*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.
Partner With Us!
"Best Of Breed" Forums Add Stickiness To Your Site
(Download This Button Today!)
Member Feedback
"...This was the ONLY place that I could find information that I could use to resolve the problem. So thanks once again to member TomSark and the SQL forum!..."
I have a 24,000 pound boat being lifted by cables, bow and stern, attached to two 6inX10inX16ft aluminum I-Beams. Top and bottom flange ½ inch thick, 5/16 inch thick web. The beams flex approximately 1¼ inches from center to ends. Is this deflection acceptable/dangerous? Is this beam too small?
Deendick, In order to ascertain whether its a problem you need to supply data such as material type (i.e grade/spec of aluminium), whether the load is applied gradually or immendiately, what safety factor are you working to, what failure mechanism are you considering. All these things need to be known.
I have just did some quick math in my head, and i reckon your stresses are around 18000psi. So you should be ok from a pure tensile/compressive stress point of view with a safety factor of say 2 (till yield). I would want a much greater safety factor though (probably 8, so your no where near that).
Thank you 40818 and kenvlach for your response. It is greatly appreciated. To 40818...I do not know the material type/spec of the aluminum beam. Since the lift was manufactured in Florida I would have to assume it is the 6061-T6. 24,000 pounds would be the extreme weight of the boat with fully loaded water and fuel tanks and supplies. This beam is used in a boat lift, so the load is applied gradually as the boat is lifted, but then hangs over the water until it is lowered again. In the winter this could be as long as 5 to 6 months. There are no safety factors built into the lift...if the beam fails, the boat falls back into the water. Your quick math in your head, (remarkable), resulting in a safety factor of 2, makes me a little more comfortable, but I also would like more wiggle room. To kenvlach...the addition of the web links was a nice touch. I have contacted Schupan & Sons and asked for their recomendation for beam size.
Start A New Thread
Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.
DESCRIPTION: Material engineering other topics technical support forum and mutual help system for engineering professionals. Selling and recruiting forbidden.