×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

pH control without using caustic
2

pH control without using caustic

pH control without using caustic

(OP)
I am currently working at a refinery were we have a problem with ammonia in our waste water this is due to partly to direct release to our holding basin and performance problems with slop water processing. we hae identified one of our problems as the presence of Organic acids that are trapping ammonia in the ammonium ion form. i have looked in to caustic but i doun't want to use it because of caustic cracking issues at process temps over 50 decC any suggestions on another way of neutralizing these organic acids

RE: pH control without using caustic

what about sodium carbonate?

RE: pH control without using caustic

Hi Gare..

From what I know from refinery wastewater experience is that ammonia source is primarily stripped sour water. Ammonia levels in wastewater directly depend on the SWS efficiency for this pollutant. Normally, the wastewater is subjected to stripping by elevating stream pH. If you have any issues with caustic, you can try other bases too. Lime has been proven one but generates sludge.

Regards
TechV  

RE: pH control without using caustic

Either lime or magnesium hydroxide will generate voluminous
"lime soap" sludge. MgO will not raise the pH high enough to convert the ammonium salts into ammonia to any great extent.

I second the suggestion to consider sodium carbonate if caustic is unacceptable. There are also zeolites that selectively adsorb ammonium ion, such as clinoptilite.

Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.

RE: pH control without using caustic

(OP)
Thanks for the info guys ill have a quick look at the sodium carbonate and see if its okay to use. Waiting on some analysis  of the feed do get exact concs of the organic acids ill write back with what i find

thanks

Gareth

RE: pH control without using caustic

Allow me to propose another alternative.  If problems with your slop system are sending more sour water to your WWTP, would it be possible to instead error on the other side and push a little more oil to your sour water system to help keep the unstripped sour water stream out of your water plant?

If this is a possibility there are a few questions you should ask yourself.  Does your sour water skimmer(s) provide adequate residence time for good oil recovery from their sour water stream?  Do your sour water tanks, and the level you run them at, provide adequate residence time for additional oil water separation, and are you set up well to skim those tanks if necessary?

The potential consequences include upsetting your sour water strippers, hydrocarbon fouling in your sour water strippers, consuming sulfur plant capacity with excess hydrocarbon in acid gas, and maybe even elevated CO emissions from your final incinerator.  So this option should not be considered lightly, but it may be worth looking into if your ammonia problems are bad enough.

Good luck.

RE: pH control without using caustic

(OP)
Sodium carbonate will still give me sodium hydroxide (caustic) in the line as the reaction with a weak acid produces sodium hydroxide

Na2CO3 + 2H2O à H2CO3 + 2 NaOH

and

pushing oil through would not reduce the amount of ammonia in the effluent which is the aim if increasing the stripper efficency. as iam trying to process crude water draw water which has been in contact with cude so im not sure werther Jason5000 what you proposed works.

thanks for posting guys its getting closer to a soulution

RE: pH control without using caustic

The neutralization reaction is sodium hydroxide + carbonic acid -> sodium carbonate + water:

2 Na(OH) + H2CO3 -> Na2CO3 + 2 H2O

This reaction does not reverse.

You are definitely not going to get caustic by neutralizing an organic acid with sodium carbonate.

RE: pH control without using caustic

Would you elaborate on the "cracking issues"?

RE: pH control without using caustic



The overall equation for the reaction between sodium carbonate solution and dilute hydrochloric acid for example is:


Na2CO3 (aq)  + 2 HCl (aq)  >>>>  2NaCl (aq)  + H20 + CO2 (g)


RE: pH control without using caustic

"Would you elaborate on the "cracking issues"?"

Thanks. I had figured it was some metallurgical issue beyond my understanding.

Perhaps, there are some kinds of stainless steel, in which intergranular corrosion will be promoted by sodium hydroxide. But, I don't know of any, and caustic soda is one of the friendliest materials to metal (if not to human flesh) that there is.

Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.

RE: pH control without using caustic

(OP)
Caustic Crackin / Corrosion = Localized corrosion due to the concentration of caustic that usually occurs under evaporative or high heat transfer conditions. It appears as localized metal loss such as grooves. it affects carbon steel and low alloy steel even with stress releaved welds.

The Feed contains mainly contains water, ammonia, H2S, Acetic acid, Propionic acid and Formic acid.

so im unsure as to how the Sodium carbonate will affect the system.     

RE: pH control without using caustic

Hmmm.

When you said "organic acids" I was thinking you meant fatty acids, like stearic, palmitic, etc.

The calcium salts of acetic, formic, and propionic acids are soluble in water. So, perhaps a lime slurry is a good choice for you. But, you need to have very good agitation in the reaction tank, lime is very prone to settle out in dead spots, unreacted.

Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.

RE: pH control without using caustic

If all that you are doing is neutralizing, then caustic should not be a concern. Mild steels (steels with low carbon and low alloy content) and stainless steels will crack if they are exposed to concentrated caustic (high pH) environments with the metal under a tensile stress.

Neutralization doesn't involve a concentrated caustic solution nor would it be occurring with a high pH. Neutralization involves taking the solution pH to a neutral pH of 7.  In addition, if you had high pH, you would be experiencing scaling from the other components in the water.

Intercrystalline cracking of steel caused by exposure to caustic solutions above 70°C while under tensile stress; once common in riveted boilers. Also known as caustic cracking. Your temperature does not appear to be high enough either to be concerned with.

Caustic usage will allow you to use the least amount of chemicals. If you use lime, you will also get volumes of waste sludge. Sodium Carbonate will also give you fizzing due to the off gassing of CO2.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

RE: pH control without using caustic

(OP)
The Problem is i need the pH at 8-9 (sorry for the confusion)For efficent stripping in the towers.

The caustic problem is due to possible build up of caustic in heat exchangers and the bottom of the tower which are at 70-120 degC.

ive been told by our inspections department that 5wt% caustic would count as a high concentration in this process, which i think is wrong. So the problem still stands!

I think 5Wt% caustic would be perfectly safe with an inline mixer down stream of the injection point along with an anlyzer to stop over doseing and it would be perfectly safe.  

RE: pH control without using caustic

A pH of 8-9 is not a high pH.

The 5% wt caustic is in the chemical feed line, not in the vessel itself.

The temperature is not that high either.

Don't see where you inspections department came up with this Caustic Crackin / Corrosion arguement.



RE: pH control without using caustic

"A pH of 8-9 is not a high pH.

The 5% wt caustic is in the chemical feed line, not in the vessel itself.

The temperature is not that high either.

Don't see where you inspections department came up with this Caustic Crackin / Corrosion arguement."

I don't either. I've seen equipment made of similar materials give reliable service for many years, on electroplating lines.

I recall, for example, a mild steel tank used to contain a steel blackening bath, 50+% sodium hydroxide, at 150+ degrees C for at least three years.

Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources