×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Shear in Concrete Wall

Shear in Concrete Wall

Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
I am designing a concrete wall that backs into a hill for a condo.  The concrete wall will hopefully be 10" to 12" thick.  

Factored Moment --> 107kN*m (79,000 lbs*ft)
Factored Shear --> 255kN (~57,300 lbs)

Based on my calculations, I will require shear reinfocing (i.e. stirrups of some sort).  My question is will horizontal reinforcing act as shear reinforcing or do I need stirrups?  I've never seen shear reinforcing in a basement wall.  

Help would be great!
Thanks,
JrEng

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

Is the shear in the plane of the wall or out-of-plane?  For in-plane, reinforcing is commonly used to resist shear.  For out-of-plane, shear reinforcing is not common.  In this case, the thickness of the wall is usually increased as necessary.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

For a 57.3 kip load (in plane)it seems like a short length of wall will work without shear reinforcing.

The moment is a bit curious. Is it as induced by the shear at the base of the wall?

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
Thanks for the quick response. What I have essentially is a 3 span beam.  The soil pressure exherted on the wall causes the shear.  I'm not sure whether you would call that in-plane. I believe its called out-of-plan since it is perpendicular to the wall.  Your thoughts?  I should mention my above moment/shear was for a meter wide of wall.

the walls looks like this. I will attempt to draw

               /| |<---Floor system
              / | |
Soil Pressure/->| |  3m span
14.1kN/m3   /   | |
           /    | |<---Floor system
          /---->| |
         /      | |
        /       | |  3m span
       /------->| |
      /         | |
     /          | |<---Floor System (max shear here)
    /---------->| |
   /            | |  1.5m span (crawlspace)
  /-------------| |

Sorry for all the metric units.  I modelled the wall with the bottom as a 'cantilever'.  I was hoping not rely on much lateral resistance from the concrete pile foundation (there is no concrete slab in the crawl space to take out the lateral load)
Hope that clarifies things, more help would be GREATLY appreciated.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
whoops, that drawings got a little messed, but hopefully it makes sense, it should look closer to this

Grade Level
_____
       /|<-----support
      / | 3m
     /  |
    /   |<-----support
   /    | 3m
  /     |
 /      |<-----support
/       | 1.5m
          (cant)

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
I ran it again using the base as a support instead of cantilevering it.  That significantly reduced my moment to 32,000 lb*ft (43kN*m) and max shear of 23kips(103kN) -->again per meter of wall.  I suppose we could use a slab in the crawlspace to take out the lateral load at base.  The engineered wood floor system is going to be taking a huge axial load as well which i am quite worried about.  Factored axial load of 190kN/m or 13kips/ft.
Any thoughts?!

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

I would second what Taro says....for out-of-plane shear in walls and slab, shear reinforcing is not common.  In most cases, by adding thickness or by increasing f'c you can up your concrete shear capacity and make it work.

A forest of shear ties through a wall is a mess and impedes the deposition of concrete.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
Thanks JAE! Very helpful.  I forgot about the obvious strength increase.  
Two more questions on that topic:

1) If they pour that wall in 2 or 3 pours, would it be best to place the cold joints at the supports to encourage simple span action?  My reasoning is to get away with using only one mat of reinfocing (i.e. on the inside face) As opposed to using 2 mats of reinforcing to carry the negative moment at the supports.  

Just a thought.  Otherwise I will likely cold joint it at minimum moment location and try to achieve a continuous "beam/wall" using two mats of reinforcing.

2)Do you have any thoughts about me adding that kind of axial load into the floor system.  I know this is a general question, but i'm worried about how much axial load the floor system will be required to resist.  It's a LOT larger than any of my previous designs.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

In addition to thickening the wall, you could spec a higher f'c to increase the allowable shear, or, step the wall thickness as needed rather than increase it all the way down.

Mike McCann
McCann Engineering

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

Once you get over 10" thick, code requires two mats of steel in the wall.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
Thanks, Where is that in code?

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

Two mat requirement for >10" walls is in Chapter 14.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

JREng

I would definitely verify the lateral stability of the structure to resist the 7.5m of earth thrust. I understand your reservations about putting too much lateral load into the piles - but this thrust has to be resisted somewhere.... I take it the rest of the building is suspended and on piles?

What is the construction of the building? Is there enough bracing to resist this load and can floor diaphragms distribute the loads to these points? I assume the bracing is rigid and the loads will not cause serviceability concerns?

As this wall will have to be constructed hard up against the building there may be potential to utilize existing bracing walls built into and perpendicular to the backwall. If a connection to the vertical bracing elements can be justified these walls will serve as 'buttresses' and enable two way action in the wall and subsequent reduction in BM and shear.

I might be a bit of track here but i thought id put my 2c in.

By the way, i specify cold joints as scabbled with bonding agents and the reinforcing continuous. As such from a bending perspective the wall acts effectively continuous. I specify cold joints in the middle third of the span as i am more concerned about the shear rather than BM at these locations. I would not specify a cold joint at a support.

Cheers

LJK

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

I would also state the joints to be in the middle third where the shear is less.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

(OP)
Thanks for all the replies!  As far as the joint location of the joints in the middle third, I am assuming that means you would be less concerned about a cold joint in a region of high moment.

to answer your question LJK, its a wood framed 4 storey stepped condominium.  I-joist construction with concrete foundation walls supported soley on concrete piles.

RE: Shear in Concrete Wall

See ACI 6.4.4. It is somewhat analogous to your case. You assume the concrete cracks at ultimate moment anyway, I would want the concrete continuous where the shear is the most.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources