×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

480V vs. 600V systems

480V vs. 600V systems

480V vs. 600V systems

(OP)
I was wondering if there are any advantages/disadvantages to useing each of these input voltages ie) power saving, less heat, less chance of faults? Thanks

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

In theory 600 V system will be more efficient and have fewer losses.  For the same kVA, smaller wire sizes can be used, voltage drop will be less of a concern.  There is really not much theoretical advantage to 480 V over 600 V, since 600 V insulation is used for both.  

In practice, the differences are not huge and the decision is largely driven by local custom and compatibility with existing equipment.  In the US, there are not many 600 V systems, while it is much more common in Canada.  

If everyone was starting over, we'd probably go with 600 V.  

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

(OP)
Are 600 volt systems more dangerous though when we are using these systems in hazardous areas with ignition sources.  Just because your dealing with a larger voltage or does that not make a difference?

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

The main advantage of higher voltage 600V vs. 480V is lower current for the same amount of power meaning less cabling and conductors. I am currently doing a project that is utilizing 600V distribution within the facility because of the power requirements. The draw back though has been there is less equipment options for 600V than at 480V which is more common. Also depending on the loads 600V systems may require installtion of more transformers. For systems that have large connected load I would recommend using a MV distribution system (ie 5kV and up)

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

480 Volt equipent is more common and easier to get ( in most places).  
IF your going to carry a good supply of spares or in an area where there are other facillities with 600 volt systems -no porblem.

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

No there is no additional danger in using 600V vs 480V in hazardous areas. Once you go over about 10V, the difference in voltage is irrelevant in terms of ignition.

Bottom line, if you are in Canada, 600V is OK because there are a lot of other 600V users there. If you are in most of the US, it will be problematic in terms of finding motors, drives, lighting fixtures etc. In fact with lighting, using a 480Y277V 4 wire system has advantages in that you can use 1 phase to neutral for much of your lighting equipment because lots of manufacturers provide 277V ballasts. With 600V, you need to buy a transformer to run your lighting systems in most cases, and transformers cost money plus drop efficiency. There are a few ballast manufacturers now selling 347V ballasts in the US, but again, limited options.

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

I have been told that the impedance and 'other' aspects make 600V systems more likely to burn via sustained low current arcs.  I was then pointed to a job our company did for El Paso Gas (controlling transmission valves) where our stuff was incinerated along with everything else when a 600V arc started in a piece of equipment then burned back down 300 feet of conduit into an equipment room toasting everything within 6-8 feet of the 600V cabling.  It was before my time, with that company, so I don't have personal experience with that disaster.  Is there any truth to this 600V arc tenacity? It might relate to the OPs question.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

Wouldn't XFMRs with 600 VAC secondaries be more expensive since 480 VAC is so much more common, or is 600 VAC common enough that there is no premuim charge there?

JB

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

For hazardous areas, I guess don't see any difference and the codes make no distinction.  You can blow yourself up with 50 V in the right mixture of gases.  

Arcing faults could be another matter.  It's an interesting question.  I suspect 480 V might actually be worse for arcing faults since the 277V is right in the sweet spot for a self-sustaining arc that just keeps going and going.  Both 480 V and 600 V having arcing ground fault issues that have to be dealt with.  But there have been hundreds and hundreds of fires started by 480 V ground faults so I doubt that any differences are really dramatic.  600 V is used widely in the pulp and paper mills in Canada and even in the US.  

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

... and a number of textile mills in the Southeast.

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

(OP)
So why then do they use 480volts in Oil Fields and 600 in manufacturing industry?

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

camfink;  See JBinCA's response.  Oil fields are often seat-o-the-pants operations relying on local supplies for hardware.  460 is way more likely to be found on a local shelf because of the 230/460 relationship lacking with 600.

Keith Cress
Flamin Systems, Inc.- http://www.flaminsystems.com

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

(OP)
Great thanks a lot for the help guys

RE: 480V vs. 600V systems

Hi itsmoked.
I think that the sustained arcing issue is more an issue of improper protection rather than 480V/600V. I have seen pictures of similar damage caused by a sustained arc on 480 volts.
Such incidents are probably the driving incentive behind the NEC and CEC requirements for ground fault protection on large services and feeders.  (CEC=Canadian Electrical Code for those of you in California)
respectfully

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources