×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Plastic and Elasic Modulus
2

Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Plastic and Elasic Modulus

(OP)
Please advise what is the difference between plastic and elastic modulus and how do we calculate the Plastic Modulus? Thank you.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Elastic modulus is the steel modulus based on the stress strain curve before yielding.  The plastic modulus is after yielding.  Plastic section modulus (Z) for various shapes are given in the steel book.  I'm not sure how its' calculated.  Plastic design is based on maximum strength of the steel and is covered in Chapter N of the 1989 ASD.  I think the new 360 spec to uses it.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

2
The elastic section modulus assumes the section remains elastic.  The plastic section modulus assumes the entire section yields.  For a rectangular section the ratio of plastic section modulus to elastic section modulus is 1.5.  For WF shapes it is around 1.13-1.17.
The plastic section modulus is calculated by first finding the PNA (plastic neutral axis).  This is the axis about which there is an equal amount of AREA above and below.
The next step is to find the centroid of the area above and below the PNA independently.  
Now multiply the total area of the section times the distance between these two centroids.  Now you have the plastic section modulus.  This for a ductile material like steel.  It is similar for something like a steel beam with a composite concrete slab, but not exactly the same.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

i think terms are getting mixed up here, 'cause we use "modulus" in so many ways.

perhaps dcnnng could clarify if he's using the term referring to stress/strain curves or to "section modulus" (menaing stresses for a cross-section in bending).

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

(OP)
Thanks Bagman for your prompt response. But I am interested to know as how to calculate manually the Plastic Modulus for a built-up steel box section instead of a standard section. Appreciate very much for any expert advising me. Thank you!

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

dcnng-
See my response above.  It is pretty detailed and will give you the plastic section modulus.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

(OP)
rb1957, I am referring to the steel Section plastic modulus.

Thank you StructuralEIT for your input, do you mean that the neutral axis for elastic modulus is based on linear triangular stress block with only the outer layer at full stress whereas the plastic modulus is based on full rectangular stress block ? Thank you!

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Yes, that is correct.  That is why the PNA will be different than the ENA if the section is not symmetrical about the horizontal axis.  To satisfy statics, the compression force and tension force must be equal.  Since both are being stressed to full fy, that means there must be an equal area of steel in compression and tension.  

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

The total area of the section mentioned by StructuralEIT above I believe must be the area of the section above or below the PNA, not the cross section area of the entire member.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

i think another constraint on the NA (Elastic or Plastic) is that it is perpendicular to the moment vector.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Ah, nice catch Bagman.  It should have been the area above or below, and they will be equal.  Not the area above and below.  I should probably re-read these posts before I hit the submit button.
The rest of it is correct.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

dcnnng,

You should be asking your supervisor(or lecturer) these sorts of questions, this forum is not really a good place to learn these types of fundamental concepts.

csd

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Actually, I was kind of glad he asked.  I knew what plastic modulus was/is but didn't know how it is calculated.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

(OP)
csd72, yes we can go back to ask our lecturer but we have left school long time ago. Sorry that I don't agree with you that this is not the right place to ask this sort of question. Well I get my problem answered and many thanks to all of you.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

if you're interested in other plastic bending analysis tools (that i think allow more than this approach) look up Cozzone.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

rb1957-
AISC limits us to the approach outlined above.  

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

dcnng,

Appologies but we do get students on this forum every now and then and I know nothing about you.

If you have to ask about something so fundamental then it shows me that you do not understand it. You will get quick answers in this forum, but it will not necessarily help in your understanding.

As engineers we should not only know, but also understand. It is often the lack of the latter that leads to engineering failures.

csd

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

I am so what agree with csd72. I think not just the newly graduates, but quite a few of seasoned engineers do not know or remember how to do this type of calculation. But as a professional, we shall at least open some text books to understand what we are looking for, especially when engineering assumptions were involved.

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Just to throw this in there the PNA is only dependent on the area if the cross section is homogenious - with hybrid girders, cover plates of different yield strength, etc, the PNA should be based on force balancing (area*fy) as opposed to just area balancing.  

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

What I would like to know is, how come in the US and maybe elsewhere S is elastic section modulus and Z is plastic, and in Australia and maybe elsewhere it is the other way around?  Is it just because we are down under?

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

In the US they use z instead of s in many places throughout the dictionary.

No idea, but it goes to show that when you deal with overseas engineers its best to state what it is and not just use the letter.

csd

RE: Plastic and Elasic Modulus

Z is elastic section modulus in the UK and presumably in most of the Commonwealth. As for the US, they have their own gallon and ton, so why not their own Z & S?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources