×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Future developments of CAD????
3

Future developments of CAD????

Future developments of CAD????

(OP)
What do you think is the next step in the development of CAD packages? or do you know of any new features lookin to be included in new editions or add ons to CAD packages?

RE: Future developments of CAD????

If you mean a fantasy wish list, I wish someone would hurry up and invent a quality holographic display system for 3D modelling, allowing you to reach 'in' and manipulate a model directly.

Back in the real world, I want a closer, quality standard of conversion between different model formats.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Hey Knobhead,

To tkae your model formats idea a little farther, how about this idea.

I'd like to see an ANSI standardized MCAD file format.  Basically, a common file format that every MCAD package could read and write, including all the features and history.  This way, if your company changes MCAD platforms, there wouldn't be any legacy data to convert.  If that's too drastic, this ANSI file format could be an enhanced neutral format, kinda like a STEP file.  Each package could still have its own unique file format, but transfering files (with history) to another platform would be a no brainer.  Nothing would get lost and users wouldn't have to run a feature recognition program.

Don Shoebridge
Sr. Product Developement Engineer
www.geocities.com/donshoebridge

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Hi there,

I love your holographic manipulation idea, kinda "Disclosure" (this not credible movie with M. Douglas refusing Demi Moore !). I think that a mouse and a screen are not ergonomic enough for 3D.

I think that the users will define their future needs.

I'm afraid of any standard that could kill the competition between the CAD companies.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Interesting topic. One way I feel that CAD is moving at the moment, in the AEC market at least, is the 'total building model' where the 3D model is the building is created and all of the relevant information about the building is stored, from structure all the way through to heating costs and electrics etc.

This would enable the project team to access and design/update their section of work which is then easily accessible by the other team members. As a simple example, if a pipe is moved by the HVAC Engineer automatic clash detection with a beam would be flagged up and the Structural Engineer would respond. The contractor is able to access all of the bills of quantities, and in the final building, facilities managers are able to obtain specifications of everything down to a the lightbulbs.

Neutral file formats are a must for these types of ideas to evolve and I'm all for it. The compotition between CAD systems would then be based around price, which can only be good for all of us! Some companies would fall by the wayside - hopefully Autodesk - but thats the cold reality of the commercial world. However, it may mean that only the best survive, theory of evolution and all that.   

RE: Future developments of CAD????

You want to know what I'd like? With every CAD package, there should be an accompanying hard copy library of GOOD manuals, with A LOT of examples RELEVANT to what's real. Non-confusing manuals and GOOD tutorials would be nice.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Hi all,
The future of CAD program is in using of informative 3D element blocks, which include information and means for professional decisions.
Volk

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Ah, you mean Lego.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Hi all,
I think , what Volk supposed would happen in near future, so there will be no more CAD or CAE or CAE. All will merge to CAx, in other word, it would be only one engineering package for all engineering tasks, thinking to the newly CAD-Packages !
And then..later...the CAx packages would be married with virtual reality, so the engineers can test their design virtually

cheers

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Every new software release needs to include a list of the jobs that it has just obsoleted by making the program easier, quicker, more intelligent, etc, etc!!!  And then a fistful of resumes to hand out to the employees.

(cold & breezy with some rain)

Thank you West Coast, look out East Coast because Chicago is ____________
today!!

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Dear Folks;

I'd like to see materials represented like the way they work in the real world. Springs that bounce up and down, shafts that spin and deflect under load, sparks that fly off when you make something interfere, chunks of metal flying everywhere, mass hysteria, women and children - the end of the world as we know it.

And then a little dialog box that pops up on a black screen of death that says "Game Over - System FUBAR error"

Have a nice weekend all !

Adrian

RE: Future developments of CAD????

<I'd like to see an ANSI standardized MCAD file format.  Basically, a common file format that every MCAD package could read and write, including all the features and history. >

EDS-PLM (UG, and iDeas), Autodesk and PTC announced at back in Feb that they were cross licensing their 3D modeling
engines, so this is closer than you think.

Realistically, I see 3 directions in CAD
1) Broad collaboration - along the 'total building' that
   AJUK mentioned.  PTC's Windchill, Bentley's recent
   Microstation and EDS-PLMs eViz are the first steps in
   this direction
2) More and more automated wizards.  You are starting to
   see this in the AEC space, where wizards help with
   HVAC routing and such.  Soon you will see software
   packages doing this automatically the way they currently
   automate walls and such
3) A convergence of 3D 'content creation'.  Companies like
   Autodesk already own other 3D 'content creators' like
   Discreet (they did the FX for Terminator 2), you are
   going to see this trend accellerate.

With the advent of 3D printers, we aren't that far from
having 'virtual sculpture' of a component that is cheaply
rendered right there in the office.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

A very interesting "white-paper" from NASA on the aspects of neutral CAD files and extracting geometry from various platforms.

http://gltrs.grc.nasa.gov/reports/2002/TM-2002-211358.pdf

"Happy the Hare at morning for she is ignorant to the Hunter's waking thoughts."

RE: Future developments of CAD????

I would settle for an inexpensive networked viewer for ProE. It seems everything usable is overpriced, it is impossible to economically go to electronic file storage.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Design Automation is the next step in CAD, but in my experience a lot of engineers don't want to know. (turkeys dont look forward to Xmas or Thanksgiving!). You can see examples of embyonic design automation at www.modularcad.co.uk

RE: Future developments of CAD????

I think automated design is fine for some applications, but will never be used in the majority.  If you have something to design which is "basic", it will work.  Look at the examples from the above posted website.  It looks mostly like shelving, cabinets and storage.  I don't think you'll see cars, medical devices or other gadgits being desinged this way.

"The attempt and not the deed confounds us."

RE: Future developments of CAD????

Hi
I would like to see the new generation of CAD systems supporting 'Feature-based Design'. But the features should be based on ISO STEP AP224 standard and exporting the product data to a neutral data file containes not only geometrical and toplogical data, but also features data, material data, tolerances data and so on.

RE: Future developments of CAD????

  <Design Automation is the next step in CAD, but in my experience a lot of engineers don't want to know>

   If one's can provide us with failproof power tools for sure they will be wellcome....... but before the design phase you must model and  after you may wish to optmize and for those easy tasks I guess that I will be a grandpa still waiting for the A.I. development.

Peace and luck,

       Fred

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources