×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Determining Vertical Curve Length???

Determining Vertical Curve Length???

Determining Vertical Curve Length???

(OP)
My basic question is: What determines the curve length that you need to use for two intersection tangents.  Also does wheel base of the design vehicle relate at all to this?

Here is my problem in more detail:
I am designing and entrance to a parking lot at a park.  The entrance comes off of a state highway and has an acceleration and deceleration lane.  It is a pretty steep entrance unfortunately but our only option.  My tangents coming in go from 3%(cross-slope of the accel/decel lanes) to a 12.5% then back to 8 then 5 then 2 (drive goes around a curve then to handicapped accessible parking area).  I currently have and unequal tangent curve at the entrance because I only have about 15' max before I have to drop to a 12.5% tangent from the 3%.  I am concerned that the curve length is two short.  The drive will also be the construction entrance that I am going to need to get cement trucks and other machinery down(and garbage trucks upon project completion).  How can I ensure that the drive is accessible to these vehicles?  Redesign of the horizontal alignment & layout is not an option.

ANY help woudl be much appreciated!!!!!

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

(OP)
Some additional info:  I basically need to drop 18 feet in 200 ft.  the last 80 or 90 feet are also a 90 degree turn so I want to make that a bit shallower.  the way I have it now I have 13'2" of 3% off of the edge of the accel/decel lane and 36'10" of 12.5%.  So my total curve length (unequal tangent) is 50 feet.  Would it be better to make it more equal and make the secont tangent steeper?

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

Vertical curve lengths are determined by sight distance.  L = KA where A is the algebraic difference in grades and K is a constant determined by the design speed and ultimately sight distance.

Guidelines for vertical curves are pretty clear in the Green Book, and which ever authority will be taking ownership of the road will have their own set of regulations.  Usually maximum grades in very low speed subdivision roads are 10% or 12%, with variances sometimes allowed up to 15%, however steep grades are discouraged with horizontal curves.  If you have an intersection in there, then typical maximum grades for very low speed roads are 5% and the subdivision I'm working on now it is 2% for 100'.

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

The Green Book is "Geometric Design of Streets and Highways", published by AASHTO.  They also have a publication "Geometric Design of Very Low-Volume Local Roads (ADT < 400)".  The State highway department shoul have geometric design guidelines you could use, but make sure they are for local roads, not state highways.

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

Lndsn

The Green Book addresses vertical curves in terms of design speed and sight distance while traveling along the curve.  This does not really apply at a site entrance, since there is usually a stop condition leaving, and a low speed entering.  

While having a transition that is as smooth as possible is desirable, I believe in the situation described, ground clearance is the main design factor.

I suggest you plot the profiles of the roads...then create a block of your design vehicle and check clearances on the profile.

Some places do have guidance on maximum grade differences and distances at entrances, so check entrance guidelines.

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

(OP)
I'm sorry I am pretty new to this.  What is the Green Book?

Also, TerryScan - you are right, because of the accel/ decel lanes, I'm not very concerned about sight distances.  I just want to ensure easy of access.  And I don't want any vehicles bottoming-out. I have done what you suggested with the profile, but cannot find any data on ground clearance for certain vehicles only wheel base.  Any suggestions?

Also, is there anywhat to get plain old AutoCAD to produce a parabola through specific points?  The best that I can think of is to use spline and the adjust it so the actual line goes through my points offset from my tangent.

Thanks!!

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

You have over specified the problem which makes a solution unfindable.  Either give yourself more distance for the vertical curve or limit the access to short whellbase vehicles.  A graphical solution of the limits of wheelbases able to access your drive is a easily developed when a section of the 15" VC goes from -3% to -12.5% is shown.  Make a template of truck wheelbase with 11" clear at the center between axles and place on VC.

RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

Lndsn,

I recently did a similar analysis.  I thought of a vehicle that I have know to have issues with ground clearance - the corvette.  I found specs including ground clearance using a web search (ended up at www.caranddriver.com).

To draw the VC, I use a civil add-on to Autocad (Carlson Civil 2007 - a Land Desktop alternative).

One could calculate points every 5-10' along the VC and connect them..or find another add-on that will draw it.


RE: Determining Vertical Curve Length???

For drawing vertical curves (parabolas) in AutoCAD I found the following tip which appears to be correct:

"Vertical curves are parabolas, you can draw them by drawing a polyline from endpoint to VPI to endpoint, then PEDIT>>Spline. For it to be a proper parabola, set SPLINETYPE to 5 before pediting, and to get a smooth curve set SPLINESEGS to 15 or higher. (Thanks to rc McSwain for the Spline/parobola info)."

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources