benzene analysis methods
benzene analysis methods
(OP)
I'm looking for some insight on analysing samples for benzene content. The application is a refinery vessel cleaning (via steam purge + chemicals) and we can sample off the top & bottom of the vessel (condensed steam).
My limited knowledge of gas testing tells me that if we're not into the large, expensive gas detectors, my options are hand-held LEL monitors (which will only give me LEL...) and Draeger tubes. If I remember correctly, you also have to acheive a certain level of toluene & xylene before you can get an accurate benzene reading. This may seem like a crude method of analysis, but for this type of applicaton (i.e. monitoring & trending), is it the most economical? Final tests are always done by our customers, so accuracy is not my largest concern.
My limited knowledge of gas testing tells me that if we're not into the large, expensive gas detectors, my options are hand-held LEL monitors (which will only give me LEL...) and Draeger tubes. If I remember correctly, you also have to acheive a certain level of toluene & xylene before you can get an accurate benzene reading. This may seem like a crude method of analysis, but for this type of applicaton (i.e. monitoring & trending), is it the most economical? Final tests are always done by our customers, so accuracy is not my largest concern.





RE: benzene analysis methods
The kind of equipment you mention is entirely nonspecific; and cannot be made specific without some means of separating the various compounds. Like, GC.
Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.
RE: benzene analysis methods
Thanks for the feedback
RE: benzene analysis methods
I don't know the chemistry behind the particular Draeger tube you're using. I imagine that it is some kind of generalized oxidative reaction, such as dichromate or permanganate oxidation. These reactions go much faster with compounds that have a side chain attached to the aromatic ring. This, I imagine, is the mechanism by which the "prefilters" used with some of these tubes work.
Take a look at this:
device: Detector Tube
manufacturer: Dräger
model/type: Benzene 5/b, order no. 67 28071
sampling information: 20 strokes
upper measurement limit: 50 ppm
detection limit: approximately 1 ppm
overall uncertainty: 25%
method reference: on-site air secondary (manufacturer)
I got it from:
www
An uncertainty of 25% could easily make the data you're looking for disappear in the analytical "noise." If I were responsible for this monitoring job, I'd find such a method to be a slender reed to lean on.
Dave Wichern
http://www.dedalusenviro.com
Science is a business of empiricism.
RE: benzene analysis methods
What are you trying to measure LEL or Benzene?
IF it were me in the field I would surely be doing LEL just to keep from getting incinerated.
IF benzene:
First thing I would read the Draeger sheet. These are very informative.
Why are you doing the monitoring? For employee protection, to determine how much benzene is in tank and how much cleanup you got left, how much benzene in plume or what?
From that what level of accuracy do you need and or want?
Do you have to have immediate in field results?
How close is the plant chem lab? What kind of equpment do hey have and can they support you??
IN FIELD GC sounds real neat and all but it has its own set of problems. If you think Draeger tubes are expensive just wait for a full GC setup.
Dan Bentler
RE: benzene analysis methods
Your application sounds like an EPA or OSHA issue. Search the web for "EPA method" and benzene. I think that you will find a bunch associated with Volitile Organic Sampling Train, gaseous organic compund immission by GC, VOC;s using Texax adsorption, GC and mass spec, SUMMA passivated canister sampling, air and oil quality improvement research - speciation, ...