Just how good is Pro/E?
Just how good is Pro/E?
(OP)
I am fairly new to the world of solid modelling and have been taking a look at all of the design packages out there. I have had some experience with AutoCAD (2D) and Solid Edge (3D).
I was recently informed that CATIA and Pro/E are at the top of the heap but that Pro/E is superior in that it is accepted on a wider range of operating systems. If this is the case where do packages like Solid Edge / Solid Works feature?
Can anybody give me some objective advice? i.e. is Pro/E really the top solid modelling package to have behind you?
Cheers
I was recently informed that CATIA and Pro/E are at the top of the heap but that Pro/E is superior in that it is accepted on a wider range of operating systems. If this is the case where do packages like Solid Edge / Solid Works feature?
Can anybody give me some objective advice? i.e. is Pro/E really the top solid modelling package to have behind you?
Cheers





RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
If you only make single parts, not to complex, and small, manageable assemblies, then most CAD systems will do the job the same.
The issue is as you expand your design, does your CAD system follow? Or will it be underpowered?
In terms of ease-of-use, ProE wins over Catia (unless you grew up in a UNIX world). In terms of complex surfaces, Catia may have the upper hand.
We use both at the office, and they both complement each other.
Best thing is to test run them, find people that use them and sit down with them for a few minutes. Dont bother with sales reps, they wont give you the full picture.
Steve.
http://www.3dlogix.com
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
One feature I miss most is the sketcher facility of Pro/E which in my opinion is far superior to Solid Works. Also Pro/E has a much more rigorous method of assembling components and allows you to build assemblies a lot quicker, with more control.
One thing I do not miss about Pro/E is using Pro/Intralink, although once you get the hang of it it is OK, just time consuming.
If you are looking to make assemblies that do not have too many moving parts then go for something like solid works. On the other hand you need some form of control over moving parts in large assemblies then go for Pro/E
Good Luck.
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
The main consensus among my fellow workers is very similar
especially when the user has had 6-12 months on catia.
I can only hope that when the auto industry changes to V5
it retains and improves upon it's virtues of simplicity and efficiency.
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?
RE: Just how good is Pro/E?