid,

The units are lbm-ft^2.  So they are pound mass units [no-one likes slugs anymore sad  ]  Typically called WR^2 or WK^2.  Simply the weight times the radius of gyration squared.

The time in seconds to change speed is given as follows:
t = (WR^2)*(change in RPM speed)/[308*(avg. accel torque)]


Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

rglassburn

Clipped from one internet site

POLAR MASS MOMENT OF INERTIA
The polar mass moment of inertia (J) is the measure of resistance to a change in rotational velocity about an intended rotational axis. It may be derived by dividing the flywheel effect WR2 by the acceleration due to gravity.

J = WR2/g lb-ft-sec2 where
 
R = Radius of Gyration, ft
W = Weight, lb
g = 32.2 ft/sec2

So is your inertia 9.4 lbm-ft^2 ?

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Hmmm...

I calculate:

9.4 lbm-ft^2 = 0.29 lbf-ft-s^2 (=slug-ft^2)

dividing by "g" (32.2 ft/s^2) as sried does.

For acceleration time, I calculate:

0.29 lbf-ft-s^2

* 3400 rev/min * 2Pi/rev * min/60s

* 1/(1.7 lbf-ft)

= 61 seconds acceleration time

So in a 2-minute cycle, you wouldn't quite make top speed at all. Of course, with your motor capable of more torque, you would be able to accelerate and decelerate faster than this, but I suspect you will want substantially higher torque levels.

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
We are using the mass moment of inertia (I:  I = m x r^2) and not the polar mass moment of inertia (J).  'J' deals with torsion, 'I' with angular motion.  Easily confused.  There is even another inertia that is also called 'I'(second moment of inertia). Wikipedia does a pretty good job of explaining.

You would think that mass(inertia)would be simpler smile


Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

The reason we are asking repeatedly is because we have been "Burned" by inertia units more times than we like to think about.

You quote (correctly) an equation for time to speed.  The wr^2 in this equation has units of lbf-ft^2 because the 308 factor is 32.2x60/6.28 (converts force to mass and RPM to radians/second).

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

A suggestion on motor speed. When a speed of 6000 RPM is contemplated, it would probably be based on a 3600 RPM motor wired for 230 volts. It would be supplied with almost 460 volts at almost 120 HZ. At almost double the frequency and almost double the voltage you will also have almost double the HP. If you use a 5HP motor it will develop almost 10 HP at 6000 RPM.

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Rob:

Both sreid and I are talking about mass moment of inertia, which the Wikipedia article you cite states goes by either I or J. (In my experience, "I" is used in science texts, "J" in engineering texts.)

The fundamental equation all of us are using is

T = J * alpha

As sreid points out, many, many people have gotten burned by unit confusion, starting from the basic problem that kilograms are units of mass, and pounds are units of force. IMHO, attempts to get around this by using units such as "pounds-mass" create more problems than they solve.

I plugged your numbers in above using the fundamental units and got an acceleration time of a minute. Do you see anything wrong with my calculations?

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

(OP)
cswilson, sreid,

I do not see any error in your calculation and it does square with where I am now in my calculations.  During the course of this discussion, I have been reducing my table size and increasing the speed required.

Currently I have reduced the inertia down to 2.7 lb-ft^2 (without the motors rotor inertia).  The speed I need is ~4200 RPM and the time to spin up to that is around 30 seconds.  The average torque required for this is ~1.2 lb-ft.

I spend a couple of days early on worrying about the mass conversion issue.  It is amazing how many sources of information have the information incorrectly stated (or poorly explained).  The metric system is certainly the easiest to understand.

Thanks,
Rob

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

Just as a wrap-up for others who may be reading this, because Rob's experience in flailing around with MOI calculations is, unfortunately, pretty typical.

Yes, metric (particularly SI) is best. Use it if you have the information given to you in these units.

If you only have the information available to you in English units, use real English units (pounds-force, MOIs in lb(f)-ft-s^2).

Avoid "crossover units" like "pounds-mass" (lbm) and "kilograms-force" (kgf). It is way too easy to make a mistake and be off by a factor of "g" in a numerical answer.

Avoid formulas that incorporate all conversion factors into a single value. Again, it is way too easy to make a mistake due to unit confusion. Write equations out using the fundamental units, then go through cancelling out units to make sure that your answer is in the appropriate units. I emphasize this in the university classes I teach, and I still do it myself.

Curt Wilson
Delta Tau Data Systems

RE: Centrifuge AC Induction Motor Requireing 30 Starts Per Hour

To quote an old NASA joke (slightly modified)

"Don't spec acceleration in Furlongs per Fortnight Squared."

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources