×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
For a rectagular reinforced concrete beam, what are the reasons that normally  we provide 2 main bars? Can we just use only one main bar with the same area and any danger? Thank you!
Regards
Richard

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

It is unlikely that one bar will give you the required are of steel unless you are using a #14 or something ridiculous.  If you do use something that large you really need to pay close attention to your develpoment length.
Additionally, you need (2) bars at the bottom and (2) at the top just to build the rebar cage which includes the stirrups.  You wouldn't want the stirrups around a single bar.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Besides being able to tie the rebar cage together, it is also important to remember that the concrete beam performs better against cracking with more smaller bars rather than fewer larger bars.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
Hi StructuralEIT,
Physically and practically, there is no problem to provide with one bar of the same or larger area and no problem for providing adequate anchorgae or lap length. Of course if one main bar is used then we also provide one hanger bar for the stirrups. Similarly, rectangular stirrups are provided for the shear. I am concerned if adopting one main bar only, the corner of the section would crack and ohter problem would arise!! May I have other experts' advice please. Thank you

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
Hi MarcbSE,
Yes, I agree that the concrete beam performs better against cracking with more smaller bars rather than fewer larger bars.e.g. I expect that theer would be carck if we provide only one main bar for say 12"(300mm) width beam. In fact I am referring to more specific narrow beam with width of some 5"-6" (125-150mm), would there be any problem? Any literature that I can refer to?

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

as MarcbSE points out, another reason for a greater quantity of smaller bars is for crack control.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

You should be able to get (2) #3 to (2) #5 into a 6" section.  This is assuming #3 stirrups and 1.5" clear.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
Hi StructuralEIT,
Yes, we have been pratising putting 2 smaller bars and stirrup for 5"-6" beams though very tight but still manageable with due care and proper vibration of concrete. But we end up with little concrete cover then we would face with durability problem. By using one single larger bar, we can have adequate cover but also cheaper cost in steel and labour. That is why I am seeking advice from experts on this issue. Thank you!

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

5" to 6" - That is a narrow beam.  I'm assuming this beam would be for an above grade location that would not require a larger cover distance.

I'm not aware of anything in the code that would prevent the use of a single bar for a beam this narrow, but I would still prefer to use (2) small bars if space allowed.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

You can't get two bars in a 6-inch wide beam with two-leg stirrups unless the bars are tied to the stirrups above the corner bend.

dcnnng, what you are asking about sounds a lot like concrete joists, which may have a single longitudinal bar and single-leg stirrups.  Take a look for joists and soffit beam systems.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Single bar in center of 6" x 6" fence post.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

UcfSE-
I disagree.  If you start with teh 6", assume #3 stirrups, and #5 main bars, and 1" clear between bars, you can get (2) #5 in there while still maintaining 1.5" clear.

[6" - 2(0.375") - 2(0.625") - 1"]/2 = 1.5" which satisfies the minimum for clear cover assuming the concrete is not exposed to weather.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

EIT, you are assuming that the bars will butt up to the stirrups in the corners.  The stirrup corners have a radius that means you can't push the bars into the corner of the stirrup loop without losing some depth.  You can tie the bars to the side of the stirrup or account for the radius at the corner.  Try adding your number again by locating the long bar at the horizontal tangent of the stirrup corner radius.

1.5+0.375+0.75+0.625+1+0.75+0.375+1.5=6.875 >6.

Another method is accounting for the bar being tangent at the center of the corner, as shown in the PCI Design Handbook.  This allows less required width but changes the rebar depth slightly.  Using those numbers, different from what I reference above, you get

1.5+0.875+0.625+1+0.875+1.5=6.375 >6.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

You raise an interesting point.  I thought the stirrup could be bent with a tight enough radius that the #5 would fit snugly inside it.  Maybe that isn't true.  I am looking at tables from 2 different textbooks - 1 is telling me that I need bw of 6" for (2) #5, the other is telling me I need 7".
I am taking an advanced concrete class in grad school right now and when checking cover requirements the professor never consider the radius of the stirrup.  
Does anyone else have some insight on this?  It isn't a big deal for normal situations, but when you are pushing the limits of  clear spacing and cover, this can become an issue.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

See also the CRSI Manual.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

could you use fiber reinforced concrete instead of traditional rebar?

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

BurgoEng-
For a beam?
We haven't come to any sort of consensus as to whether that is even acceptable for T&S steel only.  I know I would certainly not feel comfortable using that for any sort of structural application in lieu of reinforcing steel.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Professors of reinforced concrete never tied rebar with 6 bar diameters for bend diameter. CRSI is correct and the corner bars are usually not in line with the others in that face unless pulled over to the tangent point.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

ACI 318 section 7.13 is a good reference.  For joists conforming to section 8.11, one bar is acceptable.  For beams, two bars is the minimum.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
Dear All,
In this case , I am not considering using alternative such fibre reinforced concrete nor bent up bars. In ohter words, we shall end up with inadequate cover for using 2 bar approcah and not sure how it would perform by using one bar.

Taro has raised interesting points based on ACI 318 section 7.13, for joists conforming to section 8.11, one bar is acceptable and for beams, two bars is the minimum.

I don't have ACI318, can you all experts commend on Taro's reference please. If one bar approach is not acceptable, could you please also state the reasons and reference please.  

Thank you all!!

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

dcnnng, what code are you using?  If you are in the US you should have the ACI 318, or the counterpart if you are in another country.  Codes are part of the engineer's tool bag.

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
Hi UcfSE,
I use BS 8110 but searching for other codes or reference on the subject matter irrespective of whatever practices or countries. Thank you!

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

How is your structural system designed to operate? In the post by Taro, the terms joist is use to define a load bearing member smaller than a "beam" commonly used in systems with one way spans and multiple members, such as a beam and slab system, with one way slabs spanning to joists which carry loads to beams and girders.

From the width of your members, it would seem that you are working with a joist, but definiing the qualifications of the US codes would be easier by purchasing them from www.concrete.org

If your code has no similar reference, having the US code could help justify or explain your reasoning.

Best of luck,

Daniel Toon

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

dcnnng,

If this is a continuous beam then be careful of the slenderness - there should be a limit in the code.

csd

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

Did a microprocessing lab with a grillage of 8x48 beams @ 2' o/c spanning 18'(clear 15'), and used a single 25M T&B... with single leg stirrups...

Dik

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

From what I can see, from a BS8110 perspective, the minimum limit for the no. of tension bars in a beam is only governed by the rules for bar spacing and distance between bar and beam side face.
For a 6" wide beam a single bar is close enough to each of the side faces to ensure crack control. Refer BS8110; Section 3.12.11.2 .

RE: Rect Reinforced Concrete Beam with One Main Bar only

(OP)
csd72,

It is a continuous beam satisfying the code limit of the slenderness for beam.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources