×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

bend allowance for odd shapes

bend allowance for odd shapes

bend allowance for odd shapes

(OP)
Any bending mavens out there know how to get the bend allowance for bending odd shapes like C-channel or angle iron?

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Tick,

I've found that if you ask 10 different fab shops for their standard bend allowances for different materials you will get 12 different answers.  Is this something you can come up with by trial and error?

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

(OP)
I have some legacy work to fall back on.  I'm trying to find a way to at least come close by calculation.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

I cut a section and run a polyline along the neutral axis in AutoCAD.  It's usually close enough even for extreme precision sheet metal work.

The only problem is that when you ask a shop what bend radius they use, you'll _always_ get a wrong answer.  You have to go out and measure the actual radius they achieve on a representative part.

I hate that whole 'bend allowance' fantasy.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

TheTick (Mechanical)
If you have access to the shop where the work is to be done,
Shear a sample of metal, take it to the brake and bend it,
Measure the result and correct accordingly. This way you will be sure you have the correct radius and bend allowance
B.E.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Tick,
A good rule of thumb for bend allowances on a 90 deg bend are as follows:
thk<14GA  BA=1.57(r+1/3t)r=male die rad
thk>15Ga  BA=1.57(+.4t)

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

I would agree with jamfu if you are coining the outside rad if not I would use
thk<14GA BA=1.57(r+2/5t)

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

The calcs. are good to start. But are you bending with a press brake or a leaf? Hot or cold? Free form or die? With the grain or across?

These all make a difference. Go to the Fab Shop and ask. If you need something special, pay for a few samples.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Yeah, go to the shop.  Theoretical bend allowances are good for figuring out roughly how much material you'll need as a first approximation, but I've found they're utterly useless for production.  Each shop has figured out their own bend radii on each of their machines and workers using their particular source of steel.  One time, I had to send a shipment of parts back that were out of tolerance because they'd gotten new dies for their brakes and had forgotten to readjust their allowances.  Another time, they switched metal suppliers and had to delay shipment by a day so they could adjust their radii.  There are a million factors that go into a job shop's actual bend radii.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

TheTick ...

Am I right in assuming you are wanting to bend, extruded/pultruded/rolled channels and angles?
What material?
Are they structural or decorative?
What is the min radius required?
Are they being formed the "right" way or the "wrong" way

All these things will determine which processes will be used (Rolled or Draw-formed, hot or cold) and the allowances needed.

cheers

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Tick, for small quantities and/or "normal" accuracy (say, R&D not practical) I agree with MikeHalloran, use the neutral axis length.

Regards,

Mike

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

The neutral axis is not an accurate way to develop a bend, never has been never will be.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

ajack1, ref the eqns above, the difference between these and an eqn based on the N.A is only the factor of t, 1/2t based on the N.A, and factors from 1/3 to 2/5 per the above. As the material becomes thinner, the differences become smaller as well.

Depends on how "accurate" you need to be. If I needed to slam out a piece or two and was measuring with steel rules, etc., I'd feel pretty good about using the N.A allowance. You'd have to measure pretty carefuly to see any difference.

Regards,

Mike

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

The polyline method in ACAD has always worked for me.  I have used it many times and have had very few times where it wasn't close (+/-.010") using CS (hot or cold rolled) or SS. Aluminum can be slightly more (+/-0.015"), but as long as you are not looking for precision then you should be allright.  But I am also in agreement with many of the others, in that you should just have some samples made and average the results.  **Remember, the accuracy not only depends on the calculations; it also depends on the machine and the operator.**

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

as a press toolmaker i use the formula 1/3 material thickness + the inside bend radius x 1.598.
this is a very accurate way of doing it.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Quote (TheTick):

Any bending mavens out there know how to get the bend allowance for bending odd shapes like C-channel or angle iron?

If I understand your post correctly, you do not want to bend a flat piece of sheet metal into a C-channel, you want to bend a  straight C-channel instead similar to this:

bent c-channel

We used a section bender to bend angle and c-channels.  Typically these are used to roll them into a circle but we bent the material by inserting it and moving the rolls up until we reached the desired angle.

Section bender sample

Sorry I cannot tell you the bend deductions because it will depend on the machine you use to bend it.

Flores

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

(OP)
Correct.  FYI we have solved this by experiment.  Still, I would like to hear about calculating & predicting.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Could someone elaborate on the ACAD method?

"polyline along the neutral axis in AutoCAD"

Thank you

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

A Polyline is a collection or group of sketch entities which have been combined to behave as if it were one entity.

If a polyline is created on the neutral axis (often along the mid-thickness of the material) it can be measured to give a close approximation of the flattened length.

cheers

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

It's the digital version of running a piece of string or thread along the CL/Bend line.

The subtle variation in some cad packages is to calculate the profile length for a section.  Subtract twice the thickness, then divide by 2 and hey presto!

KENAT, probably the least qualified checker you'll ever meet...

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

As for bending flat sheet metal, Bendworks is a great FREE tool.   Not only can you calculate a bend deduction, you can also reverse engineer parts made in your shop and find the k-factor to be used at a later date.

Bendworks
k-factor formula and tips

Flores

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

I tried two of the methods here with a part here and they were within 0.05"

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Quote:

I tried two of the methods here with a part here and they were within 0.05"
How many bends were on your sample?   If it was only 1 or 2 bends that would not fly here because we would be way out of tolerance on 6 bends.

Flores

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Just thought I would throw this in here.
The program is bendworks
http://www.ciri.org.nz/bendworks/
a super simple program for determining bend deductions,k factors,etc..
There is a nice part in the tools menu for reverse engineer k factor that I use all the time to get the right blank size for all press brake formed materials

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

smcadman, sorry for lack of details, that’s sum of tolerances for four 90 degree bends in 0.5" plate. The part is later force fit into a part, then welded, and finally machined.

RE: bend allowance for odd shapes

Quote (Gymmeh):

smcadman, sorry for lack of details, that’s sum of tolerances for four 90 degree bends in 0.5" plate. The part is later force fit into a part, then welded, and finally machined.

4 breaks on 18 GA. C.R.S., I would not be impressed, BUT 4 breaks on 1/2" plate is very impressive.   

Flores

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources