×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

(OP)
Hello,

I'm not quite an electrical engineer (YET! ;) but I do some of this as a hobby as I get my degree. I have a question I need assistance with, hope you can help me.

At my job we are working with magnetometers that are powered by a pack of 7 AA batteries (Rechargeable) encapsulated in a pack that has a 9v type connection to the circuit board. One of those devices is connected to a simple 9V rechargeable battery instead of the pack.

The batteries are at terrible shape (due to neglect and bad maintainance of the devices, mostly) and we are about to change them all. As the only person that knows half a thing about electrical currents and circuits, the job of choosing the replacements fell on me.

My question is this: Which type of rechargeable battery is better? The 9v or a pack of 7 AA ? which would hold out longer, or which would survive longer? Is there really a difference?

I apologize if I don't supply information that is relevant, I don't know much about batteries. If you need more information, please ask. I also apologize if this is in the wrong forum. Again, I'm doing this as a Hobby, and try to learn in the process.

Thank you very much,

Moriel

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Well, it time that you apply some engineering analysis to the problem.  

Assuming a constant energy density, would a larger volume produce more total energy?

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

As IR says.

I usually go from 9V to a set of AA. Not AAA.

AA has come to be THE battery used in most applications. It is THE battery that has a good combination of volume, capacity, price and longevity.

I even choose cameras and similar things based on batteries. If not AA, then I evaluate AA battery devices first.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

How many battery packs are you talking about changing? If it is tens of them then maybe you should look at a battery analyser/charger/ from somewhere like Cadex.

http://www.cadex.com/

You may be able to repair the batteries by a suitable charging method.

On the other hand, if the batteries are 5 years old you will get at least double the energy capacity by using new ones, simply because energy densities have improved dramatically in this period.

Comparing battery packs you need to compare run time, weight and cost. This will allow an informed decision.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Keep at the back of your mind that if these are NiCds, there is quite likely to be a difference in technology too.

Last time I was interested (at least a decade back, so treat with caution), PP3 sized NiCd were still mass plate technology, compared with AAA and bigger which had all moved on to a sintered construction.

The sintered technology tolerates much faster charging, and from what I can remember, had a better energy density.

A.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Batteries are rated in amp-hours (or more like mAH, milli-amp hours) to determine how long they will last.  For example, a typical alkaline AA cell has a 2700 mAH rating and a 9V has a 565 mAH rating so at the same current draw the AA will last over four times longer.  That is the specification you want to start with when deciding what battery architecture to use.  

Go to http://energizer.com/default_refresh.asp and check out the 'learning center' and 'technical info' pages.  

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

The disadvantage of a stacked battery like the common 9V is that you can't access an individual cell for diagnosis or electrical rejuvenation.  

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

One thing that I learned recently, is that 9V batteries are pretty much reserved for fire protection equipment, such as smoke detectors.  Apparently, this was written in to 'code' along the way.  The problem was that several years ago, when hand held video games that used 9V batteries became popular, kids were removing the batteries from devices such as smoke detectors to power their games.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

That's a pretty enterprising youngster to know that 1) a smoke detector uses a 9V battery, 2) he goes through the trouble of getting out a ladder to remove it, and 3) the parents don't realize something is up when they see their child screwing with the detector.  Maybe one kid did it and an urban legend was born?

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

On the other hand, Dan, youngsters tell each other about such things. Getting batteries for their games seems to be a constant problem - getting them for nothing is probably irresistable. And, also, given today's ceiling height, they do not need a ladder - only a stool or something. Kids aren't four feet tall for many years.

But, then again, the Urban Legend part of it is intriguing - anyone with first-hand information?

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

"...9V batteries....reserved....smoke detectors....written in to 'code'..."

Hmmm... Smells like an urban legend. Is there a reference anywhere?

9 volt batteries are still very commonly used in clock radios for back-up power.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

TV remotes were often 9V in years past, but I haven't seen one of those in years... pretty much AA/AAA these days.  As Bill said, I've only seen 9V in clock radios for backup, nothing else.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

9-volt batteries are still commonly used in the transmitters (and receivers) for inexpensive RC toy cars, etc.

If there is a world-wide ban on designing 9-volt batteries into anything other than smoke detectors, then I didn't get the memo... winky smile

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Ah, yes... Radio Shack is the world dominator for selling Taiwan-made RC toys that use 9V in the pistol grip-style transmitters.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

I would imagine the move to AAA batteries in things like remote controls has more to do with the low voltage components available today then the requirement not to use 9V batteries.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

My Fluke DVMs all use 9v batteries and my smoke alarms have a linked system which powers them from the alarm box.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Re. move to AAA. Remotes with space for a 9 V battery wouldn't be accepted today. AAA is a lot easier to fit in a thin unit.

Gunnar Englund
www.gke.org
--------------------------------------
100 % recycled posting: Electrons, ideas, finger-tips have been used over and over again...

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Check out www.batteryuniversity.com for lots of good information about batteries of all types.

If you go the AA or AAA route, it is best to have all the same type cell and all the same age/usage pattern.
Get all new cells and once you've assembled them into a battery pack, keep them together.  Don't mix old with new.

I'd avoid Nickel-Cadmium (NiCad) batteries.  Cadmium is nasty stuff.  Restricted in RoHS compliant countries.  Go with nickel metal hydride (NiMH).  They are less tolerant of over-charging than NiCad, but are environmentally much better.  You need a charger specifically designed to handle NiMH.  (It will also be able to charge NiCads if you must, but a NiCad charger can't necessarily charge NiMH safely, and may easily damage the battery or reduce their useful life.)

Also, dispose of your old batteries properly.  Recycle them.  Depending on where you are there may be businesses and organizations that will handle this.  Nickel is a valuable commodity these days and quite recycleable.  If you've got old NiCad batteries, cadmium is very bad for the environment.  Don't just dump them in the trash.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Re 9V for remotes:

It is much cheaper nowadays to build remotes that run on 2.8V than 9V (or whatever the '9V' batteries actually deliver at the end of life), so they use 2x1.5v batteries.

The world is always built the 'cheapest' way, when it comes to consumer products - therefore AA batteries replaced 9V units.

It has nothing to do with 'code' requirements - do you really think that Korean or Japanese electronic mfrs care what building codes are enacted in Wyoming or Pittsburg?

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

Quote:

It has nothing to do with 'code' requirements - do you really think that Korean or Japanese electronic mfrs care what building codes are enacted in Wyoming or Pittsburg?
They would if the majority of their product's market share was in the US.

Dan - Owner
http://www.Hi-TecDesigns.com

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

I mentioned the part about code requirements as that is what I was told.  The comment was made by the local fire chief.  I don't recall his exact words, but it was something to the effect of using 9V batteries only in fire protection and other 'monitoring' equipment.  To me this explains why they still exist in clocks, DVMs, etc.  

The idea behind his statements was that the use of 9V batteries was discouraged (if not prohibited) in devices that would encourage the average Joe or his offspring from removing the batteries by making them useless in most consumer electronics.  Granted, technical issues involving reduction in normal operating voltage may have helped.

RE: 9Volt vs. AA Recheargeable Batteries

SOMEONE has their history confused. 9V batteries were used exclusively in transistor radios up until fairly recently.  When the Japanese were touting the "3 transistor" radios, I didn't even have smoke alarm.

Walkie talkies, DVMs, RC transmitters all used 9V batteries.  The only reason that quad AAs are used is the poor current capacity of a 9V battery.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources