×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

(OP)
My question is about loads acting on shear cleat attaching a typical fuselage frame to the skin.
It is a Airbus design policy to use L- shape shear cleats to attach frames to the skin & stringers. In this case frames have no mouse-holes,where stringers pass through. Mouse-holes are on shear cleats.
As far as I know,load on the fasteners attaching shear cleat to the skin, shear only. Is it the case also for deltaP load cases? I mean, for internal pressure load cases, might there be any tensile load on these fasteners i.e. does shear cleat becomes tension cleat :)

If you can help me I will be glad.
Thanks in advance.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

I think you're correct, under pressure the fuselage skin is going to "breathe" outwards and the only connection between the frames and the skin is the shear clips, so they'll carry some tension.  Mind you it'll be pretty small, I'd expect less than 100 lbs/rivet, but the best way to find out is a non-linear FE, maybe a simple linear model will get you close enough.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

(OP)
Thanks rb1957.

Probably, since the magnitude is small, it is ignored for metallic designs. Therefore, in my short carrier, I have never seen that they have ever been taken into account.
But in composite design, it seems, even this magnitude, that it can cause a problem because of pull-through phenomenon.

Cheers.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

I agree with the previous replies and like to add that the hard points in the stringer stiffened skin are at the stringer - frame junctions. At these stiffer locations the highest restraint will occur and one can see that the considered cleats are connected to the stringers as well as the frame and the outward load due to delta P can be transferred as shear thru these connections. Also note that one can also see floating frame designs where only stringer - frame joints are made with cleats and no connection exists between skin and frame.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

Gokmavi - why don't you just get the loads from the airplane internal loads FE model and use those loads to design the shear clips?

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

(OP)
SWComposites -
Question was whether there can be any tension load on the shear cleats due to internal pressure. In metallic fuselage structure I have never seen anybody who is trying to calculate such load acting on the cleats.
Question was not about shear loads.

Regards.
 

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

Yes, there can be tensile loads, with magnitude depending on whether there are also clips between the stringers and frame.  Does your internal loads FEM not calculate the loads in the shear clips?  or is the model idealized such that only shear loads are reacted in the shear clips.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

(OP)
In global FEM, there is no shear cleat.
Shear loads on them are calculated by simply taking the differences of normal forces (calculated from grid point force balance) at two ends of each BAR element idealizing the frame.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

that's pretty odd ! ... not modeling the shear clips would have a significant effect on the loads in the frames (and the skins and the clips, too).

if you're stressing hte clips you always try "no analysis required, as these aren't primary structure (not modelled in the fuselage model)".  my next tack would be "OEM, because you didn't model them I'll have to do ,000s of hours of work to determine the effect (basically to model them !), so you pay me for that"  seriosuly, trying to actuately account for their effect is going to be little short of adding them into the model; you might (just, might) get somewhere by modelling a section of the fuselage with and without shear clips, applying a unit shear load into the skin to see how it redistributes with the new load path.

good luck !

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

(OP)
Dear rb1957,
I am not in global model business. But as far as I know,in the company that I work for, they model frames as BAR elements and skins as membrane elements and nodes are located at the outer loft. I did not see any shear cleat idealization in their global models. If I do the fuselage global model, I would model them with elements like NASTRAN CSHEAR elements lying on the plans perpendicular to the fuselage skin. Anyway, as I said, that's not my business and not my responsibility and I am not the decision maker.
I have got my answer about order of magnitude of possible tensile loads from you. It is as I expected. Thanks again.

RE: Loads on Shear Cleats (fuselage frames)

actually that may be ok.  your structure, for a frame, has an inner cap, a web attached to the skin, and the outer boom of the frame is pretty much the effective skin of the fuselage; there may (or may not) be an outer cap, continuous, floating on the stringers.  The global model sounds reasonable ... fuselage skin panels, broken by stringers and frame caps (well your shear clips), frame webs, an inner boom and an outer boom (again probably not much more than effective skin).

from this model i think you could say that the radial tension stresses in the frame webs (as modelled) is the tension that the shear clip has to carry, in addition to the shear introduced into the frame web.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources