×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

(OP)
Has anyone heard of turndown footing system used in the Northeast that utilizes non-frost susceptible fill?  Supposedly this is being used to reduce the turndown depth.  

In a nutshell, rock is placed beneath the turndown, and the rationale is that the rock wont frost heave.  I'm not so sure I buy into it, especially if there isnt a fully functional drainage system in place.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

Yes, I've heard of that design and even used it quite a few times.  However the only places where I've used it were for some premanufactured buildings that were very small (as in less than 200 sq.ft.).  In these cases I designed the slab as a structural slab so if anything moved it would all move together.  I wouldn't trust it for anything much larger personally.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

I have used non-frost rock subbase under transformer slabs in combination with insulation placed horizontally.  In parts of Canada with deep frost, (10-12'), this results in substantial savings.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

Something to keep in mind with respect to frost depth/penetration and potential heave.  First, one must have a frost susceptible material which can heave (clean sand, sand and gravel are not frost susceptible).  Secondly, one must have a source of water with which the susceptible soil may suck in to form the ice lenses and that leading to the heave; and (3) one must have cold temperature which lead to freezing.  I have had sites in Northern Ontario (frost depth 3 m or so) where we put the footings at 0.75 m or so because (1) the groundwater was more than 4 m down and (2) the upper 8 m was a stratum of clean sand. As civil person indicates, you can negate frost depth by use of insulation. Also in heated buildings only the outside footings need to be placed below the frost zone.  See the following link which also has links to other articles:
http://irc.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/pubs/cbd/cbd182_e.html

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

(OP)
I don't get a warm and fuzzy feeling this ideology is used for anything other than structures of minor nature.  Aka, don't build your entire house on it....just your tool shed.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

The "minor" structure described was a 280 kip transformer costing three million dollars carrying twenty thousand dollars an hour worth of power.  Warm and fuzzy is not applicable to this design, just cost analysis vs reliability.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

(OP)
Nice, that's what I'm looking for.  How would you defend your design?  I'm assuming this is something where you stand behind a geotechnical recommendation..correct?

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

To Defend the design:
  Proper Geotechnical Report to define the site - See BigH above.
  Proper definition of shallow subsurface and surface water control - See BigH above.

Million dollar homes in resort areas of Colorado done this way, in total or in part.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

See thread592-169967: Design Concrete Slab on Grade.  CarlB posted a link to a HUD Design Guide for Shallow Foundations.  It essentially uses insulation to reduce the frost depth.

The OP wasn't asking about insulated foundations though.  I've used shallow downturned slabs under transformers and outdoor mechanical equipment.  Put gravel down to +20% below frost depth.  Read here somewhere that placing a gravel fill increases frost beyond normal depths.  My thinking is that the gravel may fill with water, freeze, and lift the pad a small amount.  But it won't heave inches.  I make sure that the equipment has flexible connections so a small amount of lift won't break anything.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

     A continuous gravel layer from the surface allows the cold to fall through the voids to the base of the layer.  A concrete slab with horizontal insulation 4" thick extending 3' beyound the limits of the foundation prevents this intrusion of cold.  I do not need to defend this design since it is successful with no failures in many built applications for numerous clients in New York and in Canada.
     I will be the EOR for your project for a modest fee if my details are incorporated.

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

(OP)
Thanks for the information guys, I at least have a start.

"because it worked in other places" isn't necessarily a valid argument in court and allows you to get sucked into errors caused by the contractor.  

RE: Turndown Footing Technique, No Frost Depth worries!!

Hire an expert, (someone who has built similar projects).

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources