×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

(OP)
THE ORIFICE SHOULD BE LOCATED UPSTREAM OR DOWNSTREAM OF THE CONTROL VALVE??? WHY ?? WHICH POSITION IS MORE ACCURATE?? THE POSITION AFFECTS MORE IF IT IS A LIQUID OR IF IT IS A GAS??? WHERE CAN I FIND SOME INFORMATION??

REGARDS

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

orifice for what? more pressure drop, for measurement, for fun, for sound abatement, for getting the control valve in its midpoint?

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

(OP)
The orifice is for fluid measurement.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

In liquids the valve is down stream to assure no flashing.  On gas streams an upstream control valve can actually shorthen the meter run because its breaks up swirl.  Again, flashing and liquid formation means typically downstream.

the API MPM (AGA has information on the industry standards for measurement.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

Does the control valve control the flow, upstream pressure, downstream pressure, etc.  dcasto makes a point not often considered onshore.  Generally locate the flow measurement upstream.  Also, if you are controlling the pressure upstream then locate the measurement upstream.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

(OP)
The function of the control valve is to control the gas flow to a stripping tower.

I've seen a lot of PID's and the flow measurement it's always upstream the control valve (Liquid and gas cases). I wonder the reason and I think it's because we calculate the orifice of measurement with a pressure among other qualities of the fluid (Viscosity, spgr, temperature). The pressure will vary downstream the control valve, but upstream the control valve the pressure will remain constant. I was thinking that maybe we need a constant pressure for the measurement device, the orifice in this case.

Anyway I'll look up in the API MPM that dcasto said.

Regards

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

Most head-type flow elements requires a "fully developed flow profile".  This is achieved by long straight pipe or a flow conditioner upstream of the flow element.  Elbows within the same plain just upstream of the flow element increase the straight lenght.  Multiple elbows in different plains further increases the length.

The API MPMS is a complete manual of standards.  I don't have the complete set of the standards.  Addressing chapters, the head type flow measurement standards are mostly chapter 14.3.  Other standards include chapter 21, chapter 5 for Coriolis, etc.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

But a control valve upsteam shortens the meter lenght.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

(OP)
If you're designing you have to assure that there is a straight run enough for your meter.

I meant that the orifice should be upstream the control valve. In order to don't short the straight run of the meter you have to assure that there is enough straight pipe (I guess is 5 pipe diameters downstream the orifice and 20 pipes diameters upstream the orifice)

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

It's an unusual installation where the orifice plate would be located downstream of the control valve in my experience.

The instrumentation engineer wants, as mentioned, a fully developed flow profile into the meter.  The straight piping requirements will vary depending on the upstream piping configuration and what type of error you can accept.  A process control application is less critical obviously than a custody transfer service.

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

In natural gas metering &regulating stations, the orifice meter is always upstream of the pressure cut because it is more accurate to meter at higher pressures.  To illustrate, take a look at the orifice equation

Qh = C’√hwPf

Qh = Volumetric flow rate, cfh
C’ = Modified orifice constant
hw = Differential pressure, inches of water
Pf = Metering pressure, psia

Assume Pf is measured with a transducer that has an error of 1 psi.  A 1 psi error relative to Pf = 52 psia will introduce much more total error than a 1 psi transducer error relative to, say, Pf = 520 psia.  

There are requirements for upstream and downstream lengths unobstructed pipe or flow conditioning.  You should get a copy of AGA Report 3 for specifics.  By the way, control valves and regulators also have requirements for lengths of unobstructed pipe up and down stream.  Check the manufacturer’s specs.

The attached paper is pretty informative.
http://www.ceesi.com/docs_techlib/events/ishm1994/Docs/112.pdf

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

transducers have error as a percent of range.  A 1% error on a 0 to 2000 psi means 20 psi so put your 52 psia meter spanned to 0 to 2000 psia and 20/520 = ? meanwhile I'll put a 0 to 100 psia in on my 52 psia and be off 1/52.  Who wins now?

Oh and because pressure is under the radical, the error is is cut in half (approximately).

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

pipehead:

You must be a technician. Obviously my illustration was not intended for someone of your level of sophistication.  If you look at the illustration for what it is, an illustration, you will begin to understand why the natural gas industry installs orifice meters up stream of the pressure regulation.  It's not about winning.  

RE: POSITION OF THE ORIFICE AND THE CONTROL VALVE

Passage through a partially opened valve creates about the least developed flow profile possible. As a result, a long run of straight pipe would be required to return the flow pattern back to "fully developed". This is one of several reasons for generally preferring to have the flow measuring orifice upstream of the control valve.
Doug

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources