×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
Wondering if anyone has experience with helo blade icing problems and some of the deicing sytems used?

Not allowed in the deicing solution;
1) heated wires on the blades, too much power and it can damage carbon fiber.
2) liquid deicing techniques stored on board, too much extra weight.

I've seen and read some ultrasonic solutions, seems like a direction to go. Or maybe plungers built into the forward edges.

Some thoughts my novice brain has;
1) Is the primary problem at initial starting, whereby ice has formed overnight or is it in flight ice buildup?
2) I realize that blades must be balanced, but do they start up an iced helo blade at low rev's to knock off ice, or do they need to be perfectly ice free to intialize the blades?
3) Are two different deicing systems needed,
a) inflight front edge of blades
b) preflight deicing of entire blade (once snow has been cleared)
4) If one was to modify and add a deicing system to the front of the blade, what's involved with modifying the blade? i.e. mechanical drilling, sealing, etc. I'd expect an entirely new blade design, test, etc....costly..

any thoughts would be appreciated, plus sources of info.
Thanks,


kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

-
2.  Starting with an unbalanced rotor sounds like a bad idea.
-

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

It's both.  You need to get the ice off to take off, but you'll also need to keep ice off during flight.

SAE AIR 1168-4 is part of an entire series of environmental design requirements, of which -4 is specific to icing, rain, fog, and frost.

There is an FAA Aircraft Icing Handbook that's downloadable from DTIC.  ADA238039, ...40, ...41 are the accession numbers for the 3 volumes.

ADA406321 is the Army Aircraft Icing tome by the Corps of Engineers' CRREL.

There are a few Army MIL specs regarding icing and deicing as well.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
Thanks IRStuff,
I'll take a look at the spec's.
 
I've read about heater wires, acoustical vibration and surface heaters.
One heating technique uses a thin sheet of ?resistive film probably insulated on mylar to require the smallest amount of heating power to make a full sheet of ice come off. This was developed by a professor Dartmouth College engineering professor Victor Petrenko. He has some interesting video's. I think it takes a bit of power for his heating though.

kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

If you can get the SAE 1168-4 volume, there's lots of detail on the amount of heat required, dictated by the air temperature, water content, and the airspeed.  

I'm more familiar with windshield deicing requirements, which for a 500 kt airspeed, requires about 4.26 W/in^2 to maintain anti-icing.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

1.  Both although I'd suspect on the ground could be mitigated by use of antifreeze spray.
2. Agree with Mike, as I said on the ground it may be possible to spray with antifreeze from an external source.
3.  Due to mass considerations I'd expect only one onboard system.
4.  Many systems would probably require a new blade though applying a film that can be heated might be retrofittable I suppose.

Unless it's what you mean by plungers I don't see you mention the pneumatic rubber boot, not sure if this is used on rotor blades though.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler
Have you looked at this?
 
Electro-impulse deicing
Kodet, A.C.
Southern Tier Technical Conference, 1988., Proceedings of the 1988 IEEE
Volume , Issue , 19 Oct 1988 Page(s):193 - 200
Digital Object Identifier   10.1109/STIER.1988.95479
Summary:Electro-impulse deicing (EIDI) which uses EM field induced eddy currents has been demonstrated to be an effective ice protection technology in various applications. The applications that EIDI has been demonstrated on by flight tests or icing wind-tunnel tests are the large transport aircraft, engine inlet, general aviation, business jets and commuter jets, and helicopter rotor blades. Various computer codes have been written for analyzing the pulse circuit, the electrodynamics, and structural response. It is concluded that EIDI is the only ice protection technology that has demonstrated potential in all market segments and does not impose the energy consumption penalties of present ice protection technologies

 
B.E.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
Haven't looked at EIDI, I'll read up.
Since that technology is 1988, one might guess it works but has drawbacks that stopped it from being widespread.

This requirement is for minimum power requirements.
Seems like impulse shock waves to fracture the ice is talked about using Piezoelectric shakers.

I was wondering if a laser mounted on the helo body would be able to cut slices in the ice on the bottom and edges, then with a small slot in the ice, the wind would to the rest. It may put a small slot in the blade too, which wouldn't be good.
On a similar thought, anything added to the body pointed upward would probably be attractive. Possibly focused sound waves to produce the shock remotely? Maybe a bank of high frequency acoustic transducers.

To minimize power use, the need is similar to switching power supplies, one blip of power, not continuous power.

KENAT, I think you're probably correct that on the ground a different system would be needed offboard. Thick ice is tough.

I'm on travel till the end of week in case I seem unresponsive.

Thanks for the thoughts.

kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Any laser that could melt ice is probably non-eyesafe and therefore a hazard to other aviators.

A possibility might be to heaterstrip only the leading edge of the blade

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler...

Icing [blade, engine, airframe, controls, LDG, etc] is not a simple subject. In-fact the complexity confounds experts.

Suggest going to the following websites and entering terms such as "icing", "aircraft and icing", "helicopter and icing", "engine and icing", etc.

http://stinet.dtic.mil/

http://www.airweb.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgAdvisoryCircular.nsf/MainFrame?OpenFrameSet

Special coatings, inflatable boots, electric heat, etc have been tried with varying success. The problem appears to revolve around the nature of the ice accumulation... and not only affects blades but aslo windows, airframes,  stabilizers, stub wings, stores, landing gear, etc... have fun in Your research.

Regards, Wil Taylor

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

I don't know if anyone has ever tried running compressor bleed to the blades. Granted, I can think of 5 or so technical difficulties involved, especially the sealing and routing of some kind of distribution manifold, but the big benefit is that you will always have CDP as long as you have operational engines. No extra power source required.

When I was on CH-47s, we didn't have any deicing capabilities once in flight. We deiced completely on the ground and then started up.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
Interesting thought, so if I interpret correctly, you'd be perforating the blades (maybe drilling some small holes) and adding an air pressure lines inside the blade. Air will break off the ice. Maybe have to have valves to control the air distribution.
I'd think the ice would seal the blade well. May take alot of air pressure to pop the ice. It'd be an interesting and easy experiment.
I could picture making the first crack in the ice, then maybe the air from other holes leaking out the original crack, unless that first crack sealed itself again. Short powerful bursts from many locations may work.
Thanks Fred,

kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Unless you've got doors on these puppies, the ice will go INTO the bleed channels and you've still not get any deicing.  And If you DO have doors, you won't be able to get the open once the blades ice over.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
A good bit of realism added IRStuff. Water does like to plug up holes.
Thanks.
I guess that's why they use air to inflate rubber pieces to crack the ice. No holes.

Maybe the available air pressure can be used, have the air move a small door that's slightly flexible. Maybe a plunger that's oring sealed can be moved using the air pressure.

kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler.
Compressor bleed air is usually warm, all you would have to do is run it up the D tube of the rotor and out the tip.
The major question is whether or not you could get enough warm air up the blade to de- ice from root to tip.
B.E.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

If the outlets are plugged, and there's no flow, there's no heat transferred, or at least not much, since you'll be counting strictly on thermal conductivity of air through a skinny channel from the compressor ALL the way up the rotor mast.  

Note also, the rotor mast will likewise be cold and the amount of actual heat that makes it up to the top strictly by conduction would be pretty miniscule.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies


RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
How warm is compressor bleed air? Do you mean hot?
 
Discussions I've read hint two solutions, in-flight vs. on ground solutions. In-flight ice is primarily on the front of the blades I believe. If warm air is circulated on the front edge of the blade, that may be enought to melt ice, especially if the air is hot and under alot of pressure. To Thermally isolate the front edge enough to heat it, there is probably a need to change the front edge. I've read that blades front edges get beaten up and the military would like some better designs. I wouldn't want to presume that redesigning a forward edge of the carbon fiber blade that is nicely insulated (for hot air injection) is an easy task. I read that the hot wires added for melting ice does some damage to the blade.


kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

CDP temperature and pressure varies from engine to engine. It is extremely warm and pressure is usually pretty high (800°F and 400 psi perhaps). I was actually thinking more along the lines of a radiant system that would not have external hole features. It would simply have an internal circuit that the flow would heat the entire blade surface via conduction.

However, thinking of electrical pitot heating, in many flights that is turned on and left on. If you did perforate the surface with holes, once the flow is started on the ground, I can not see them getting plugged as long as flow is maintained.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler (Electrical)
I had forgotten that you are using a carbon fiber rotor blade. I was thinking in terms of an aluminum blade where the metal would conduct heat.
B.E.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler...

IF You are truly serious regarding helo blade icing issues, then You need to "mix and learn with the big-boys".

There is a MAJOR SAE conference coming up in Seville Spain Sept 24--27 2007: "SAE 2007 Aircraft & Engine Icing International Conference".

The technical sessions appear to be very indepth... and it is likely that every major "player" in the fixed and rotary wing world with have attendees. These are THE folks worth knowing!

The notice and detailed info is available at the following website:   www.sae.org/icing

Regards, Wil Taylor

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
I wish I could go to Spain. I'd like to see where the rain mainly falls. It would require a plane trip.
Kevin
PS: Been on travel alot lately.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

I still think the bleed air (or exhaust gas) has merit.  Simply leave proviles for air to move close to the surface, spanwise to the tip.  

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Holes and hoses accumulate water, which once frozen, requires a heater.  Gee, weren't we here already?

For those non-believers, we had a system that sat on the mast of various ships.  The system constantly accumulated water INSIDE the housing, just through simply respiration through its so-called "seals."  One time, we got up to 5 inches of standing water, supposedly accumulated over the course of several months.  Had nighttime temps dropped below freezing, we would have had a literal frozen popsicle.

TTFN

FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

What about hydrophobic coatings, e.g., Teflon®?
If not durable enough on its own, some rotor bladea with aluminum leading edges are hard anodized, and the anodizing can be Teflon®-impregnated.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
We researched hydophobic coatings for shipboard radomes. The US Navy didn't like the 6 month re-application timetable so they nixed it. I don't think we discussed ice formation.

I would think it would work pretty well if it could handle the air pressure, but I'd guess it couldn't handle it. As it was described to me, hydrophobic coatings are put on in two steps. The resultant surface is close to a "tiny bed of nails" whereby the water balls up on the nails since it can't run down between the nails due to surface tension (wonder if surface tension of water is less at higher altitudes). Anyhow, I'd picture the super high wind force would rip off the coating on the front edge of the surface, but maybe it could handle it on the top, bottom and back of the rotor. Since that material has been around for awhile, I'd expect someone has tried it. Good thought though, I'll take a look at it on the web and see how tough it is.
Thanks,
kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Higgler...

Suggest you review SAE AIR 1667A "Rotor Blade Electrothermal Ice Protection Design Considerations".

Regards, Wil Taylor

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

(OP)
Thanks, I'll take a look wktaylor. The present requirement looks for a minimum of power required, hence the recent discussion.

kch

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

There is a "anti-ice" system, known as TKS, that 'weeps' a glycol solution thru thousands of tiny holes in the leading edge of the wing. Note this is an "anti-ice" system, as opposed to a "de-ice" system, in that it must be actuated before entering icing. I think it was developed in the UK, and was first used on the Hawker series of business jets. It is also used on the Citation 550 SII , and on the single engine Cirrus aircraft. I suppose one could design a 'slinger ring' device to get it to the blades, tho It makes a hellava mess when operating.

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

Folks..

An interesting Article in the Seattle Post-inteligencer follows...

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/business/1310AP_Water_repellent_Coatings.html

Last updated June 27, 2007 9:18 p.m. PT

Water-repellent coatings hold promise
THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

AUSTIN, Texas -- Aircraft that won't accumulate ice while awaiting winter takeoff. Engine parts with self-cleaning capabilities to boost efficiency. Even automobiles or toilet bowls that require little to no washing. All could be commonplace someday if ongoing research proves successful into "superhydrophobic" - or extremely water-repellent - coatings that are durable enough for metal and ceramics. The idea is that moisture will simply bead up and roll off, picking up dirt particles along the way.

The opportunities are "pretty incredible," said Margaret L. Blohm, who manages the nanotechnology program at the General Electric Co. research arm.

GE's coatings, tentatively expected to be ready for commercialization in five years or so, will probably first target the energy and aviation industries, Blohm said. Other scientists engaged in similar research believe consumer-oriented uses - think self-cleaning cars - aren't too far off, either.

There's little doubt the market for such technology could be lucrative, if it can live up to the early hype.

The aviation industry, for instance, spends large sums to remove ice from airplanes and render them safe for flying. AMR Corp. unit American Airlines alone pays more than $10 million annually for deicing fluid and another $1 million for employee training, according to the company, figures that don't include equipment or lost time and fuel.

But ice wouldn't adhere to an airplane wing finished with a thin, "superhydrophobic" coating.

"We think (GE's effort) offers great promise if in fact it can be applied to aircraft," said Basil Barimo, vice president of the Air Transport Association, a trade group that represents major carriers. "I'm sure the airlines would love to get out of the deicing business."

Blohm said it's too early to estimate the price for such coatings, although she noted that GE's goal is to make them cost-effective for customers.

Research into so-called "hydrophobicity" - or the properties of water repellence - has been focusing for the most part on the surface structure of the lotus, an Asian plant that retains a pristine appearance despite thriving in muddy waterways.

Among other things, the texture of the plant's surface, which consists of microscopic "hills and valleys," creates a thin layer of air that prevents full contact with water or dirt. As a result, water rolls off its leaves, taking the dirt with it.

In recent years, various long-lived coatings have been developed that are modeled after the structure. Products incorporating such technology range from new lines of spill-resistant clothing to house paint dubbed as self-cleaning.

But duplicating the lotus structure for use on steel and other metals has been more problematic.

For one, metal is naturally "hydrophilic," meaning moisture tends to slide, or smear, on it instead of beading up. Metal also is difficult to mold because of its high melting point.

In addition, metal and ceramics often are deployed in extreme conditions - as an engine part, for instance - so any suitable finish must be exceptionally durable.

Fairfield, Conn.-based GE has had success in the lab formulating lotus-style coatings for metal and ceramics and has a number of patents pending, Blohm said, although she declined to reveal precise details of the technology.

Other researchers doing similar work have reported strides as well. C.P. Wong, a scientist at the Georgia Institute of Technology, said his effort to develop a titanium-based "superhydrophobic" coating for use over steel is showing substantial promise.

But both Wong and Blohm said increasing the durability of their respective techniques remains key.

"Durability is the most important aspect for commercial applications," Wong said.

Tentatively, Blohm estimated that GE's initial coatings will last 10 years on the outside before needing to be reapplied or replaced in some fashion. She also considers the most viable early uses for GE's coatings to be those in which "the robustness requirements are less severe."

Examples she cited include gas turbines, in which certain internal parts experience minimal wear but would gain a substantial improvement in efficiency from a self-cleaning capability.

Likewise, such coatings would be valuable to the aircraft industry even if minor chips or worn spots developed over time and left tiny ice patches on planes, she said.

Barimo, of the Air Transport Association, concurred.

"It doesn't have to be a perfect solution, where the aircraft is always pristine," said Barimo, who was familiar with GE's effort. "Even if it just trims a little time off the deicing process ... there are benefits there."

GIT's Wong said he's already been contacted by some interested manufacturers, and he contends that the days of self-cleaning toilets, solar panels or automobiles are a mere two to three years away.

Still, Wong acknowledged he has plenty of work left to do.

"You have to use a lot of really tough materials," he said. "If you lose the durability or the appearance, you'll lose the customer interest."

Regards, Wil Taylor

RE: Helicopter blade deicing ideas

I'm always suspicious of such "forward looking statements".

On the other hand, you could just try a little Rain-X.

Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources