×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Higher Degree or Experience
7

Higher Degree or Experience

Higher Degree or Experience

(OP)
Hello,

I'm just wondering whether or not I should just go straight to work with a bachelor's or go for a master's? Is it better to work to gain more work experience than to get a master's? If employers say "master's preferred," would they still prefer bachelor's with more work experience than a master's with no experience? Does that hold true for the environmental engineering companies? Also, is it better to work and go for a PE license with a bachelor's than to get a master's?

Thank you,
j

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

2
My personal experience is that unless you are planning to go into general engineering, the Master's will be of far less value to you than two years of solid feet on the ground, dirt under your nails experience.  Typical companies value that you know how to actually do things, not that you possess two more years of esoteric knowledge.  Any esoteric knowledge you'll need for your day to day activities will be picked up during that two years you weren't getting your Master's.

Now, if you're planning to go into a more highly demanding technical field where you're going to need that level of esoteric knowledge as a bare minimum to get in the door, then I'd say that the Master's is again not the best option, and the Ph.D. would serve you better as it only takes another year and looks much better than the Master's.

Of course, I'm toying with the idea of getting my Master's degree, but I'm coming up on five years of experience out of school.  At this point, I can more directly focus the learning of esoteric information to maximize the usefulness to the job.  Five years ago, I'd be throwing darts in the dark trying to learn something I could apply now.

Of course, I'm often wrong.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

My personal experience is that IF you are planning to go into...

There.  I fixed that.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

HgTX, there's an entire world outside of the US with different education systems.

In the UK to get a Masters will typically take 1 more year of full time study than bachelors.  To get a PHD around 3 more years full time.

This on top of the fact that the bachelors only took 3 years.

So starting at 18 straight out of high school you can have:

Bachelors by 21
Masters by 22
Doctorate by 24

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

go with a master's first.  the allure of that steady paycheck might stop you from going back.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Why not do both.

My employer is paying for my graduate work %100, including books and any other fees.  I think that most would agree that kind of coverage is unusual but many employers these days will offer to pay at least some part of your education.

Going directly to get a Masters and you will have more debt and no experience.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

not if you can get a fellowship or assistanceship

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

KENAT--2 more years or 3 more years from master's to PhD?  You say three but then go from age 22 to 24.

And the comment that there's a whole world out there goes both ways.  Blithely assuring someone that a PhD only takes one more year than a master's doesn't work Over Here.

Hg

Eng-Tips policies:  FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

HgTX I didn't say that, I was just following on from Greg.  You said "Where does a PhD only take 3 years with no MS beforehand??" I suppose I took it a little out of context and thought the double ? implied that you thought the idea of a phd in 3 years was ridiculous.

It's not quite set up the same but if you started doing a research masters and then moved into doing a Doctorate then it would take about 2 years extra from what I recall.

However, work was getting to me so I was probably a bit grouchy, sorry for any offense.  

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Star to James,

Why pay for it when your company will and pay you at the same time?



RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Wow, look at what I started!  What I meant was what Kenat said.  You do a research Master's and your dissertation would be the full treatment of the research so you can sort of make double use of your time.

This is in distinct contrast to my suggestion on going to work first and getting the Master's to accentuate your skills later when you know what you need.  At that point, you probably won't be able to get a research Master's due to the time constraints of the job you'd have.  The Master's I was talking about was definitely a straight coursework Master's with no thesis.  

I didn't mean to imply that I'd wait to go to work first before getting a research Master's.  If I were going into something requiring a research Master's, I'd just go the full Ph.D. route and get it done with.


RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Also, I just checked the LSU School of Engineering, where I'm considering enrolling for my Master's.  To get a Ph.D. starting from a Bachelor's degree requires 60 hours of class/dissertation research.  Full-time in graduate school is 9 hours spring/fall, 6 hours summer.  Optimally, you can complete 24 hours a year.  That's where I got my three-year figure.  If you don't go full time, it necessarily takes longer.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

I got my master's degree before getting engineering experience.

Now that I have an engineering job everything is great.

However, getting an entry level position is difficult with a master's... yet getting a higher level position is also difficult if not inappropriate!  Also, I didn't know what information would be important to my future career.  Having the best intentions to learn "everything" isn't quite as helpful as knowing what's important to you.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

jistre, Are you sure it's only 60 hours from a bachelor's.  The PhD programs I have looked at are 90 hours from a bachelors or 60 from a masters.  I good bit of that is research/dissertation so that the extra classes beyond a BS amounts to 50-60 hours.

Chestud08, I would definitely recommend getting a job and then doing a master's degree while working.  You will have an entirely new perspective of your classwork and you will be able to apply new knowledge immediately.  In my case, I was able to sometimes use something I learned the very next day.  That helped very much to reinforce the understanding.  Also, some of your undergraduate classes may be enlightened by your experience.  Make sure that your prospective employer offers tuition reimbursement for the MS program you are looking at.  After you have your 4 years experience, go for your PE if it will help you.  It really depends which employer you are talking about whether they value BS/PE, BS/MS, or MS/PE and what are your career goals.  I think in the chemical world, you can never go wrong with a MS/PE and neither one will get any easier as you get older.  Good luck!

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

3
Chestub08, the answers to the questions that you originally  posed are dependent upon your own personal and professional goals, and the industry and type of job that you envision for yourself. I earned my PhD in Materials Science at the University of Rochester back in the early 1990s. The requirements of that program were representative of most university PhD science and engineering programs at the time in terms of the credit hours required for graduation, which totaled 90 minimum. I had 72 hours of course work, and 18 official hours of research credits under my belt when I walked into my dissertation defense. In order to graduate, you must write a PhD dissertation and then successfully defend it in front of a committee that is composed of your thesis advisor, professors from the department in which you are enrolled, and at least one faculty member from outside your department. The apparently minor detail or writing and defending a thesis seems to be absent from most of the posts above, yet represents the majority of the time and effort required to earn the PhD. After the coursework is done, the real work begins. I actually did the calculations several years ago, and estimated that after earning my Bachelor's degree I spent an average of 60 hours a week for 5 years studying and working toward the PhD. I went straight through from the BS degree to the Master's, and then to the PhD before landing my first full time job. And I observed many people who studied part time for their advanced degrees. They had no life outside of work and school. It took them much longer to earn their degrees because they were employed in full time positions, and they were only able to juggle at most two classes per semester along with their job and their family. I can't imagine going back to school to earn my degree with the responsibilities and time constraints that are placed on me now.

How your potential employer views the Master's degree depends upon the requirements of the position and their expectations. If the job that you apply for lists a B.S. degree as the minimum educational requirement, then the M.S. degree will provide you with some distinction from the rest of the employment pool when you go for that first job. For the most part it should be considered as an advantage. And unlike the PhD, you are usually not viewed as being overqualified when you have the M.S. degree. If the minimum educational requirement for the job is a Master's degree, you will have to have it if you expect to even be considered for the position. What this usually means is that the employer is looking for someone with more specialized knowledge and ability than the B.S. degree candidate would normally be expected to demonstrate, and the bump in pay over a B.S. can be significant in this type of circumstance. If they typically hire lots of PhDs (think national lab for example) then the Master's degree is looked upon as more of a consolation prize that was given to someone who did not have the drive or ability to earn the PhD. Note that I do not condone this point of view. It was expressed directly to me by one interviewer, and I believe that it is not an uncommon sentiment in some work places.

Having the Master's degree will pay dividends for you as you progress forward in your career. In upper level management, it is sometimes a requirement of the position to have an advanced degree. And getting the Master's when you are younger is much easier than trying to earn it later in life. Lots of things like job responsibilities, family issues, and life in general have a tendency to get in the way of reaching that goal. If you plan to go into environmental or civil engineering, a PE is a worthwhile investment of your time and effort.  Whatever your decision, I wish you good fortune.

Maui   

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

(OP)
Thanks everyone for your time and advices.
j

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

As we move further into the 21st century, the Masters will be come the new Bachelors.  Here is the hard truth in U.S. Private industry:  When you graduate with a B.S. and go looking for a job you are now going to be competing with people in India and China who have more education than you do and are willing to do your job for 1/10th the salary you are looking for.  You simply can't compete with that.   In another 10 years a BS in engineering will probably just get you a job a Starbucks.

Lower level engineering jobs are leaving the U.S. every day, and it looks like thay won't be coming back any time soon.  If you want to have any hope of a career, you need to set yourself apart.   Getting an advanced degree is a start.   Anybody can be a SolidWorks jockey and your prospective employer isn't going to pay you 70K a year to do it when he can get someone in India to do it for 7K a year.

Having an advanced degree and becoming a specialist are in my opinon, the key to success.   Now more than ever you need to show an employer that you can add value in order to command a salary.

I have my MS in Mechanical Engineering and I am a specialist in strucural dynamics and acoustics.   An advanced degree was important for my line of work.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

spongebob007

The demise of the Bachelors has been predicted for some time.  In fact it's why I was originally on a Masters course back in the 90s.

I'm not saying it wont happen but it's been exaggerated/timescales set too soon.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Hard evidence (survey in The Australian's Higher Education supplement) from Australia says that a Masters does you no favours in starting salary, and a PhD is a backward step, for engineers.

What makes spongebob think differently?

Cheers

Greg Locock

Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

There is nothing that says you need to quit work to go get a masters if you decide to work first.  I am just starting a masters (after 1.5 years on the job after BS).  I find myself far more knowledgable than my classmates that are doing their masters immediately after BS.
I am not saying one way is better than the other, it certainly depends on your individual circumstances.  I will say this, though.... Someone who gets MS without working between will have more general knowledge than someone with BS (obviously).  If you do get a MS after working you will gain much more from the classes than those who did not have any real world experience when taking them.
Being faced with some tough, real world problems and having to think through them a little on your own before being exposed to the theory is invaluable in having that knowledge actually sink in compared to someone to whom this is purely academic.
Just my 2 cents!

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Spongbob, I am confused because this discussion and I have read a few articles like the following:

http://www.prism-magazine.org/march00/germany.cfm

This one is a little old, 2000, but like a few I had read have said that more engineering is going toward the BS for various reasons. Main reason being, in order to reduce personal cost the engineer ends up designing/drafting/analyzing/managing/etc…which require a more broad skill set then MS.

Which is more correct, is engineering really going toward MS or BS?

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

I agree with Mr Squarepants, that you have to be in a specialized area in order to get into jobs that may have a hard time finding somebody on the other side can do.  If you can seperate your self either by degree (MS) or certificats (PE, Quality), you may have a better chance.  

I kinda agree with StructuralEIT, but I beleive that it can go both ways.  You can get your masters first and then practice what you learned.  During that time you will get a more indept understanding of the subject.  Plus, you are already in the acadamia mind set.  It is a roll of the dice when you leave uni that you ever come back.  Life has curve balls, before you know it, you may move on to the next phase of life.

Tobalcane
"If you avoid failure, you also avoid success."

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

I am speaking strictly about the situation in the United States.  In other parts of the world your mileage may vary.   

It also depends on what line of work you are in.  I have spent most of my career in R&D and an MS is certainly a good thing to have and in some cases a requirement for the type of work I do.  For me a Masters has certainly led to a better salary.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

In response to Spongebob...

I have about 2 years working since I got my BS. The places I have worked typically are divide between engineers with degrees and "designers" or "detailers" without degrees. I do not believe that until I start seeing a decline in designers or detailers I will be concerned about my prospects. On the contrary, it seems that the designer/detailers have an increasing demand.

Also, I do not believe that the outsourcing of engineering work will be instantaneous. When/if it does occur, everybody who currently has a BS will have a fair amount of experience and the impact will mostly be felt by new graduates.

This is just my point of view. I realize a major factor may be the specific industry, location, and size of the company. The companies I have worked for are small, and typically each item engineered is unique. Therefore, the capital cost of working with international employees is certainly more of a factor than a large company, which may make hundreds of thousands of a product from the work performed by the employees.

-- MechEng2005

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

To expand on MechEng2005's post, some idunstries require a PE from a specific jurisdiction.  It will be difficult for someone outside teh US to obtains and maintain a PE in the US when their work must be overseen by a PE in the jurisdiction where they are seeking registration.  That is difficult to do from overseas.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

I don't always agree with StructuralEIT but this time he's right.

It is difficult for most non US types to get PE.  So in areas of industry that require PE this should be kept in mind.

I know this from experience.

Also there are language, logistical and cultural issues with dealing with people from different countries as MechEng suggests.

Not to say outsourcing isn't going on but I personally think Spongebobs first post overstates it a bit.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

I agree with mecheng.

Local firms continually struggle to find enough people with even drafting courses, let alone experience.

In many fields, engineering degrees from places like China and India are not even recognised by the relevant professional organisations. It's typical for immigrants from such countries to be required to take a BS or an MS (most go the MS route if they can as it's shorter) before being eligible for EIT status.

The few cases I see of work done out of country are for multi-nationals who were impressed by work done in country or exceptional projects where specific expertise is required.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

gwynn-
Will a MS count toward EIT without an accredited BS degree?  I don't think it will.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

It depends on the location. Some places a masters degree can be substituted for the BS requirement, but you would have to check this locally.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

RE Outsourcing:

Most engineering jobs outside of Civil don't require a PE so that is irrelevant.  

The fact that professional orginaizations may not recognize foreign degrees is also largely irrelevant in many cases.  American companies give the title "engineer" to people with two year degress (or even less) all the time.  Don't even get me started on that one.   

The logistical issues with dealing with others in foreign countries are real. This can be a big problem with outsourcing, although the MBA types who came up with this crap don't have to worry about details like that.  I used to routinely have teleconferences with India and China from my home very early in the morning or at night because that is when those folks were in the office.   Since the time difference with China is 180 degrees out of phase, email correspondence had a 24 hour lag time.

Outsourcing is probably most prevalent in large private corporations that have the means to handle it.  My former employer opened engineering centers in China and India.  Many small companies don't have the resources to do that.

I now work for the government because my job has to be done in the US by US citizens.   

But like I said before, to be immune from outsourcing you need to set yourself apart.  Having a PE can do that, but really only for jobs where a PE matters.   

I have been at this for nearly 14 years now and I can tell you young engineers that experience doesn't matter as much as you think-at least not to the bean counters who make the financial decisions.   They don't care if the guy in India has half the experience you do.  He's willing to work for $7000 a year, are you?

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

Quote:

I have been at this for nearly 14 years now and I can tell you young engineers that experience doesn't matter as much as you think-at least not to the bean counters who make the financial decisions.   They don't care if the guy in India has half the experience you do.  He's willing to work for $7000 a year, are you?

The bean counters will start caring when they get hit with law suites for piss poor engineering from that $7K/yr engineer in India that result in personal injury....ie wing falling off a plane!

I'm reviewing a 17-4 H900 SS part right now that was manufactured in Bangkok.  The heat treatment cert tells me it was heat treated and the material cert tells me the part meets all requirements to be 17-4....But after 600 cycles the part's flogged and that's telling me it's not heat treated to H900.

Heckler   americanflag
Sr. Mechanical Engineer
SWx 2007 SP 4.0 & Pro/E 2001
      o
  _`\(,_
(_)/ (_)

This post contains no political overtones or undertones for that matter and in no way represents the poster's political agenda.

RE: Higher Degree or Experience

So if the PE issue isn't enough to convince you then...

For many aerospace/defense jobs you need to be US citizen.

Now of course this doesn't stop out sourcing of major components etc but it is a factor in foreign engineers coming here or I would think some outsourcing of design work etc.

The language, logistical and cultural issues with dealing with people from different countries are a major issue for some things though.  I have a hard enough time dealing with field engineers from our own company in some parts of the world, let alone from another employer.

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources