beams by computer analysis
beams by computer analysis
(OP)
hello
do you trust the moment values resulting from sap , Etabs...etc analysis?? even if it differs from values resulting from manual load distribution and solving beams?
another thing for flat slabs
how do you handle the huge values of shells -ve momnets at column joints? and what are the actual design values you use?
do you trust the moment values resulting from sap , Etabs...etc analysis?? even if it differs from values resulting from manual load distribution and solving beams?
another thing for flat slabs
how do you handle the huge values of shells -ve momnets at column joints? and what are the actual design values you use?






RE: beams by computer analysis
The code clauses rely on this to work, whereas the computer analyses tend to treat it as an elastic medium and figure out the moments based on this assumption.
It is important to remember that reinforced concrete is not an elastic medium, so any elastic analysis is still only an approximation.
csd
RE: beams by computer analysis
1-Size of plate element and mesh size
2-Torsional stiffness for a beam is considered so some of stresses are transferred as torsion
3-axial deformation of column supports
Using software results need always engineering judgment
For flat slab you will always have high values at support and lower value for positive moments than hand calculations , to avoid this I generally design for the moment around my column and add around 20% extra reinforcement for positive moment.
RE: beams by computer analysis
I'm not sure about other programs but in SAP under section properties you can set the shear area equal to zero... thus the software will only consider bending deformation.