×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Series resonant circuit help

Series resonant circuit help

Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
Hi I am new to the forum. I have been studying and recently doing experiments with (LC) series resonant circuits at home. I have been referencing numerous electrical engineering books for information on series resonance, but unfortunately I have been unable to find any books that break the phenomenon down to the most basic level as to what is really going on in a series resonant circuit to reduce impedance to to zero. I have seen the vectors and the math but that really doesn't explain to me how for example the capacitor is able to interefere with the inductor's ability to control current rise in itself. All I can do is theorize that the capacitor's voltage rises at the same rate as the inductor's reactive voltage which results in no voltage drop across the the LC network. If anyone has had it explained to them or understands it more deeply and is willing to share the information please respond.

Thanks

RE: Series resonant circuit help

If you think that the vectors do not explain it, then I do not know how to explain it to you. Complex algebra. Would that be better for you? Vectors, math, algebra there's not much left, really.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

If you think series LC resonance (Lo-Z) is a mind bender, then try parallel LC resonance (Hi-Z).

RE: Series resonant circuit help

How about: Reactance (X) can be either positive (+X) or negative (-X). In series, they add (+). Thus: +X + -X = 0.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
I can understand parallel resonance a lot better than series resonance. When I say I would like to have a deeper understanding of series resonance I mean to take for example one 12 volt pulse of power. If I had a inductor at a value of 1 henry and 3 ohms it would take aprox 333 milliseconds to build up a current of 4 amps through it. Now when I add a capacitor of 0.001 uF in series behind the inductor the current builds to 4 amps in approx 100 microseconds. what I am trying to understand is how the capacitor enables the current to build to its full amount in the inductor in a shorter time than if the inductor was by itself. I speculated that it had something to do with the capacitors voltage rise since I know that a inductor controls current flow through itself by inducing a voltage to counter the current that is rising in itself. If the capacitor is rising in its voltage at the same rate that the inductor is inducing the counter voltage (back emf) wouldnt that mean there is no voltage drop across the two components?

thanks

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
I am sorry about a miscalculation I did in the above post. In the first inductor example it would take current 1.665 seconds to rise to 4 amps.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Are you clear on the difference between transient response and steady-state ac response?  

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Consider using a sine wave rather than a pulse.  The current through both the cap and inductor is the same.  The voltage across the cap will lag the current by 90 degrees, the voltage across the inductor will lead the current by 90 degrees. Thus, the voltage across the cap and inductor will be 180 degrees out of phase. When at resonance, the magnitudes of the voltages will be the same, thus cancelling out and causing a net voltage of 0.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
dpc,

I am not really clear on the difference between the two definitions. I have played around with parallel resonant circuits and was able to drive them with pulsating dc at the resonant frequency. My example about was based on the calculated time constant for current to rise to maximum through the inductor. I assumed that current through the inductor rises to maximum in series resonance in just a shorter period of time but I may be mistaken.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
geekee,

Thanks for your response. I have read that explanation before the the cap and inductor work together to bring current and voltage into phase. I may be on a pointless quest. I was just hoping to learn more deeply what happens in that small instant of time when current flow though the inductor is rising much faster than it would without a capacitor in series, or how it is that the capacitor is appearently able to interfere with the inductor's back emf. I mess around with inductors and capacitors a lot as a hobby. thanks again
 

RE: Series resonant circuit help

The problem is the difference between a steady state response to AC and a transient response to a switch-on (for example). You can be assured that AC transients are very hard to think about so electronics engineers tend to not think about them too much! The answer is to simulate the circuit with SPICE and you can then plot out the voltage and current waveforms. This may help to explain it without using maths.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
logbook,

That maybe the direction I need to explore next. thanks

RE: Series resonant circuit help

My suggestion is to first analyze the transient and steady-state response to a dc input.  The steady-state portion of the dc case is trivial, but that won't be the case for ac.

The ac case will also have the same second-order differential equation to solve with both a transient and steady-state component.  The standard descriptions of resonant LC circuits for ac systems generally only deal with the ac steady-state case.

Actually, a pretty good reference source is the ARRL's Radio Amateur's Handbook - just about any edition.  There is a pretty good section on basic ac and rf theory explained without need for calculus.  You should be able to find a recent edition at a local library.  

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
dpc,

Thanks for the suggestion. I happen to have the 2006 version of the arrl handbook. I must not have looked close enough for a good explanation. Thanks again to taking the time to respond.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

A spring with a mass connected to the spring is an equivalent to a series LC circuit (Spring = C, Mass = L).  Put driving functions into the spring support and observe what happens.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Dear chadj2,

If I had understood that you did not even understand the difference between transient DC and steady state AC! Then I had redflagged this thread as inappropriate at once instead of letting so many people try to make you understand.

Your last post "That maybe the direction I need to explore" says it all.

It may not be somthing that you need to explore. These things are well explored and well understood by most engineers that has taken basic electricty at school. You are an engineer? Aren't you?

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
Skogsgurra,

I am terribly sorry for wasting your time. I would not have posted if I had known that my question would upset some members. I am not an electrical engineer, I just really love electronics and talking about it. Once again sorry.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Basic electricity is included in all engineering schools - not only EE schools. So, you should know about this.

The problem is not that you waste my time. The problem is that threads like these make people wonder about the level of engineering as such and if the Eng-Tips is for hobbyists or professionals. This has recently been discussed in Pat's Pub and other places.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Well, not so much "discussed" as "ranted about" it by me for a few precious minutes before it was yanked winky smile

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: Series resonant circuit help

There are also other discussions going on. It is a policy thing. Besides, there are hobbyist sites.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
Like I said before I didn't mean to open a can of worms. I was just hoping to get a deeper understanding of series resonance which went into the precise interactions between the capacitor in inductor. Of course I can pass a test on what it is and the math problems concerning it. I just wanted to find out more. Right now I am referencing some old EE books from the 1940s and 1950s hoping to find more indepth coverage of the subject.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Fair enough.

But it is very simple, actually. You just have to forget about those pulses. They have very little to do with an AC circuit (except that they are a special case of the transient solution to the differential equations describing a series resonant circuit). But that, you have to leave for a little later, when you have undserstood the steady state AC solution.

So, here goes:

You have an inductor and a capacitor connected in series. Fed from an AC voltage source. Right?

There is a current flowing through this circuit. An AC current of a certain amperage. Say I amps. Right?

Now (vector diagram needed) draw one thick arrow from a point from center of a paper to the right. Make it about four inches (ten cm) long. This represents the current. Let's say it is 4 amperes.

As you know. Voltage across an inductor leads current by 90 degrees. Right? Then draw a new arrow pointing from center of paper (where current arrow starts) vertically upwards. Done?

This arrow represents the voltage across the inductor. The phase rotation in a vector diagram is always CCW. So, a leading vector is drawn 90 degrees CCW from the reference vector (the current arrow).

Now. You have half the picture. Any questions? Yes? Ah! If these arrows represent amplitude or RMS? Good question. Well, lets say for now that they represent amplitudes. More on that later.

Look at the circuit diagram. You have two elements (inductor and capacitor) in series. Voltages across the two elements sum (just like the voltage of two batteries sum). So, now you have to add the capacitor voltage to the inductor voltage. In other words, draw a new arrow (representing capacitor voltage) from the inductor voltage arrow tip.

Just one little step left for you now. Are you OK so far? Good.

As you already know (see, you actually knew all these things already!) the capacitor voltage lags the current. So, the capacitor voltage arrow shall be pointing downwards, parallel to the inductive voltage, but in opposite direction. Do that! Yes! from the top of the inductor voltage downwards.

Yes, that means going back towards where it all started.

How long? That depends. Let's say about half-way down the inductor voltage arrow.

Now, when you look at this diagram, you see a reference arrow going to the right, a voltage arrow going up and another voltage arrow going down. The sum of the voltage arrows is the distance from starting point to the tip of the down-pointing arrow. Got it? Good. What's that you said? Yes, right. This is the voltage across the circuit.

Now, resonance. That is when you have equal impedance in inductor and capacitor. Yes, same voltage drop across capacitor as across inductor. BUT DIFFERENT DIRECTIONS!

So, if you make the capacitor voltage longer. Same length as inductor voltage. What do you get? What? Nothing? Oh, yes. You mean there's no distance left between starting point and tip of capacitor voltage? Yes, that's right! No voltage across the circuit!

That is what resonance is about. Current but no voltage, Z = U/I so you have also zero impedance. Got it?

It wasn't that hard. Was it?

This is essentially what the text-books say. Only with fewer words.



There may be quite a few typos in this. I didn't have energy left to proof-read it.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Look up the formulas for inductive reactance and capacitive reactance. You will see that one of the terms in both equations is frequency. A sign wave is assumed.

A resonant circuit is not universally resonant. It is only resonant at one frequency.
You may get interesting results by pulsing an L/C circuit with DC, but resonance is unlikely without a lot of math, or a little bit of trial and error.
And, by the way, the DC must reverse polarity on every pulse or the capacitor will charge and the current will stop.
respectfully.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
Skogsgurra,

Thank you for taking the time to write that explanation. It helped clarify some more things to me. I guess my big problem is that I wanted to understand how resonance occurs with a waveform resembling pulsating DC or such. As I stated before I am not an electrical engineer. My degree is in aeronautics I am actually a pilot by trade. As waross stated I was able to get parallel resonance with pulsating DC with a tiny bit of trial and error, meaning I calculated the resonance frequency and just adjusted the function generator a bit to get maximum impedance. The only difference I noticed from having an AC signal was the amplitude on the negative side was a bit lower than the positive side. When I started observing some series resonance circuits I built I was intrigued with the voltage amplification I was seeing on my scope which occurs across each component but as you stated add to zero for the total LC. I probably should have said this is not work related I just enjoy experiments with power electronics in my free time. I guess in this age of TV and video games experimenting with resonant circuits with different waveforms for fun is strange. I can understand why a lot of EE's do not like to mess with or think about this stuff when not doing it for work. I don't really like talking about flying or doing traveling during my free time either. Once again thank you for helping me get a more indepth understanding of this topic.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

(OP)
P.S. I have been reading that Tesla did a lot of work on resonant circuits so I will study some of his writings.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

chad, if you're going to use square waves, you can simply consider them to be the sum of a series of sine waves (look up Fourier transform) and all of the above explanations still hold.

waross, I think the pulsating DC does not have to reverse polarity. It's all a matter of what you take to be your reference voltage (GND).  You can build a filter with a positive and negative supply, or you can build it with a single supply. The only difference is that you'll have an offset with respect to ground on the single supply version.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Hi geekEE;
I saw a reference to "Pulses of DC".
To me a series of pulses means an applied voltage followed by an open circuit. However from rereading the thread it appears that the OP is using a function generator which does not go open circuit but switches between two defined voltage levels (one of which may be zero).
In this case I have to agree with you.
Although the voltage does not have to reverse, I believe that the current must reverse.
respectfully

RE: Series resonant circuit help

chadj,

You have to get your definitions straight. In this discipline (electric engineering) there are quite a few understood things. Like this resonance thing. It is always about sine waves (yes, sine - not sign). Square waves or whatever you are applying to your circuit are not sine waves. So you had better get hold of a simple function generator (or signal generator) and switch to sine output. Then, get an oscilloscope, then start your experimenting from there.

Applying pulses to a circuit is also a very valid and interesting excercise. But the resulting waves are a little more complex to analyze and understand. Do not expect to get a good and solid understanding of these matters without taking a formal course. It is possible, of course, for very gifted and talanted individuals to derive all these things all by themselves. If you are one of those individuals, go on. By all means. But building on knowledge that is commonly available is more practical and acquiring that knowledge is usually best done in schools.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

I have a little fun application.  Years ago I picked up a bunch of nice German 220V muffin fans. When I put the right cap in series with one, it gives me about 180V on the motor winding.  Just the speed for nice quiet operation. A novel way to generate a higher voltage from 120V easily.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Another "Free Energy" patent coming up?  winky smile

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: Series resonant circuit help

Just put one fan in front of the other and you can "harvest" all that wind!!

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: Series resonant circuit help

When I was just a little sprout I put a capacitor in series with a 120V power transformer. I wanted to reduce the output and capacitors resist the flow of AC.  The transformer went up in smoke.  Lessons like that stick with you. All this low voltage stuff isn't as much fun. You just don't have the same impact looking at a scope.

Wisdom comes from knowledge.
Knowledge comes from experience.
Experience comes from bad decisions.

RE: Series resonant circuit help

That's ingenious Operahouse.
I once considered using a capacitor to run a DC relay on AC. When I went looking for components I found an AC relay before I found an appropriate capacitor so I didn't complete the experiment.
respectfully

RE: Series resonant circuit help

I'd be with waross. To me, applying a pulse means that there is a DC source available and the DC is applied to the circuit with a momentarily closed switch.

An FFT of the result when a pulse is applied is usually more telling than just looking at the waveform on a scope.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources