×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

(OP)
I noticed on a trip out to Las Vegas that all of the residential areas have homes with what looks like the air conditioning unit located on the roof.

Are these air conditioning units that I am seeign on the roofs of the houses?  If so why are they located there?

If not what are they? (Solar hot water heating???)

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Those are swamp coolers, evaporative cooling units (no heat).

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Some might be, but not all.  

The problem may be getting more efficiency out of the exchanger.  The ground is quite hot during the day and the air is generally stagnant.  Putting the exchanger 30 ft into the air may result in getting a better air flow and better efficiency.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

I thought it was just a matter of room and convenience?

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

A condenser only occupies about 6 sq. ft., hardly challenging, even with today's micro lots, not to mention the added weight and plumbing and power needed to facilitize such an installation.  There has to be a more engineering oriented requirement.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

My initial thoughts were similar to IRstuff's.

It might also be to get the coils away from wind-driven sand, which can be quite abrasive to aluminum fins.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

There are two things that motivate builders:  cheap and easy.  With a typical swamp cooler system, the return air duct for the heating system is used as the distribution ductwork for the evap air cooling.  Guillotine dampers are used seasonally to isolate the cooler from the RA header.  It saves a bunch of ductwork to put the cooler on the roof, as the heating RA duct is in the attic.

I believe in Las Vegas, most people have both a swamp cooler and a refrigerated air system.  The evap coolers give you cheap cooling up to the mid 90's, and the refrig system is used for truly hot days.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

I don't think having both a swamp cooler and a refrigerated air system on a house is commom. There would be too many people who would run them both on a hot day, not understanding how they work. With the huge latent load, they would literally be pouring money down the drain in the form of condensate.

On the other hand, I have seen the two systems mixed before on a dining facility. Evaporative cooling was used in the kitchen as make up air for the exhaust hoods, and the dining are was refrigerated air. The key is to maintain the kitchen at a negative pressure so the air from the evaporative cooler never gets to the AC coils.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

I've seen these too and I don't remember seeing any water piping.  I asked a friend who lives in Pheonix and he thought it was because most houses don't have basements.  That's where most furnaces (or fan coils) are located in Northern IL.  You never see residential rooftops here.  It's probably just the cheapest option since you have no refrigeration piping, etc.  Most of the units I saw were just "thrown" up on pitched roofs with cheap angle iron frames to level out the slopes.   

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Quote:

Most of the units I saw were just "thrown" up on pitched roofs with cheap angle iron frames to level out the slopes.  

The tell-tale sign of a swamp cooler on the roof is massive streaks of white salts running down the roof.  Did you see that?  If not, it definitely isn't a swamp cooler;  sooner or later they always overflow!  The stain is permanent too.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Roof top be hotter than the ground

Take the "V" out of HVAC and you are left with a HAC(k) job.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

make it harder for all the dried out compulsive gamblers to steal all the copper.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

It also may depend on the construction constraints.  No basements for fans etc. because it may be too expensive to excavate.  Closet mounted furnace/fan takes up floor space, so an attic or roof mounted unit that is out of the way may be their best solution, probably a pain in the butt the maintain for your regular homeowner though.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

Another interesting design constraint,
a local school has about 10 Carrier slimline units mounted on the roof, to stop the kids from kicking the condenser coils.
B.E.

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

The units seem to be mounted high for a number of reasons.  The blower section is often close by in the attic, limiting the piping run.  Setting the unit on the roof keeps it away from dust as well as give you some space back.  The unit sitting in the sun is the same on the roof as it is on the ground... not much efficiency difference in the dry heat of the southwest.  

And no they typically aren't 'swamp' type.  

In other regions many units are on the ground because the main coil & blower section is nearby in the basement.  

www.vanderweil.com

RE: Why are the heating/cooling units in the southwest located on the roof

those are usually heat pumps, done that way because its cheapest. you will also see whole subdivisions using split systems (condenser on a pad on the ground) sometimes it gets enclosed on 3 sides by house and a short L shaped wall, occasionally just by dumb luck its on the north side of the house. most home builders and buyers just don't care. a swamp cooler works great (PHX AZ. right now @ 1:18 PM -  109deg. 5% RH )   but you almost never see them in new homes. the people in those houses you saw are probably paying $300 +or- a month elec. bills this time of year.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources