20' high basement wall and diaphragm
20' high basement wall and diaphragm
(OP)
Basement walls of 20’ in height
Residential
IBC 2006 North Carolina
Paragraph 1610.1 “Basement walls and other wall in which horizontal movement is restricted at the top shall be designed for at rest pressure”
Exception basement nor more than 8’ below grade with flexible floor
Similar wording in previous code
Table 1601.1 for most sandy types of backfill has an at rest pressure of 60 psf
For reinforced masonry with 12” CMU that puts a limit at about 12’ with 11’ of backfill.
If you go to concrete then the wall is possible but the resultant at the top is app 2100#/ft.
With a typical ¾” plywood floor as a diaphragm the plywood is overloaded.
Any ideas on how you have solved such a situation
Residential
IBC 2006 North Carolina
Paragraph 1610.1 “Basement walls and other wall in which horizontal movement is restricted at the top shall be designed for at rest pressure”
Exception basement nor more than 8’ below grade with flexible floor
Similar wording in previous code
Table 1601.1 for most sandy types of backfill has an at rest pressure of 60 psf
For reinforced masonry with 12” CMU that puts a limit at about 12’ with 11’ of backfill.
If you go to concrete then the wall is possible but the resultant at the top is app 2100#/ft.
With a typical ¾” plywood floor as a diaphragm the plywood is overloaded.
Any ideas on how you have solved such a situation






RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Given that, I would still design the diaphragm to take some load from the wall for some possible surcharge or soil saturation after the diaphragm is in place.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
I have suggested a concrete floor at either the 10' level or the 20' level but none of my clients ever want to pay for that.
apparently they find someone that comes up with a design because I never hear from them again and I never check out what someone else may have designed. I have seen CMU wall that High and are standing but I wouln't do it.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Just design it like a tank with counterforts at long span and your footing and wall thickness wont be too crazy.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
bylar-
is the basement 20' high or are you using CMU for the entire height of the house? The OP seemed like the basement had a 20' high ceiling, but your last post seems like it is a 10' (or less for framing) basement ceiling and the CMU continues to the second floor. Which one is correct?
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Go here for the thread:
thread507-184078: Cantilever retaining wall or not?
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Yes it is a walk out basement with both side wall masnry or concrete.
I have already considered the sliding effect.
To me the only solution is have a concrete floor at either the 10' or the 20' elevation.
I don't believe a retaining wall is practical.
I feel somewhat confident in I analysis of the situation but I have seen it done with simple reinforced masonry and even though the walls are in tact and still standing I do not believe it complys with the chapter 16 that I originaly stated.
I had looked at the sited thread before I even posted mine but the conditons are not th same.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
If you consider it to be a cantilevered wall, the big downsides are:
1. The wall (cip concrete for sure) and footing will be huge. Answer: too bad. It is what it is. They don't like the other option of installing a concrete diaphragm.
2. The wall will deflect later on and possibly damage your diaphragm or other LFRS elements.
Why not bite the bullet and cantilever the wall? Deal with Item 2 with detailing.
Depending on your situation, the total wall deflection would be 0.8" to 1.0" according to the various CRSI cases. Try to figure out how much of this should occur later on, after the diaphragms are installed. It might not be enough to spit at. Detail your system to handle the deflection. It might not be that hard to do.
What kind of backfill and drainage system are you planning to use? I know I'd feel better about it if I had granular backfill going back at an angle, plus a drain at the bottom. I'd be a lot more scared with clay behind the wall.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Many markets routinely stock 14" and 16" units. The 16" units can be very efficient if partially reinforced/grouted since they allow a very thick wall with slightly less material.
You can also use higher strength units. Many producers only stock one or two different strengths, but other may be produced. A f'm=3000 psi can easily be obtained. I have seen f'm=4800 psi hollow 8" prisms made with block having a 8000 psi net compressive strength.
You may have a difficult time finding a testing laboratory capable of testing without severely cutting the samples down.
This information does not address the actual design concept and analysis of the deflection and floor/wall interaction. It does, however, point out that there are many materials possible.
With the substantial horizontal loads, it is unfortunate that the hollow core plank could not be used economically to maintain consistant long term material properties and not rely on a wood diaphragm.
Dick
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Are you talking about designing the wall as a twoway slab?
I haven't tried that yet but it seem that I did that several years ago and came up with results a lot greater than what you did.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
To veteran structural engineers out there, do you think my approach is good? The PE I work for liked it and stamped my work. Am I taking too much risk for not worrying how much load is taken by the diaphragm and design the wall to stand without the the diaphragm?
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
The IRC requires that the basement slab be a minimum of 3.5" and poured directly abutting the foundation wall and on top of the footing.
You can use this to provide sliding reisistance if necessary (unless you have a big pool in the basement).
Dick
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
I would imagine in a daylight basement, the slab wouldn't offer much sliding resistance.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
It all depends on what direction you are talking about. A concrete slab 3.5" inches or more thick can offer significant diaphragm action in both direction, but may depend on the geometry. It is a very handy and predictable engineering tool.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
I agree, with the right geometry it may work.
But, the reactions at the ends of the concrete diaphragm will be very large for 20' retained height. Plus, you would have to provide dowels from the floor slab into the side walls or footings, which I've never seen.
Most of the houses I deal with that have daylight basements are much longer in the direction perpendicular to the slope, so the diaphragm becomes very long.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
Diaphragm action? Do you dowel the slab to the side walls? Do you provide a reinforced slab with no control joints?
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
What I have done in the past (Cashiers, Brevard, Asheville) is design a segmental retaining wall outside of the foundation wall. I place 4' between the two, and provide a walkway to the residence. This makes it into a tall foundation wall. The bottom of the segmental wall is near the bottom of your bldg footing, however, you do have to take the resultant force of your segmental wall, and place it on whatever backfill you still have against your foundation wall. Usually is not too big a deal. Just be careful with your slope stability. Use Mesa Wall for your analysis as it will do a global check for you. Call out for verification with a geotechnical engineer in your general notes.
I, personally, think it is a brilliant idea. However, I can't take credit for it as I initially saw it done at a house in Hendersonville, before I decided to incorporate it. I don't know who the engineer was for that house, however, I owe him (her) a big thanks!
Chip
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
We do have a basement flooor of concret and it offers some friction resistance and I design it as deep beam and dowel into the side walls. Again I have to dowel the side walls into the rock. Those items all work but my original question was using the code requirements of 60 psf earth load is there anyway that plywood diaphragms from the floor will work. My answer is no and that it has to be a concrete floor but I respect the ideas of those active on this site.
RE: 20' high basement wall and diaphragm
The sliding resistance you've provided makes sense. As for the plywood floor, I agree that there's no way to make it work...Unless you design the wall as cantilevered (with counterforts?) and backfill first, or build a segmental wall in front (if possible) as Chip suggested. I guess it comes down to the cost of building the large retaining wall vs. the cost of two concrete floors and the beefed up framing required to support these floors.