×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

beam design software

beam design software

beam design software

(OP)
I am a mech. engr and I have a client that will require several beam designs in different sizes and loading.

They will all have uniformly distributed loads, that do not extend the full length between simple supports.

Also I might have the same in a statically indeterminate (3 supports) arrangement.

I need to calculate stress and deflection. There are enough variations and investigations to make software the best way to go.

I would appreciate any recommendations you guys might have. I probably will not use this again. I will not be designing trusses or complex designs, and would like to spend under $300.

Any suggestions. Thanks alot in advance!

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: beam design software

What design specification will you be using?

RE: beam design software

(OP)
This is for an industrial product, not a bridge or other such design so there is no design spec, other than what I have set for my design.

In my case, my initial shot will use about 1/3 Sy to achieve deflections within the parameters of my machine.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: beam design software

(OP)
I located a software package from Orand in Canada called Beam 2D.

Does anyone have any experience with this? It looks good.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: beam design software

Methinks that you may be slightly over your head IMHO and you should really consult with a qualified structural engineer.  This exercise is not just about designing and picking suitable beam section, but there are also the connections to consider.

RE: beam design software

ostand, I know you said that software is the way to go.  But if you look at AISC steel manual it has all the Shear Moments Deflections formulas for all the things you mentioned.  Maybe just do a spread sheet so it will be a lot quicker to do different problems.  But if you are going to use it again for other projects then yeah, buy a program.

I use struc calc but they are closer to $500.  But they are cheap to upgrade.  It is really simple to use if you have continuous beam.  I wouldnt buy it if you are going to do trusses or frame though because it wont do that.

http://www.swijetty.com
Sea Water Intake and Jetty Construction

RE: beam design software

there are alot of spreadsheet solvers around ... excelcalcs.com for one, yakpol.net for another.  the solution (even for singly redundant beams) is pretty straight forward, it shouldn't take you long to develop your own spreadsheet (and you'll have the advantage of knowing exactly what everything does (and what assumptions you've built-in)

RE: beam design software

Quote (minorchord2000):

Methinks that you may be slightly over your head IMHO and you should really consult with a qualified structural engineer.  This exercise is not just about designing and picking suitable beam section, but there are also the connections to consider.

I am pretty sure a mechanical engineer can figure that out.  You dont have to be civil/structural to know all that.

http://www.swijetty.com
Sea Water Intake and Jetty Construction

RE: beam design software

Ostand
A word of warning, depending on the shape that you are using there may be failure modes you are not used to working with. Are you familiar with lateral torsional buckling and local buckling? These are failure phenomena that I personally would want to check.

I am sure that you are capable of determining the moments, shears and axial forces in the members, with that I would recommend Tedds. It is a program that I use often and it checks these failure modes, if you input the forces. However I am not sure of the cost of this program.  I also believe that you can download a demo version of RISA. My old roommate from college used the demo version for a few months when he started working. You will not be able to save the file, and I am not sure of what you will be able to print out. But that may be an avenue worth looking into.

Good luck, and when in doubt make it stout.

RE: beam design software

I tend to agree with minorchord. Consultation with a structural engineer is probably advisable.  

What are the unbraced lengths of the beam? If they are overly long, is there a way to provide a brace point?

What kind of support do the reaction points have? Can what ever supports the new beams support the load of the unit plus the beam?

How will you connect the new beams to their supports?

These are questions that need to be answered. Plugging numbers into a software program with no understanding of what those numbers mean is a shaky way to proceed.

Would most of us structural engineers feel its OK to post a question on the mechanical board to the effect of ' I need to size an RTU for a small office, were can I buy a software program to size it for me?'

RE: beam design software

Check out www.Archoneng.com - "BEAMS" - $40 or $50 for steel only.  They also have a wood program

If doing wood and/or steel - check out www.BeamChek.com - about $150 - yes it is spelled that way

RE: beam design software

Here's a fairly simple, but decently comprehensive sizing program for 150 bucks, that should do everything you stated it needing to do.

http://www.beamchek.com/

I don't want to poke the proverbial beehive here, and I'm not looking to start some big off-topic discussion, but if we never did anything we've never done before, how would we learn ANYTHING??  This sounds like pretty simple stuff as far as the world of engineering goes.  Not like you're building a skyscraper.  Good luck with your project, and if you have a question, post it on here! That's what these boards are FOR.

RE: beam design software

So, what you are saying is that it is OK for someone to practice engineering outside their area of knowledge and expertise.

I think most state liscensing boards for engineers would tend to disagree with that position.

RE: beam design software

Not to be contentious or territorial, but here are my thoughts:

I am a practicing structural engineer.  I usually know what I don't know, and generally keep myself out of trouble by asking the right questions.

If you don't know what you don't know, you may not even realize that you need to ask certain questions.  The tiniest gap in your knowledge can have disastrous consequences in this profession.

Are we enabling someone that is delving into an area outside their field of expertise to unknowingly get themselves into serious trouble?  It has definitely happened before, and merits a warning at the very least.  There are attorneys out there waiting with knife and fork for people who screw up when they practice outside their field of expertise.

Ostand, only you can answer the question as to whether you know what you don't know.  If you cannot readily answer all of the questions posed by lkjh345, and there will be no one to check your design, then you really should consider having a structural engineer handle the beam designs.



    

RE: beam design software

If this is a beam that's part of a machine, I have to assume that a ME would be an expert at designing that kind of thing--probably much more than most of us, considering fatigue, etc.  I guess it depends on whether this is more of a mechanical application or structural application.  Only ostand knows that.

RE: beam design software

I just wanted to make a point that engineers are more versatile than that.  I could have taken a few more credits and I would have graduated double major in mechanical eng also.  Same goes with Mech eng major with civil eng.  Wouldnt advance mechanics of material cover connections?  I am pretty sure I also learned dummy load method to figure out deflection of a member from advance mechanics of material.  I just think sizing structural members are part of mechanical engineering also.  Have a good evening gentlemen.

http://www.swijetty.com
Sea Water Intake and Jetty Construction

RE: beam design software

If someone posts a request for a reference as to how to solve a problem, I'm willing to help.  As soon as someone asks for software to solve a problem, especially outside of their field, a red flag goes up.  I've seen too many engineers who are willing to trust a piece of software to solve a problem they otherwise couldn't solve. It may not be the case in this instance, but it sure sounds like it.

RE: beam design software

(OP)
Golly guys, I sure got it started. First, thanks to all, for your help and concern. For the record I am both a ME and PE and have (ugh!) over 30 years doing this. I am not building a bridge but a platform, 12inche off of the floor carrying a static load. I can't say more due to client confidentiality.

I have many of these, similar ones, to design, besides determining the best lengths and support locations. I don't feel it worth while building a spreadsheet, and checking it for this one job. I burned out on shear, moment and deflections. Just too many of them to do.

Considering what my time is worth, the bucks into a program is a bargain, even if I never use it again. A bargain for me and my client.

For your interest, I have found one program at $285 and it looks very nice (and friendly). I haven't purchased it yet, but have run the evaluation version. http://www.orandsystems.com/

I will look into your recommendations and again thanks to all.

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: beam design software

This is just a question, but if you are only 12" off the floor have you considered just blocking the machine up? What about pouring a 12" thick concrete pad. I am not sure what your situation is, but I am guessing that something like that could work well also.

RE: beam design software

I like DrFrame - www.drsoftware.com. There's also GRAPE - a free finite element program that's a lot of "fun" to play with.

RE: beam design software

I didn't look too hard into it, but does the orand software help you with design?  It looks like it is still up to you to determine allowables and the effects of local and global instability.

RE: beam design software

(OP)
DWHA

Well the reason is it moves slightly vertically and also must clear some machine elements on the floor, hence it is limited to being on supports.


The Orand software allows you to set up the problem very easily so you input loads (cont, conc., moment), supports (type and location), dimensions, I etc.

The output is shear, moment, deflection, stress, slope and maybe something else.

Check it out the free demo is full functioning. And no, I have no connection with them. Actually, I haven't purchased it yet, still using the demo.

Dave, I'll check out the ones you mention.

Thanks again

Paul Ostand
www.ostand.com

RE: beam design software

ostand,

Not to be entirely flip but, if your time is so valuable; wouldn't it be better spent farming out this work to someone who specializes in structural work? It will take far less time and the return product will definately be correct. In fact in the three days spent discussing which software to buy for under $300 dollars, a structural engineer could have had you an answer and kept the project moving.

I do structural and civil work and there are alot of other engineering problems I COULD tackle. But my time and my clients' money is better spent allowing those who specialze in those fields address those problems, while I address those in which my expertise lies.

RE: beam design software

Based on ostand's posts, it appears he has enough qualifications to size a beam.  A few posts over a 3 day period on this forum doesn't mean he's spending that much time looking for the correct software.  

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources